Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Rethinking the American Union for the Twenty-First Century Hardcover – February 1, 2012
New from Michael Savage
Michael Savage reveals why we have an infected political system, and what we can now do to nurse the country back to health. Learn more
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
From the Inside Flap
In this thought-provoking collection, editor Donald Livingston presents seven essays addressing the modern paradigm of centralization. An outgrowth of the Abbeville Institute Scholars' Conference held in Charleston, South Carolina in February of 2010, this collection presents an exploration of state nullification, secession, and the human scale of political order. Scholars from a variety of backgrounds delve into such complex issues as nationalism, government by judiciary, the effects of size on the republican tradition, and natural progressions in rethinking nationalistic government.
By returning to original source materials, including the Constitution, the essayists clarify topics as diverse as the source of nationalism and influences of early political figures, the role of size in government, and the disintegration of the Soviet Union with parallels evident in the United States.
The essays provide clear evidence of the centralized government's ongoing power struggle with individual states. They offer concise justification for immediate action to preserve the sovereignty of member states while protecting all citizens from the ever-expanding federal government and restrictions on freedoms. As a collective, they provide a modern cautionary tale for the twenty-first century.
About the Authors
Editor Donald Livingston is an emeritus professor of philosophy at Emory University. He is the president of the Abbeville Institute, an organization of higher education devoted to the study of what is true and valuable in Southern tradition.
Kent Masterson Brown is a practicing attorney who has argued cases in constitutional law before the Supreme Court and in several state supreme courts.
Dr. Marshall DeRosa is a professor of political science at Florida Atlantic University and the author of several books on politics and the Confederate constitution.
Dr. Thomas DiLorenzo is a professor of economics at Loyola University Maryland and a senior faculty member of the Ludwig von Mises Institute. His articles have been published widely in academic journals and major newspapers.
Kirkpatrick Sale is the author of twelve books and director of the Middlebury Institute for the study of separatism, secession, and self-determination.
Yuri Maltsev received a doctorate from the Institute of Labor Research in Moscow, Russia and served on the senior team of Soviet economists on Gorbachev's economic reform programs. He is a professor of economics at Carthage College and has lectured around the world.
Rob Williams is the editor and publisher of Vermont Commons: Voices of Independence, an independent multimedia news journal. He is also professor of media/communications at Champlain College.
From the Back Cover
Is the United States simply too big to govern? These essays begin the discussion.
In 2003 Donald Livingston and a group of academics formed the Abbeville Institute, an organization of higher learning dedicated to a scholarly study of what is true and valuable in the Southern tradition. In 2010 the Institute sponsored a conference to focus on "State Nullification, Secession and the Human Scale of Political Order." Scholars from across the political spectrum came together to examine the unwieldy political strategy of centralization and the resultant expanding scale of government. This collection of essays grew out of that discourse, providing fresh insights at a time when the nineteenth-century nationalistic language of "one and indivisible" is losing its salience.
Kent Masterson Brown demonstrates that the Constitution ratified in 1789 was, and is, a compact between distinct political societies.
Marshall DeRosa reviews the current revival of states' rights in the Tea Party movement.
Thomas DiLorenzo examines the transformation of a federative constitution grounded in state sovereignty into a nationalist constitution in which the central government defines the limits of its own power through judicial review.
Donald Livingston explores the question of size, scale, and true republican government in historic context.
Yuri Maltsev brings forth the modern secessionist example, discussing in depth the peaceful separation of fifteen states from the Soviet Union and the lessons to be learned by thoughtful Americans.
Kirkpatrick Sale seeks to raise awareness that the republican values of self-government and rule of law cannot exist unless certain conditions of size and scale are satisfied, while questioning what the optimum size should be.
Rob Williams examines secession as it exists today, providing a substantive history of the movement and its introduction into the mainstream discussion of runaway centralization.
Top Customer Reviews
If there is an overarching thesis of the book, it may be found in the following words from Livingston, in his introduction. The essays in the book are "efforts to rethink the philosophical, political, moral, and constitutional assumptions that have led us to think that size and scale do not matter in political things and that have produced a regime suffering from elephantitis, with little understanding of its condition and even less inclination to seek such understanding" (p. 23).
Here are the chapter titles:
Introduction: "The Old Assumptions No Longer Apply" (Donald Livingston)
Chapter 1: "Secession: A Constitutional Remedy that Protects Fundamental Liberties" (Kent Masterson Brown)
Chapter 2: "The Founding Fathers of Constitutional Subversion" (Thomas DiLorenzo)
Chapter 3: "The Tenth Amendment Awakening, the Supreme Court Be Damned (Marshall DeRosa)
Chapter 4: "American Republicanism and the Forgotten Question of Size" (Donald Livingston)
Chapter 5: "'To the Size of States There is a Limit': Measurements for the Success of a State" (Kirkpatrick Sale)
Chapter 6: "Too Big to Fail? Lessons from the Demise of the Soviet Union" (Yuri Maltsev)
Chapter 7: "Most Likely to Secede: U.S.Read more ›
In particular, Professor Livingston's article about the "scale" of government is an eye-opener. This notion of scale may very well end up as the best chance the "Liberty Movement" possesses to offer an alternative to the national government now occupying Washington DC. However, before the solution can be properly understood, it is important to understand how the national (vs. federal) government came to being. Professor Livingston and the other academics in this book provide the answers. Uncomfortable truths indeed! If you care about liberty and fear the explosion of national government control over our lives, this is a MUST read!"
The book was an enjoyable read with a good amount of end notes where one can consult for further research. There is an adequate index, but no bibliography. I highly recommend this book for those who are worried about a centralized, impersonal government. This book gives tips on how to truly reform government. Five stars.
Donald Livingston, editor and essayist, notes that their question is posed at a time when "Many political, business, and cultural elites are shifting their allegiance away from their nation-states to supranational entities."
Livingston notes, however, that George Kennan, architect of U.S. policy to contain the Soviet Union, argues that the U.S. has become too big for the purposes of self-government. The U.S. now rules more than 305 million people, by imposing one-size-fits-all rules, which result in a "diminished sensitivity of its laws and regulations to the particular needs, traditions, ethnic, cultural, linguistic, and the like of individual localities. "
Size, Kennan says, has encouraged an abstract ideological style of politics that favors universalistic, egalitarian solutions applied across the board to all parts of the population. "Particularly is this true of the United States, with its highly legalistic traditions, its dislike...of any sort of discriminating administration, its love for dividing people into categories, its fondness for regulating their lives in terms of these categories and treating them accordingly, rather than looking at the needs of individuals or of smaller groups and confronting these on the basis of common sense and reasonable discrimination.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Wonderful collection of Essay's on "Big Government and Secession". I think everyone should read this.Published 5 months ago by Acarroll
Excellent collection of essays recalling the founding of the republic and the future of Liberty.Published 6 months ago by Amazon Customer
My only criticism is that there is no Kindle edition of this book, because it seems made for copious annotation of the sort that Kindle excels at. Read morePublished 15 months ago by Michael St James
A fascinating read for anyone interested in the theories of government, democracy, or republic formation and maintenance. Read morePublished 22 months ago by Paul Gebolys
What a great book. It contains seven essays addressing the problems of Modern Centralized Government. Read morePublished 22 months ago by Gerry Kevil
Content question for all previous reviewers.
Do these essays discuss and/or analyze any of the issues below for their Influence on U.S. Read more
Mixed reviews. It IS a collection of essays and the essays differ widely in accuracy and quality. One author/contributor seemed unaware of the differences between... Read morePublished on August 20, 2014 by Dr Markway
The American Empire is over. No sane person can argue otherwise. The only question that remains is what happens to the geographical area known as the United States? Read morePublished on April 5, 2014 by whitebuffalo