- File Size: 708 KB
- Print Length: 289 pages
- Publisher: W. W. Norton & Company (June 6, 2011)
- Publication Date: June 6, 2011
- Sold by: Amazon.com Services LLC
- Language: English
- ASIN: B003R7L90I
- Text-to-Speech: Enabled
- Word Wise: Enabled
- Lending: Not Enabled
- Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #58,917 Paid in Kindle Store (See Top 100 Paid in Kindle Store)
The Shallows: What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains Kindle Edition
Use the Amazon App to scan ISBNs and compare prices.
- Highlight, take notes, and search in the book
- In this edition, page numbers are just like the physical edition
- Length: 289 pages
- Word Wise: Enabled
- Enhanced Typesetting: Enabled
- Page Flip: Enabled
Switch back and forth between reading the Kindle book and listening to the Audible book with Whispersync for Voice. Add the Audible book for a reduced price of $7.49 when you buy the Kindle book.
|New from||Used from|
The Amazon Book Review
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Customers who bought this item also bought
From Bookmarks Magazine
Would you like to tell us about a lower price?
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
It becomes this obsession, small bits of human contact, mediated by the computer.
"This person likes what you wrote", digital pats on they back, they become addictive.
I am five days clean from reddit.com. I've used drugs, no drug I've tried is as addictive as social media. The first day my entire body hurt. I just wanted to check my posts, refresh the front page. I knew it would be hard, I didn't know it would make me suicidal.
I kept having these thoughts about missing out. How would I know the absolute latest information about the Las Vegas shooter? Even with a NYTimes subscription I felt left out.
The endless conversations, arguments, quips. It feels like a huge extended family.
I get why. It amplifies our conversations to make them seem outsized, but no one is really reading. It's non-stop entertainment. My views were never seriously challenged. Any belief, no matter how strange, a group is waiting to accept you.
I want more real life friends and I can tell a reliance on the Internet has stunted my ability to relate to people in the real world.
I'm getting over an addiction, now the work of living begins.
At the same time that the Internet is changing the world, bringing us closer together around masses of information, it is changing our ability to think and it is changing our brains in dangerous ways. The issue is not the content of the Internet, but its process.
The human adapts to its tools and its tasks. Give a man a hammer for a lifetime’s work and his body shapes to effectively drive nails. Take away his pen and give him a typewriter with a ball and his prose turns from fluid to staccato. (That happened to Nietzsche in the late nineteenth century.) In that process of adaption the brain, since it is not a machine but an organ, changes. These changes can be seen with instruments and their results observed in human behavior. This is the world of Nicholas Carr.
I will describe a tiny fraction of what the Internet is doing to our brains.
1) The brain, confronted with a glowing screen and the ability to hypertext its way from one interruption to another across the universe of knowledge from what its buddy in Australia thinks of rutabagas, to the spelling of rutabagas to the history of rutabagas to dishes that can be prepared from rutabagas leaves the brain sliding from one fact of surface interest to another fact even less useful, until it occurs to the brain to pursue the prompt on the pop-up menu and check the weather and get off of this slide onto the weather channel where a five minute video on playful seals on San Francisco Bay can be watched for free which does remind the brain that it could slide over to Facebook and find out if anyone “liked” the picture of the family cat posted an hour ago. And many do. Twenty-three “likes,” praise the Lord.
Just as the carpenter’s arm grew it muscles to deal effectively with the hammer the brain changes to succeed in a slippy slidey world of itty bitty bits of knowledge intended to interest momentarily and then disappear.
So what will happen when it confronts a life choice? Will this passive instrument skidding from meaningless bit to another meaningless bit see itself suddenly as an agent? A “decider?” Or will it in panic seek the next button to push, even if that button bears the label “Self Destruct?”
According to Time magazine this is happening now in the Silicon Valley high schools; kids depressed and without a sense of agency pushed around by the ripples on the surface of the Internet are choosing to leave life. Rutabagas have lost their interest. Having your cat liked did not fill the hole intended for having yourself loved. And this child is not accustomed to doing things about things. This child does not do. This child is done to. With the same alacrity that he or she pursued the prompt to watch the seals he or she may “decide” it is time to end this.
2) I discovered my wife of the last forty-three years with whom I have raised two children and now five grandchildren with much happiness when while sitting on her front lawn, I seriously told her my goals in life. She thought they were so funny she actually rolled over laughing.
If I had instituted a computer search what algorithm would have found her an appropriate match? Yet this brain of mine sorted through whatever book-formed channels it had and locked in immediately on her as the “one,” the antidote to the man who takes himself too seriously. The Internet would have provided me many potential companions, each more serious than the last. That is the way it works. It finds my interests and then adds to the pile. If I follow its suggestions I become narrower and narrower, a better candidate to respond to the advertisers, a defined target, and a wealth of possibilities pass me by.
3) For something to remain in long-term memory it must spend two hours in short term memory. (There is actually a tiny physical growth that must happen.) But on the trip through rutabaga land, things go in and out too quickly to be grafted on the long-term nodules. Of course it still exists in the computer’s memory. When you know you need it, it can be sought. However the advantage of the human memory is that it coughs up stored information when you need it but do not know you need it. Not only does your intellect call on your memory, but your memory initiates conversations with your intellect. You won’t have that ability any longer. And since your long-term memory is not being used the section of the brain devoted to long-term memory has already begun to shrink.
Distant memories of your mother’s tears, your father’s embrace, your sisters admiration and your little brother’s needs will be crowded out of the brain, and I doubt if you will find them in Internet land either.
4) There are now residential therapy centers to assist the hooked to unhook from the Internet. The Internet lights up the same section of the brain as does cocaine. Didn’t’ know those grade school kids were getting a buzz? Makes what may be happening to my grandchildren a little less cute and a little less funny.
Read The Shallows yourself. What I have written is just a corner of the future described there. See if it scares you! And if it does, see who else you can scare with it. Hope they have enough of an attention span left to read the book. (A sign of the times is that people who used to write books no longer can read them. Not enough slippy and slidey. Boring!)
Can the majority of us survive without complex and nuanced thought? Without deep and poignant memories? Do we want to?
If you're looking at this, just go for it.
It's a quick read that shouldn't keep you from your tech for too long. Read it on a Kindle for extra irony.
The first half is largely a historical summary of communication and media, with the back half emphasizing the effects on our brains. It was written years ago, so it adds an interesting potency to see the impact today.
Top international reviews
However sometimes author makes far stretched conclusions and connections between his research and the main idea, that the "technology makes us worse". Furthermore, the author never begins to question his own stance and his own point of view. Why is remembering more "good"? Why is deep thinking "good"? Why thinking more deeply is something we should strive for?
He states that technology straps away our humanity and makes us less human. Why is this bad? Because we are different than our ancestors without such technology? Why is the difference bad? Those questions are very hard to answer and if the author had attempted to answer them, he would discover that this book and all his arguments are just a matter of opinion.
I'd recommend this to anyone who has some concerns about their internet use.
I will continue to use the internet but far more strategically after reading this book. I will reduce my time spent online, and in a more self directed way.
I am honestly in love with this book. It is super interesting and it does not only talk about the internet, but also about other technologies like reading, writing, clocks and other tools that we use and how our brain starts to perceive them as extensions of our body or mind and how that affects us.
There is only one thing that I disagreed with. The author claims that some e-books are distractive and contain hyperlinks which would render deep reading impossible. I have read many things on my kindle, and if anything, the kindle has helped me stay focused as I could not simply tap on a word and see its meaning without having to use my phone which would bombard me with notifications the second I turned on the internet. However, I sort of know what the author was referring to. Funnily enough, I could click on a few books that the author has mentioned himself in this book and I did have to decide whenever I saw the book symbol next to the title if I did or did not want to check out the book. I did click on one of the links. This however disrupted the session of deep reading that I was having. Links inside of books can indeed get distracting or interrupt your reading, so I hope that fewer people will resort to hyperlinking everything inside books.
Otherwise, I am so happy to have read this book and I am tempted to buy a paper version of it as well. I'd totally recommend it if you are interested in how your brain works and reacts to changes in environment, tools and so on. It is very interesting to find out what changed people's minds in the past and what is happening to our minds today.
This book is one of many that serve as a wake-up call to those who care deeply about that which makes us human - our creativity, empathy, courage and imagination. We are facing a crisis of our own making largely due to our blind faith in technology. By ignoring the warning signs and the words of seers like the author we're dooming future generations to a life of horrific destitution.
And yet nothing has changed since this book was written.