Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Top Customer Reviews
While the movie does deviate from the facts in some instances, it is largely faithful to the important details of the Silkwood case. Richard Rashke's "Who Killed Karen Silkwood" (1981, 2000) - written after Silkwood's parents pursued (and won) a civil case against K-M and based on court documents - presents ample evidence that Silkwood was indeed deliberately contaminated with plutonium and was murdered just days later. In fact, the film doesn't even address the most serious accusations - that Silkwood was part of a larger conspiracy that involved a number of state and federal agencies, that she was spied on by both K-M and the FBI, and that she may have stumbled across an international plutonium smuggling ring.
As a documentary, "Silkwood" does an acceptable job of outlining Silkwood's murder and the events leading up to it. Some of the dramatizations are disappointing but understandable. The lesbian storyline involving Silkwood's roommate Dolly (played by a refreshingly unglamorous Cher) struck me as silly and extraneous, particularly since, in real life, Silkwood's roommate was merely an acquaintance (not a good friend), and Silkwood was the one suspected of being a lesbian.
Nonetheless, as a drama, "Silkwood" certainly deserved its five Academy Award nominations.Read more ›
It was absolutely haunting to watch "Silkwood" and then go to work the next morning. There is so much the government doesn't tell the general public about the disastrous conditions in the labs, where we worked, that literally date to the days of the Manhattan Project. If the press only knew just a *few* of these things, the shockwaves would shake the US. I saw plenty of "accidents" (more like disasters) involving spills of concentrated solutions of plutonium compounds ... and was contaminated, once, myself.
The movie just gave me chills. No, in real life, they don't scrub you down with harsh brushes if you're contaminated (plutonium and other fission products are VERY dangerous if they enter through a break in the skin, into the bloodstream), but there was definitely enough in this film to give me chills at work.
I'm still a chemist, but won't work with plutonium again. And, hopefully, this review will remain anonymous.... Through this review, and stories I've told my friends, I've done my share of "whistle-blowing", and it's not a safe thing to do.
See this movie, and you'll think twice about how you feel about the "blue collar" workers involved in the mass production of nuclear warheads in the US.
Most Recent Customer Reviews
I bought several of these movie for my children to show the way Atomic Energy operates. I watched a biography on Karen Silkwood and she was far from a good mother. Read morePublished 2 months ago by David
I'm giving this movie 5 stars out of respect for the artists, because I saw it in the theater when it came out in 83 and it was just as amazing to watch then as I'm sure it would... Read morePublished 3 months ago by Deal Grabber!
Loved this movie years ago.... had kind of forgotten it until something reminded me of it the other day. I went and purchased it immediately for my DVD library. Read morePublished 3 months ago by Sherri B.
DVD had a skip on the disc which caused loss of film footage. Only played on DVD not blue ray (as advertised). Knock off comes to mind.Published 4 months ago by Backatheboat
EXCELLENT PORTRAYAL OF SOME REAL LIFE EVENTS....MERYL STREEP IS A S SENSATIONAL AS EVER!!Published 5 months ago by CHRISTINA HIGGINS
Love this movie that is amusing and tragic. Great performances.Published 6 months ago by Word of Mouth