Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Straphanger: Saving Our Cities and Ourselves from the Automobile Hardcover – April 24, 2012
The Amazon Book Review
Author interviews, book reviews, editors picks, and more. Read it now
Frequently bought together
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Customers who bought this item also bought
“All the cities we admire most in the world--the places young people want to live--boast great public transit systems or are in the process of building them. Taras Grescoe explains why: there's nothing more civilized than a great subway, or a bus rapid transit system, or a squad of ferries, or any of the other ways we've learned to move ourselves around urban space. As this splendid account makes clear, a car isn't liberation: not needing a car is liberation!” ―Bill McKibben, author Eaarth: Making a Life on a Tough New Planet
“Grescoe presents a strong and timely argument for moving metropolitan motorists away from their cars.” ―Publishers Weekly
“[Straphanger] is rife with bits of interesting trivia, and it almost reads like a travelogue as the author revels in the wonders of his diverse destinations. With a smooth, accessible narrative style…each chapter is packed with important information… A captivating, convincing case for car-free--or at least car-reduced--cities.” ―Kirkus
“Entertaining and illuminating...Grescoe's adventurous, first-person inspection of the world's latest high-tech transit systems keeps readers engaged while underscoring the importance of developing greener forms of transportation.” ―Library Journal
About the Author
Taras Grescoe is the award-winning author of four books and countless articles focusing on world travel. He's written for The New York Times, The Times (London), Wired, the Chicago Tribune Magazine, and the Los Angeles Times. He currently lives in Montreal. He has never owned a car.
Top customer reviews
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
In other words, Grescoe came to Phoenix not with an open mind, but with a predisposition to hate the city. Unfortunately, Grescoe was so blinded by his prejudice that he saw only what he wanted to see in order to confirm his negative impressions and ignored signs of success all around him. Grescoe claims he saw only a few university students when he rode the city's light rail line; however, I ride it to and from work every day, and it's crowded almost all the time. See the photo for an example. Since operations started in late 2008, light rail ridership has been approximately 50% higher than forecast, and the projected 2020 ridership level was achieved 8 years earlier than anticipated in 2012. Recognizing that success, Phoenix voters just approved a new sales tax increase that will fund significant light rail expansion.
Grescoe blatantly contradicts himself by first stating, incorrectly, that Phoenix has no historic city center. Then, a few pages later, he admits that prior to World War II, Phoenix was a compact and walkable city with an extensive streetcar network. He also claims that Phoenix's extraordinarily successful light rail line "doesn't really go anywhere." Since when does "nowhere" include two university campuses, an emerging biomedical center, symphony hall, popular theaters, a convention center, corporate headquarters, several major museums, state and federal courthouses, a busy international airport, a community college, and several of the city's most celebrated arts districts and historic neighborhoods?
Of course, defenders of Grescoe might say that this negative review is the result of hurt feelings and wounded civic pride. Not really. It's about so much more than that. The real problem is that if Grescoe approached one city with a preconceived conclusion, isn't it likely he did the same with the other cities profiled in the book? As a result, Straphanger has no credibility at all. Grescoe can't be trusted no matter which city he praises or condemns. His unconvincing arguments against Phoenix's emerging transit culture echo the same tired and thoroughly debunked cliches used unsuccessfully by opponents of the city's light rail line, and, as a result, he plays right into the hands of the anti-transit voices he opposes.
The former is of no special interest with rather banal descriptions of the author’s childhood experiences in suburbia or of his current marital bliss.
The latter is quite enlightening and covers for each of a wide range of urban transit systems historical aspects, a diagnostic and a prognostic. The bibliography shows that significant research was made by the author who took the pains of personally visiting each city. The approach is by no means rigorous however and much contents appears based on impressions and interviews with specific stakeholders. Descriptions and analyses are certainly not exhaustive and for instance nothing is said of the extensive development of bus lanes in Paris over the last 15 years as a complement to the metro.
The writing style is overly dramatic with the chapter on New York City beginning for instance on the blasting site for a new subway line. The first sentence reads: « Something impossibly big and powerful was moving beneath the city. »! Strangely, no maps are provided and the reader must resort to Internet to adequately spatialize what is described in each city covered.
Though it does provide interesting vignettes on what goes on in terms of transit in many locations, this work presents too many quirks to be recommended.