Amazon.com: Customer Reviews: The Origins of the Irish
Amazon Vehicles Fall Reading 2016 Amazon Fashion Learn more nav_sap_plcc_ascpsc $5 Albums Fire TV Stick Health, Household and Grocery Back to School Totes Amazon Cash Back Offer ElvisandNixon ElvisandNixon ElvisandNixon  Amazon Echo  Echo Dot  Amazon Tap  Echo Dot  Amazon Tap  Amazon Echo Starting at $49.99 All-New Kindle Oasis Florida Georgia Line Shop Now STEM

Customer Reviews

4.4 out of 5 stars
14
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Combining archeology with linguistics, adding genetics to explain the connections between these two fields, this expert in Indo-European Studies turns to his homeland to wonder how its earliest inhabitants wound up on this North Atlantic island. With attention to demystification but with an affection for the myths, J. P. Mallory builds on nearly a half-century of his research to present an academic study that anybody curious about his title will welcome. Learned but lively, Mallory's contribution remains throughout cautious in its surmises but diligent in his analyses.

He begins about as far back as the Big Bang, if in passing. Much of the first hundred pages explain how recently Ireland (and Britain, always its fractious or friendly neighbor) split off from the Continent--itself long in the making as the tectonic plates shifted slowly. Two parts of Ireland at one time faced each other, if from a distance as far apart as Australia from the island today.

After the last Ice Age, the land bridge between northwest France and Ireland cannot be firmly dated, but it broke apart over 12,000-10,000 years ago. That means whomever settled as what Mallory calls the "Irelanders"--prior to the relatively recent national formation of the "Irish" under Niall of the Nine Hostages, the first figure straddling legendary and historical times and allegedly the kidnapper of Calpurnius' Romano-Briton son to be known as Patrick--had to migrate into that thawed-out expanse after the melting glaciers filled the Irish Sea.

For only 1/43,000th of its existence as a land mass has Ireland occupied its present site and shape. Poorer in flora and fauna than Britain or the Continent, it could not have supported many prehistoric families. As few as 3,000 people may have lived in Ireland for the first 40% of its existence as we know it. Recently settled in Eurasian terms, colonists may have voyaged from the nearby Isle of Man as global warming wiped out part of that territory. Generally, Mallory favors looking closest--to the western Scottish and Welsh shores for those who would populate Ireland first.

As for farming, around 3800 BCE marks a revolution in agriculture. It may have spread rapidly, within two hundred years, and again probably westward from a British base. Brittany at the tip of today's France may have contributed, as the longer sea passages navigated back and forth in turn may have stimulated Irish-British trade all the more.

Any archeological treatment of Northern Europe debates the origins and provenance of the Beakers, the pottery goblets with a bell-like shape. Suffice to say Mallory delves into this with gusto and wit, no small feat for what can be deadly dull material for those of us outside the trenches. He loves citing his more imaginative predecessors to telling effect about the romantic interpretations of sherds and grooves. "Drink, fighting and the Irish Sweepstakes would certainly tally with Irish stereotypes," he comments as he surveys the eagerness of his gullible colleagues to imagine (ca. 2500 BCE) brutal invaders, tipsy warriors, and horse-drawn shock and awe descending upon cowering scrabblers.

Metallurgy ushers in the Bronze and Iron Ages, and the siting of dramatic hillforts may show cultural shifts for population changes and ritual behaviors at this time. While Mallory downplays the exotic or martial, he notes how, given hoards found, Continental foreigners could have visited or stayed. He consistently edges away from a scenario of invasion (despite the Irish legends and their "nine waves" of conquerors) to one of gradual diffusion of goods and contacts. Ironically, Niall's own inheritance centuries later would signal the end of this mythical time, as a cult from Southwest Asia and the customs and language of a dying empire would transform Ireland into the "Irish," whose legacy would be distorted by Christian interpretations of what has come to be known as a "Celtic" past.

Earlier than often assumed, by those celebrating Patrick's freedom from Niall's enslavement and his return to Ireland to convert its "pagan" natives, Roman influence entered Ireland as it had Patrick's homeland, wherever it was across the Irish Sea. In fact, perhaps by way of earlier slaves than that fabled missionary to the Hibernians in 432, Christians lived on the island; a bishop was sent there the year before Patrick to minister to that flock. Niall and his ilk engaged in an active sea-slave trade.

Mallory shows that while a pre-Christian Roman presence left a fraction of what imperial centuries of occupation over Britain had, nonetheless Irish evidence for Roman trade and settlement can be marshaled. From the classical reports of Ptolemy and the Romanized variations on the savage British and Irish tribes and places, we get the first glimpse into what "civilization" regarded as Hibernia, a damp backward dump on the world's edge. "Why the Romans or indeed anyone else should have wanted to come to Ireland is a mystery if the early classical descriptions of the island had provided copy for Roman travel brochures", Mallory remarks with typical flair.

We also owe the classical historians another label, if an elusive one. They named the diverse peoples across Europe speaking similar languages as Celts. Mallory follows Kim McCone in matching this to a root meaning of "hidden" and therefore "offspring of the hidden one," identifying this allusion with the lord of the dead, Donn, the "dark brown one."

Speaking of enduring identifiers, generations looked south to Spain (anywhere but east!) for Irish origins, but this Latin confusion does not fool Mallory. He dismisses origin myths as modeled by monks on the biblical wanderings of the Jews. He also blames the Wikipedia equivalent of the 7th century, Isidore's Etymologies, with this persistent but false derivation of supposedly adjacent Hibernians from venerable Iberians.

Deepening his application of language, the latter third of Mallory's study finds him tackling the spread of the Celtic tongue into Ireland. These final hundred pages pack a tremendous amount of data--DNA as well as glottochronology--into a few chapters. Microliths give way to haplotypes.

He leaves us with two possibilities about the spread of Proto-Irish during the first millennium BCE. Mallory posits social prestige and identification with trend setters as likely explanations for a native adoption of a Celtic language. He suggests that an initial impact around 1000 BCE is one of two "most likely" windows of opportunity, in tandem with the emergence of hillforts. The second may be around the 3rd century BCE as Tara and other highly visible "ritual enclosures" dominated the landscape and consolidated a mental perspective that would endure as the "Irish" looked around in Niall's pivotal era to adapt the four provinces circling around a fifth center as their nation's model.

This valuable book does not leap from a petri dish or a soggy excavation to any bold conclusion. This Belfast-based professor knows his subject all too well to trust in what genetic findings from next year's lab or carbon dating from this season's dig may override. Mallory relies on commonsense and judicial balancing of the more fervid proposals of his colleagues. "The Origins of the Irish" serves as a trustworthy. eminently scholarly but accessible guide past tricky diversions and evasive directions.
22 comments| 40 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on June 10, 2013
If you want to know for sure how the Irish became Irish then you'll have to wait. The Irelanders, as the author calls them, probably arrived about 8,000 BC, based on archaeological evidence. The Irish, that is those speaking the Irish language, came anywhere from 1BC to 1AD.
So is there a one-line answer to the book's title? Not that I can make out.
Each chapter deals with archaeological and linguistic evidence, and as Prof. Mallory is an expert in both fields he lays out the many theories and claims based on what is known, and each chapter ends with his Conclusions, which summarize what he has said and spells out what he believes is factual.
The book is entertaining, for sure, but has an academic feel to it, which is really not surprising given that he is a professor at a Belfast university.
Mallory also has a sense of humor, which he slips in from time to time.
Am I glad I read it? Absolutely yes. Would I recommend it? Absolutely yes.
But do I know the answer contained in the book's title? Kinda, sorta, but not really sure.
I still have another history-of-the-Irish book to read, which I sense without opening it will have a less academic approach to the subject.
Bottom line: The subject is a very complicated one, and Mallory's academic approach and professional accomplishments are used to their full to nail down the answer.
Possibly reading it again (NOT an easy thing to do) would bring more enlightenment.
44 comments| 14 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 4, 2014
I haven't even finished this book and I love it already. I have never once found another book that looks at Irish history in its entirety, as in all the way back. This is not necessarily for those who have no knowledge of archaeology, as the fellow who writes this speaks in a "dumbed down" archaeologist's language. It's still a bit technical. I graduated with a degree in history and a long love of archaeology, so I have little issue with the language, but I can see how it might be an issue for those with no knowledge of archaeology at all.
0Comment| 4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on May 26, 2013
Quite different from the Irish "histories" I read as a child. Solidly based on science and provable history, and entertaining as well.
0Comment| 9 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on November 18, 2014
An excellent book that recounts the evidence and interpretations regarding the prehistory and early history of Ireland. Mallory' s good sense, intelligence, profound knowledge and wit produce good prose and convincing arguments . Unlike so many prehistorians , he recognizes how common migration was in prehistory and its essential role in creating the Irish. The Irish, like almost everyone, are cultural and genetic mongrels, not autocthonous. Mallory is sometimes too tolerant of colleagues' trendy stupid ideas but at the end of every chapter lists the relevant facts and sensible conclusions.
Larry K
0Comment| 3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on June 28, 2014
I loved this book. For a book that was heavy with academic information, it felt surprisingly light. The humor and brilliant writing made it feel like more of a summer beach read than anything else. Nevertheless, it is wonderful introduction to Irish prehistory starting with the big bang and going right up to the time of Niall of the Nine Hostages.
0Comment| 3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on April 7, 2014
Interesting account of the creation of Ireland from the days of Gondwana to recent times and the beginnings of 'Irishness' in the population from humble and sparse beginnings. Worth reading.
0Comment| 4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 1, 2015
Better than ANY other book about the earliest inhabitants of Ireland that I have found. There is none of the Celtic magical nonsense you find elsewhere. A bit scholarly for some, possibly, but enjoyable with ample citations.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on May 4, 2013
Mallory goes into a lot of detail and research on the subject. When one is interested in not only the "name" but how they got there, this does the job . If you coordinate this with Thomas Cahill's, " How the Irish saved civilization" you will get a greater appriciation for the contributions of the Irish .
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on May 9, 2013
Having some Irish blood I've been interested in the Irish and Ireland since I was quite young. This book starts at the Big Bang and goes from there into how Ireland and the Irish got to where they are. Naturally, without the benefit of time travel, there's a lot of theory and supposition, but it all makes sense of where the Irish and their language came from.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse