Oil month Automotive Best Books of the Month Introducing Prime Wardrobe nav_sap_plcc_ascpsc Unlimited Music. Made for you. Learn more. PCB for select Bang & Olufsen Starting at $39.99 Grocery Handmade Mother's Day gifts Book a house cleaner for 2 or more hours on Amazon Fifty Shades Freed available to buy Fifty Shades Freed available to buy Fifty Shades Freed available to buy  Echo Fire tablets: Designed for entertainment Kindle Paperwhite AutoRip in CDs & Vinyl Shop now TG18PP_gno



on January 5, 2017
My Copy: Oxford Univ. Press: 30th Anniversary Edition (Hardbound)

There is much more to "The Selfish Gene" than is advertised, even in the most glowing of its reviews. In fact, I (not a biologist, but fascinated by evolution ever since "dinosaurs" and the first high school biology course) have been vaguely aware of this book since its initial wave of rave reviews many years ago, but never bothered to read it because as it was advertised its theme(s) always seemed pretty obvious. But something recently piqued my curiosity again, not sure what that was now, and after reading the prefatory material online I finally decided to take a look.

After reading quickly through the first 3 chapters, it became apparent that there was a great deal more underlying the book than was overtly presented, that it was not just an over-extended, over-simplified, over-popularized, metaphorical presentation .... but rather that its metaphorical treatment is painstakingly faithful to an elaborate, closely-reasoned, even rigorous, scientific underpinning. At which point, I stopped reading and began again from the beginning, first the prefatory material, then from page 1, this time more slowly and more carefully, taking care to appreciate and reflect on all the markers of the underlying basis and their implications.

This is a wonderful book, even beautiful in many respects, from its initial beginning (at the "beginning") with the purely chemical/physics "evolution" of the primordial soup (cast suggestively in the form of biological evolution); to the consequent continuity with the creation of "replicators", elementary "survival" cells, genes, and the beginnings of life forms; to the important distinction between genes and individuals, as genes and their "survival vehicles" (the first cells and "us", for example); to the nicely extended notion of "gene" itself, required by underlying scientific reality; to a clear presentation of the conflict between Darwinian and "group" selection and evolution; to the nature of evolution, operating (in distinct ways) in terms of both genes and individuals, aka both genes and "their" survival vehicles, aka both chemical/physics and biological evolution; to genetic kinship and its very special selective and social implications; ... ; to the delicious End Notes to the 1st eleven chapters, which provide much supporting and fascinating material.

"The Selfish Gene" goes on to clarify not only its expressed subject, the nature and genesis of Selfishness and Altruism, but to make clear the error, scope, and source of various (idealistic, and often political) arguments and ideas centered around group selection fallacies, including the genesis of (ill-conceived) "group-beneficial", cooperative "functions" vs. (individual) evolutionarily stable strategies (ESS) and kinship. It also sheds light on many other commonly-posed questions, among them: the fundamental "reason" for the 50:50 sex ratio (despite the number of different breeding strategies observed for male competitors); the driving source of the natural variability upon which (continuing) evolution depends; the variety and shadings of competing "strategies", which can be both conceived and advantageous, clustered around a given regard (partly on account of environmental inconstancy), one incidental, unintended but important, implication of which is that this is itself an evolutionary driving source of the natural variability upon which (continuing) evolution operates; .... and NOT so commonly posed: that "In its long journey down the generations therefore, an [ANY] average gene will spend approximately half its time sitting in male bodies, and the other half sitting in female bodies", and thus genes will generally contribute positively to both sexes, sometimes in very different ways, and that, indeed, many "purely male / purely female" effects pass (unexpressed) through many bodies of the opposite sex; and much, much more.

Beautifully written and packed with wonderful insights, "The Selfish Gene" is not only well-worth the read, but will amply reward the reader in proportion to the thoughtfulness and reflection with which they read it. In fact, there is so much food for thought in the story-lines and examples (e.g., the fig, "lichenization", and organelle endosymbiosis) provided in "The Selfish Gene", that one must often stop and consider, at length and at leisure, the questions which it provokes or which Dawkins rhetorically poses.

I will, however, amend Dawkins' wonderful characterization of "us" (Preface to the First Edition, p. xxi): “We are survival machines --- robot vehicles blindly programmed to preserve the selfish molecules known as genes. This is a truth which still fills me with astonishment. Though I have known it for years, I never seem to get fully used to it.” ...... by grafting it to my own previous synopsis, with the result:

"We are Conditioned-Reaction Engines [built on Basic Senses + Unconditioned Reflexes (among them innate Kantian "Categories", instincts, emotions, etc.)] built as Gene-Survival "Machines" [genetically "programmed" to serve the "interests" of our genes] = Pavlo-Kantian Conditioned-Reaction, Darwin-Dawkins Gene-Survival Automatons.
0Comment| 18 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on July 24, 2017
I recommend this book and learned a great deal from it. Please consider this review in that light.
This book which sets out the gene centric theory of evolution is difficult for a lay reader (me) to review. Dawkins tries to make the subject understandable to just about any non-science but reasonably well -educated reader. Throughout the book, Dawkins attempts to make it more approachable by using snappy colloquial language. Nevertheless, this is a challenging read.
For a lay reader, part of the challenge is sorting through the book’s near endless digressions in which Dawkins “rebuts” the contrary views of some very well-respected evolutionists (e.g. E.O. Wilson, S.J. Gould and others). I was/am uninterested in these quarrels and have no way of evaluating their merits. However, many of these are integrated into the explanatory text so that it is hard to skip over them. The book is listed at 450 pages of which 100 pages are devoted to end- notes which contain even more rebuttals/explanations of other competing thinking in the field. I wish the book were 250 pages and the end-notes 200 pages. I believe the lucidity of the text would be much improved.
0Comment| 4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on December 20, 2016
This is the first of his books I've read, and I expect to read all his others before I die. A challenging topic to understand, for me anyway. Dawkins writes clearly, with wit.
0Comment| 5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on December 28, 2016
The Selfish Gene elucidates the genetic determinants of biological structure, function and behavior in a highly articulate, yet comprehensible manner. This book has withstood the test of time and it's central theme is as relevant as it was forty years ago, thanks to the preface and epilogue. The author's writing skill and erudition make it an enjoyable and highly informative read.
11 comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on August 22, 2017
I loved the point of view switch of focusing on genes as the unit of natural selection from organisms; it was illuminating and fascinating. This book felt like a refinement to my point of view that is only somewhat less important than the discovery of natural selection itself; I am particularly struck by its potential application to other forms of life in the universe. If you are interested in science in general and biology in particular, read this book.
11 comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on August 8, 2017
Probably one of the best examples of how to write science for laypeople. It lays out its ideas clearly in the first few chapters: that genes "work" to further themselves, and spends page after page helping laying out the evidence. More generally, he lays out the idea of the "replicator" and how all life essentially functions as collections of replicators, all trying their darndest to stay in order.
11 comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on November 21, 2016
Some books should be required reading. This book conveys so much knowledge and so many mind expanding ideas.

Having heard professor Dawkins in Philadelphia it made the read even more enjoyable. People desperately need to combat the rampant anti-intellectual sentiment that is growing ever popular,and this book is a vehicle to do just that.

This book isn't technical, but it is not the easiest read. I had to stop and digest a few times, but my prior knowledge was weak. That being said I am buying "The Extended Phenotype" at once. I will own all his works before it's over.

This deserves a place in every home beside "A brief History of Time"
0Comment| 19 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on September 6, 2017
WOW!! This book will change the way you see EVERYTHING....or not. It depends on whether or not your brain is "write protected".
11 comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on April 20, 2018
This is an excellent overview of how genes impact on our bodies and lives. It is a fascinating tale of reproduction and disease. The struggle for survival is one that envelopes ourselves and everything that surrounds us.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on April 10, 2017
my new favorite book. you must carefully read the text as its a bit difficult to understand if you simply rush through it. but its great information and a good way of answering you why questions from bottom up.
11 comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse