Industrial Deals HPC Best Books of the Year Holiday Dress Guide nav_sap_hiltonhonors_launch Weekly One STEM Limited time offer Handmade Gift Shop Holiday Home Gift Guide Book a house cleaner for 2 or more hours on Amazon TNF TNF TNF  Echo Devices starting at $29.99 Save $30 on All-New Fire HD 8. Limited-time offer. $20 off Kindle Paperwhite GNO Shop Now HTL17_gno

The U.S. Albums
Format: Audio CD|Change
Price:$151.99+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime

on January 25, 2014
While the set is getting rave reviews from most, and justifiably so, the purists, like myself are not as thrilled as we could have been.
Allow me to qualify myself; I am a musician and mastering engineer by profession, a life-long audiophile and a Beatle fan from the beginning (actually a little before they were really known in the US).
The set overall sounds great. No worries there, many of the unique mixes are present, and several 'firsts' on CD. It is a worthy compilation for the true fan.
But, it becomes obvious that these are not the actual 'final' Capitol mixes, especially on the earliest albums for the most part, as they are lacking the hard compression and reverb that the Capitol engineers added to make the records sound 'more American'. I have the original LP's and the Vol. 1 Capitol box, which is from those tapes.
From what I am hearing, it is perhaps fear on EMI's part of offending the sonic sensibilities of fans that fall in the category of millennials and Gen X'ers that are accustomed to more refined audio reproduction, when in fact, many in this demographic have been responsible for driving the revival of the vinyl LP, and who also revere these early Capitol efforts. Or it may be that they decided to give us a sonically superior version of those unique Capitol versions, which is a great idea, I just would have liked to have known before hand. I would still be on board to buy.
We are missing the few fake stereo mixes, being replaced with mono mixes, or actual stereo mixes. Audibly superior, but missing the point of a reissue like this. We want those crunchy, loud, reverberated chaotic environs Capitol created, as that is our first experience. This is less about audio quality and more about nostalgia.
Now, having said this, some tracks have the correct mixes, but lack the post production processes.
If you want to really hear what we heard back in 1964, I, like many others, would recommend either buying the original Capitol Box Sets, or start cruising eBay for good used copies of the original LP's.
I have a bit of an advantage because of my background as an engineer in dismantling 'mixes', and I have both a great stereo system, and a reference workstation with the ability to quickly do A-B analysis. Most of this box set doesn't sound much different than the 2009 remastered box sets at first listen.
But that's OK too.
On the plus side, we finally get A Hard Day's Night, the United Artists version, on CD, although some of the logic eludes me as to having I'll Cry Instead in both versions as mono, since the shorter version has a stereo mix. The original U/A release had only the musical score in stereo, and all of the Beatles' music were 'fake' stereo mixes from mono masters, with even more reverb. They are true stereo mixes here, with the exception of I'll Cry Instead. Love the score on this one!
The Beatles' Story for the first time ever on CD. This isn't for everybody, but is a fun piece for those of us that remember it.

Allow me to address 'fake stereo' issue, or as it has been mis-titled by the fan base for decades now, 'Duo-Phonic', (Duo-Phonic and Duo-Sonic were the names of the process for any stereo release by Capitol, in much the same way RCA had Living Stereo as a process brand, not as an indicator of fake stereo).
Most fans insist that The Beatles Second Album is entirely fake stereo. It isn't. It's mostly real stereo, but what the Capitol engineers did, with the heavy reverb and compression, and also panning the left channel slightly right, with all of it's channel bleed, it is very nearly like the (forgive the contradiction in terms) 'real' fake stereo mixes when listened to casually due to it's poor separation as a result.
Creating a stereo track from a mono source involves splitting the signal to two channels, and alter the EQ of each channel (roll off high end on one lower the bass on the other for example), add stereo reverb to give the illusion of two discrete channels. The stereo reverb gives a slight channel delay and channel bleed to enhance the effect. Love Me Do is mixed like this, for example, as is She Loves You, but not on this box set version. They are mono.
The later albums had less affectation from the Capitol guys, but were still very tightly compressed up until Sgt. Pepper's.

This is where I differ from most fans; I only bought singles until 1967 when I got my first stereo open reel deck, with the primary goal of getting all of The Beatle albums on pre-recorded reel. There was good reasoning for this, as the open reel tapes did not receive a lot of the heavy post production compression, and were just better sounding overall. Those of us that grew up with the Beatles in this medium are the smallest fan niche out there, but we also had the best representation, at the time, of The Beatles' recorded works.
My first tape was Revolver, and it was about 3 times the price of the LP, but well worth it. I only lately heard the Capitol LP of Revolver for the first time, and it was incredibly stressful to listen to (and I have a high end archivist turntable and signal chain)! While the tape had a certain amount of compression added, it was over the top on the LP! The 2009 remaster out performs either, as pure audio, but when nostalgia calls, I pull up that 47 year old reel.
My point is, the Capitol mixes are what they are, (or were) and are best experienced via the medium they were intended for; LP. The original Capitol Box sets capture this sound and vibe beautifully, but may not be for everyone, and may be stressful listening for most.

In the 60's I wanted the best quality possible in recordings by The Beatles. These are here now, in this set and the 2009 remasters.
And for those of us that really want those original mixes; do you think EMI will set us adrift when there is money to be made?
If you have the first two Capitol Box sets, just buy the titles you need to fill the gaps. But if you are a 'completist' as I am, you will want this Capitol set as well. It has more going for it than against it. Think of it as an audiophile version of the Capitol albums.
I love the packaging, the while the sound isn't exact to our first experience, the rest of it gives a tangible link to those early days via the artwork, play order and vibe.
If you have doubts, go to iTunes, and sample the tracks there before you invest, but do have a good audio system connected to your computer, particularly of you want to conduct your own A-B comparisons. For me there is enough difference to go for it.

UPDATE 2/17/14
I need to upgrade this to 5 stars. Capitol tapes were definitely used on at least a good portion of this collection, based on a discovery i made over the weekend.
I can only speak to Rubber Soul and Revolver at this point. True, they do lack the really heated and compressed sound of the LP, but are a dead match to my pre-recorded reels which are period to the original releases.
I bought the open reel versions as opposed to LP because they sound better and lack a lot of the post processing used for the lacquer master tapes. The tracks on Rubber Soul are from the 1965 original mix, for one, Capitol enhanced and a totally match to my later Ampex reel, warts and all! When I did critical A-B on Revolver, between the original Captiol tape and the new CD, the wave forms, compression levels, harmonic distortion (a small matter) were an absolute match sonically and in the software. Amazing! I need to do further analysis on the other albums, and it appears that while the sound is better than the original LP, these masters at least are from Capitol. I never thought i would hear this particular sound outside of my 47 year old tape, and the digital remaster i had done on it some years ago.
But meanwhile, I am just enjoying this set! I suggest you do the same!
A Hard Day's Night, was, at least on the orchestral score, the same as the LP. I was hoping for a bit of an improvement on these ate least, but sound about the same as the LP. I have the LP, so I already have the fake stereo mixes of The Beatles for that one (I remastered that particular LP to hi res digital sometime ago).
I have no absolute conclusion on the overall set in regards to whose tapes were used for which album or track, but I'll do more forensics as my mood and time permits, and if i find any other amazing aspects, I'll update here. I'm having a blast otherwise!
5150+ comments| 511 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on March 18, 2016
It is about time that the USA albums come out on CD. What's really great and much anticipated is "The Beatles' Story", the documentary. These discs bring back fond memories of my carefree childhood. It's particularly great to know that the soundtrack instrumentals of "A Hard Day's Night" and "Help!" finally made CD recordings; these instrumentals are conspicuously absent from the original British issues. No, the albums from "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" to "Let It Be", did not make this box; that's because the USA and British versions have the very same track listings.
0Comment| 5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on July 13, 2016
NIce presentation, even if some of the tracks are not the American mixes.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on August 27, 2016
While these are quite good...they are NOT the Capital releases. The stereo versions are from the 2009 releases. I have the 2004 and 2006 Box Sets and the sound it VERY different. The Second Album has the STEREOPHONIC She Loves you....from 2004 as well as I Want to Hold You Hand from.. Meet The Beatles. These are good...especially the Album art looks better than the 2004 and 2006 releases. Hey Jude...Revolver...Something New...Yesterday and Today...and The Beatles Story...had not been released...which I was waiting for the 3rd Box I can't compare the sounds with a previous release. I just know the stereo versions are the same as the 2009 release. The Monos' however, are SLIGHTLY different than The Beatles in MONO that was released. I rather like that release. Get that one if you don't have it. You'll like Sgt. Pepper in Mono. WAAAAAAAAAAAY different sound!!! Still tho ENJOY!! after's........ THE BEATLES
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on September 8, 2016
CDs Showed up within a week. And now I'm starting from the beginning and so far it sounds fantastic & what beautiful package. The mini me of the albums I grew up with. And still own. Good seller !!! Keep rockin. BL
review image
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on August 24, 2014
Capitol Records really dropped the ball on this one. The fans who were interested in this collection expected the US Capitol mixes of these recordings. Instead we get the same mono & stereo mixes that were released in 2009. I thought this was a better repackaging of the two Capitol Albums box sets, but I didn't realize they didn't use the US mixes. I bought it before I knew the real deal. Although I've always felt that the US mixes were inferior, I'm aware of the nostalgic feeling of hearing these songs the way we first heard them in the USA.

So, I now have a box set that rarely demands play. The only thing in this box that I need as a completest is the US version of the album "A Hard Day's Night" and "The Beatles' Story". The US "Hard Day's Night" features instrumental versions of the songs by the George Martin Orchestra. I could have lived without them, but George Martin is cool and it's also cool to have those. "The Beatles' Story" is an interview album that offers very little that the average Beatles fan doesn't already know. It's not important to have this, but I'm glad that I do. It's also fun to have the "Hey Jude" & "Yesterday & Today" compilations, although I could have easily burned them from my collection.

The packaging for "The U.S. Albums" is stunning, to say the least. It's also a nice touch that they used the original "butcher cover" for the album "Yesterday & Today". If you don't get "The U.S. Albums", you aren't missing much at all. If you find it used for cheap, go for it.
11 comment| 10 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on June 3, 2017
love it
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on December 6, 2017
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on December 9, 2017
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on March 17, 2017
Completist that I am, this was perfect.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse