To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Other Sellers on Amazon
+ $3.99 shipping
+ $4.99 shipping
+ $3.75 shipping
A Thyme and Place: Medieval Feasts and Recipes for the Modern Table Hardcover – June 7, 2016
|New from||Used from|
"Warlight" by Michael Ondaatje
A dramatic coming-of-age story set in the decade after World War II, "Warlight" is the mesmerizing new novel from the best-selling author of "The English Patient." Pre-order today
Frequently bought together
Customers who bought this item also bought
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
About the Author
Lisa Graves is the author and illustrator of the series Women in History, with three books to her name, as well as the illustrator of The Tudor Tutor (Skyhorse Publishing). She is the creator of Historywitch.com, a site dedicated to illustrations of history’s most fascinating characters. She lives in Medway, Massachusetts.
Top customer reviews
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
1) While the book claims to consider the medieval period, which it defines as "the end of the fifth century... until the sixteenth century", it includes recipes and events "until the mid 1600s" - a solid 150 years after the period they define has ended. As a rule of thumb, if you're talking about Queen Elizabeth and Mary Stuart, you're looking at the early modern period (the "Renaissance"), and not the medieval.
2) Class matters. Many of the social practices and foodways mentioned in this book were class-specific, and there's not much discussion about that. Nutmeg, for example, was far from "readily available" for the vast majority of people - it was a valuable and exotic spice, and in 1621 the Dutch East India Company engaged in a bloody genocide to gain control of it. Similarly, while arranged marriage was the norm (at least for first marriages) among the landed classes, it really isn't useful for the peasantry at all.
3) Corn (maize) is a New World crop, and was not available in medieval Europe (or even in early 17th century Europe, really). Prior to European cultivation of maize, "corn" meant a grain - compare barleycorn, peppercorns, etc. The "ear of corn" to be left out on St Brigid's day is presumably wheat. Similarly, tomatoes are a new world vegetable, and for most of the medieval period nobody in Europe had heard of them. They weren't grown in England until about 1590 - and were understood to be an aphrodisiac, undesirable for eating, but not necessarily poisonous at that time.
4) Not a historical note, but: figs are not inverted flowers, and they are fruits. Like many other fruits (including basic ones like apples), the fruit includes tissue from outside the ovary - this is called an accessory fruit, but it's still a fruit. Figs are also a multiple fruit: the fruiting body combines the fruit of many flowers. None of those flowers are inverted - they are all right-side out, but hidden inside the synconium.
5) For a cookbook exploring medieval food, it's oddly opinionated. Simnel cake, for instance, is delicious. I can see not including a recipe as they're widely available, but the note implies that it wasn't included because it tastes bad ("It is essentially a fruitcake with almond paste. But don't worry, we wouldn't do that to you."). Elsewhere, on a pudding recipe, they say "Don't worry, we have not developed anything with rendered suet" - but why not? Tallow isn't hard to find, thanks to the paleo diet folks, and makes delicious baked goods. Lard is an even more available substitute. So why throw shade and swap rendered animal fats out for vegetable shortening?
6) There are no citations. Not on the recipes, not on the history, not on the annoying little sidebars. There's no list of referenced works anywhere. Recipes all have daft, cutesy names ("Chase that cheese and onion soup"?) that can't be traced back to any origin recipe, making it hard to tell what's authentic, what's adapted "for the modern table", what's invented, and what's just wrong. Given the obvious errors in the book, the lack of citations makes everything else suspect.
Recipes from the medieval eras do not have cutesy names. 'Silence of the Lamb Stew' maybe quite tasty, (the recipe appears to be good) but titles like that do not belong in a medieval cookbook. Even one that has been geared toward 'Modern Table'.
There seems to be no citation ANY where in the book. For ANY thing.
I'm sorry I spent $1.99 for this book. It's barely worth that. Do not spend any more that. Or better yet, spend it on a better book. 700 Years of English Cooking leaps to mind. Or if you can't find that, Pleyn Delit: Medieval Cookery for Modern Cooks will do quite well.