Your Garage Best Books of the Month STEM nav_sap_plcc_ascpsc Amazon's Choice Computers Starting at $39.99 STEM Handmade Mother's Day Gifts STEM Shop Popular Services siliconvalley siliconvalley siliconvalley  All-New Echo Dot Starting at $89.99 Kindle Oasis Nintendo Switch Shop Now disgotg_gno_17

Customer Reviews

4.7 out of 5 stars
Format: Kindle Edition|Change
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Showing 1-10 of 32 reviews(Verified Purchases). See all 40 reviews
on November 29, 2013
I love both the US & especially the UK Transformers comics. First off, let me say that Marvel in general makes the best comics ever. X-Men, Avengers, Fantastic Four Iron Man; the list goes on. Even some of the toy based ones were great. Besides the obvious suspect, I also loved Micronauts & Rom. They all continue to entertain me to this day. While the US Transformers comic was spotty at times there were still some very good issues. But when Furman came along, it was nothing but awesome, all the way through Generation 2. I have to admit that overall I think it’s better than the cartoon, especially when you include the UK issues. Although I think season 2 of the show represents the high point of 80s animation (as well as at least two-thirds of season 3), the comic lasted longer than the show & got to handle more characters which made it a little more interesting. And I have to admit that while the first season is good on its own, I like the first twelve issues of the comic a bit better. A few episodes presented a better debut for certain characters. Heavy Metal War was significantly better than issue #10 of the comic (though that issue was good too), and Jetfire’s origin was much better in the cartoon, even if he was called Skyfire. But aside from 2 or 3 more episodes those are really the only better parts of the first season. I love everything about the first 12 issues. The characters all get a better introduction than in More Than Meets The Eye, especially the cassettes. I find it really interesting that Ravage, Laserbeak & Buzzsaw (& later Ratbat) can talk as opposed to only speak in animal noises. And they should too. Their tech specs all have quotes, and how could they have quotes if they couldn’t talk? I wonder what Laserbeak & Buzzsaw would have sounded like, but to this day I always use Ravage’s Beast Wars voice when reading his lines in the comic. Ratchet & Shockwave are also significantly cooler in the comic. In the cartoon, Shockwave was just another of Megatron’s loyal followers while in the comic he fights him for leadership (believing himself to be the most logical choice for leader, which is closer to his tech spec) & beats him. And while Ratchet never got much of a spotlight in the cartoon, he got a really good one in issues 7 & 8. But the biggest improvement over the cartoon as a whole (apart from lasting longer) is the Dinobots. In the second season they were always cool, but in the first season their stupidity was a little annoying at times. Here though they are smarter and they come from Cybertron (which makes them more interesting than being built on Earth as it lead to one of my favorite UK stories, Grudge Match) & got their forms because their ship was scanning the inhabitants of the Savage Land. That’s another nice little bonus I wish we could’ve seen more of, interactions with the Marvel universe. Ah well at least we got a crossover with Spider-Man. And I don’t care what anyone says, these stories all take place in my ideal Marvel Universe (the Transformers & G.I. Joe cartoons were technically produced by Marvel, & that’s good enough for me). Really, I have nothing but praise for the first 12 issues. The only nitpicks I have are that Buster & Jessie aren’t quite as cool as Spike & Carly, & I wish that Sparkplug had eventually opened up to the Autobots, but I guess I’ll just have to write fanfiction to fill in the gaps (though I was very glad when they brought Spike in later). Sadly there is one real flaw in this volume, in that it does not end on a good story. I’m not superstitious but 13 was a really unlucky number for this comic. The story Shooting Star is about a loser who happens to find a mentally damaged Megatron in gun form & uses him to make grand robberies. It’s not the only subpar story Budiansky would write but it is by far the worst. Bob, we buy the Transformers comics for the giant robots, not the people they happen to meet. If you were so bothered by Hasbro asking you to keep throwing in new toys maybe you could have used this issue to spread it out a bit more. But still he did a good job overall, even with some of the later ones (especially the Headmasters miniseries).

Overall this is a must-read. This is easily the best of the Transformers Classics without any stories by Simon Furman in them. To be honest while the next 9 issues are good, with a couple exceptions they pale in comparison to the second season of the cartoon (I honestly like to use my imagination of what happened after this & some tweaking of the dialogue here & there to get the series to the point where it’s compatible with the second season), but starting with issue 23 it does get great again, for a little while at least. The next couple volumes are overall a bit spotty, but there’s still some good to be found. For further details, stay tuned for more reviews.
0Comment| 3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on January 23, 2017
Great comic. I am a fan of the 80s cartoon. I watched the reruns as a kid and loved it. This is the comic that started it all! I started collecting these volumes and plan on collecting the UK version when I am done. If your a true fan of the G1 transformers you won't be disappointed. Happy reading!
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 5, 2013
I decided only recently to get into Transformers, and I wanted to start from G1. It was pretty impossible (at least for me) to find scans online, but I bought volume one and two for only about $20 after shipping here on Amazon, which is just fine. From what other people have said, I'm glad I got this newer version instead of the older collection. I like the information about the series and some individual issues. Volume one was really fun to read, a bit corny, being from the 80s, but that's part of the charm. All in all, this volume is a great introduction to the series and I'm really excited to start devouring volume 2!
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on August 28, 2015
Speaking as a diehard Generation One fan and a diehard hater of the live-action movies, I think this book is very worth the while of any serious Transformer fan.

From the beginning of the story, you see that things are different in the Marvel Transformers universe (Yeah, Marvel produced this before it was picked by IDW Comics) than the cartoon. Watching the original G1 Cartoon is recommended, also, before reading these books, but it's not a necessity.

Instead of humans trusting the Autobots right off the bat, most of the humans are like the humans in the horrific Bayformers films where they are distrustful of the Robots at first. However, there are a few humans who trust them, mainly the character of Buster Witwicky (Spike in the cartoons, Sam in the movies...technically). Also, Spider-Man and SHIELD make appearances. How cool is that?

Now, if you are expecting this to be very dynamic and full of action, well, you won't be disappointed, but there is also a LOT of talking in order to establish the characters. There's an entire sequence where the Autobots and Decepticons all sound off and talk about their personalities and individual powers. A little weird and it kind of ruins the pacing.

The thing to look for here is the character of Shockwave, who was set up to be the main villain of Dark of the Moon originally and who is well-known to a lot of fans as a braindead loyalist to Megatron in the show. However, in the comics, he's like an evil version of Spock, relying on pure logic and mathematics to drive him and he is also like Starscream, only unlike Starscream...Shockwave is successful in toppling Megatron who is reduced to a low-level minion for several issues.

Also, you get to see glimpses of what Cybertronian customs and religions are like. How cool is that?
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on May 13, 2013
Sometimes you just can't beat the classics. The differences in the classics comic collection from the '84 and up cartoon is interesting. At first, my sons weren't real impressed because they enjoyed the cartoon more. However, once we all started reading out loud and individually doing the voices for different characters (ones we each prefer), that made it much more enjoyable for them.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on February 6, 2013
We grew up watching this on TV and have introduced it to my son. While he is a bit young (3-1/2) to understand a lot of it, he loves the transformers and the cartoons of the past offer a simplicity no longer found. No one ever dies and while it is action packed, its in a simple good vs. evil format with a lesson being taught in each episode.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on December 12, 2012
I bought this for My Boyfriend for a Christmas present because he Loves the Transformers. He Absolutely Loved this graphic novel ! He is a huge fan of graphic novels. He enjoyed reading this from the Beginning to the End !
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on December 24, 2013
I had never read the original Transformers comics before, so it was great to finally read it. The comics are very good and have good plots. If you love the original comics or want to read them, this is a great buy. This volume contains issues 1-13.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 20, 2014
This volume of the classic comics is amazing. I love this book!
I had never read them before but I found this addicting and I was easily hooked. If you like transformers then you will love this!
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on April 26, 2016
Nostalgia for my youth helped this garner a 2nd star.

If you are a Transformers fan and have not read IDW's "More Than Meets The Eye" series by James Roberts, then Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukkah, Good Kwanzaa and a Wonderful Festivus to you. It is, by far, the greatest piece of work on the Transformers in any genre and it holds up with great comics across the spectrum of choices.

Where to begin with this volume, that has neither aged well nor should be appealing to people over 9:

1) The writing is horrendous. The dialogue and lengthy narrative explanations are silly. "Unknown to even Optimus, his words were heard by the Decepticon Ravage -- whose detection by any monitoring device was virtually impossible."
2) The thought balloons are stupefyingly awful: "Indeed, Starscream! Like presenting yourself as the Decepticon most worthy to lead us! But you overestimate your worth as well as your comrades' gullibility!"
3) The art is inconsistent and often lacks detail.
4) Most of the side plots are awful.
5) The appearance of Spiderman is painful.
6) The characterization is a trainwreck. It is hard to see the differences between characters (again, I direct you towards Roberts' MTMTE series to see a master course in character development and portrayal).

The bright spots:

1) It's 13 issues in a decently bound and printed book for a cheap price.
2) There are a few notes in here about the creation of the Transformers and the rationale behind Spiderman's appearance. These notes are excellent.
3) It's colored well.
4) The Shockwave plot is good. This is the strength of the story.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse