It's good - and filled with footnotes and history. Hutton explains what the cult is doing when it's looking for universal god and goddess forms to incorporate and it includes a lot of historical background on those topics. The kindle translation of the book is also well done and flows nicely.
The writing is dry at times - actually most times. Hutton doesn't hold back his opinion in some places but those places are easy to distinguish from the body of the work.
The main problem I have with Hutton is he doesn't always distinguish from folklore and primary historical sources, and he mixed them freely. No-one takes The Golden Bough literally, but Hutton freely cites it when discussing some of the mythology and The Golden Bough is a mix of folklore and interpretation of myth. Essentially this gives us an exposition on the interpretation of that mythos, and Hutton does this several other places in the book. Best to check the footnotes for what he is citing and make it a regular habit if you want to approach the book from a totally scholarly perspective.
Another example of that is Hutton's treatment of Freemasonry. He treats Freemasonry as one product - a "batteries included, no assembly required" sort of cult. The problem is Freemasonry is far from that. It has its own branches, customs, modes of recognition, and lodge structure. To treat the whole of Freemasonry as a consistent experience is a real head scratcher and it makes it hard to figure out what he's referencing except in the most general sense. It would be safe to assume that he means Blue Lodge and Scottish Rite when he's referencing Masonry. However we run into the same problem as above: His sources are not primary sources, but rather what people have written about Freemasonry in a general sense. This means any argument he puts forward is diluted by interpretation on top of interpretation.
Overall? Good. Worth the read. I don't regret putting the time in. However please be sure to check his footnotes for his sources as they're oftentimes not the best primary works.
- Amazon Business : For business-only pricing, quantity discounts and FREE Shipping. Register a free business account















