I love a number of Ishiguro's other works (The Buried Giant and Never Let Me Go might make a list of my ten all-time favorite novels) and generally consider him one of my favorite authors (alongside Gene Wolfe and George Saunders), but The Unconsoled is a repetitive exercise in frustration which, even if that is part of the point, does not feel worth completing.
Initially, the narrator's experiences being taken off course by people he meets and discovering (sometimes to his own surprise) the deep connections he already has with characters he's seemingly encountering for the first time are intriguing and dreamlike, and there are shades of Kafka in the way people and events conspire to make enacting even his simplest desires impossible. But the same kinds of situations and exchanges repeat themselves over and over, exhausting the concept and Ishiguro's execution of it long before the novel reaches the halfway point.
Reading a scene in which the protagonist finds himself unable to speak just when he's required to identify himself to save another character from horrible humiliation, I wanted to throw the book in frustration. Were this a short story or novella or had Ishiguro varied these dynamics so it was not merely the same structure over and over, this could be quite impactful, but stretched out at such great length (500+ pages) and in such a repetitive way, the novel is tedious and unsatisfying.
Usually, Ishiguro is able to create sharp irony and/or deep emotion out of his characters' confusion about their own lives and circumstances. They may not grasp (or admit) their errors, or the cruelty of their world, but we can understand, relate, and see what was lost or missed. The Unconsoled is almost the opposite: what is often only mildly frustrating for the narrator is tedious punishment for the reader.
Oddly, given the novel is more like a dream than reality, it somehow becomes the one thing dreams almost never are--utterly predictable.
- Amazon Business: Make the most of your Amazon Business account with exclusive tools and savings. Login now
- Amazon Business : For business-only pricing, quantity discounts and FREE Shipping. Register a free business account









