If you read the memoir of one of the original Code Talkers Chester Nez, you will be very disappointed in the way they were depicted in this movie.
To begin, the marines who served with them did not know they were code talkers. Also they were sent into the field in pairs, and they gave constant reports from the front lines in battle, moving after every transmission so as not to be detected. In the pair, one wrote while the other operated the radio. They switched roles when one got tired.
The depiction of an individual marine assigned to shadow them is inaccurate and a fabrication of Hollywood. There could have been marines assigned in their unit with orders to shoot them, but this has never been verified.
The term code talker was not officially released until it was declassified during the Nixon administration in the 70's, up until then their role in the war was classified, even to ground troops who served with them. The code talkers were debriefed before returning home that they could not even tell their families what they did or even mention the existence of the code.
Showing the Navajo code talker going off on his own and bathing, or holding ceremonies is also a stretch.
There are also a lot of other points about the movie that does not align with other memoirs from soldiers who served in the Pacific theatre, like every soldier having a pistol, marines leaving a hill behind a village unguarded and calling it 'secure'. Also the last scene showing a soldier taking home another's dog tags was just not done. Also the terrain looked like the shot the whole film in California.
It's an entertaining action movie, and some of the fight scenes are good. However, if you really want to know the real exciting story, read Chester Nez's memoir and hope that someone comes along and write a script based on those real events.
- Amazon Business : For business-only pricing, quantity discounts and FREE Shipping. Register a free business account