- Publisher: Berkley/ Published By the Berkley Publishing Group/ A Division of Penguin Putnam, Inc.; 6th Printing edition (1999)
- ISBN-10: 0425176428
- ISBN-13: 978-0425176429
- ASIN: B0027NADA0
- Product Dimensions: 9.1 x 5.9 x 1 inches
- Shipping Weight: 1 pounds
- Average Customer Review: 3.9 out of 5 stars See all reviews (132 customer reviews)
- Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #13,232,519 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
Enter your mobile number below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Getting the download link through email is temporarily not available. Please check back later.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
What If? the World's Foremost Military Historians Imagine What Might Have Been Paperback – 1999
|New from||Used from|
See the Best Books of the Month
Want to know our Editors' picks for the best books of the month? Browse Best Books of the Month, featuring our favorite new books in more than a dozen categories.
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Top Customer Reviews
It is true that at times the authors spend far more time summarizing the real-life events than exploring their alternate scenarios in sufficient detail. Although this was probably necessary for a general audience that may not already be aware of the details of Poitiers or the Golden Horde, it did often leave a hungry feeling in the pit of my stomach. In many cases, I wished there had been a much lengthier version of the scenario available.
I also agree that more consideration of "second-order counterfactuals" would have helped, but the general point of this work is well-taken, and should jolt the reader out of the lazy sense of historical determinacy into which we all tend to drift when we're not thinking very hard about the past. As must have happened with many readers, the book also caused me to run through the past 15 years of my own life in search of equally intriguing near-miss counterfactuals-- "what if I had moved to Rhode Island in 1996?", "what if I had married Ms. X after all?" I mention this anecdote because it is good evidence that the book can work its magic on the reader's mind despite the flaws that have been mentioned.
The bottom line is that I found this book hard to put down _despite_ reading it for the most part in a loud and seedy neighborhood bar.
The authors take various approaches to the challenge. Some launch into intriguing 'what ifs' and their consequences. These include the impact of Alexander the Great's pre-mature death, ways the American Revolution could have easily failed and what if the Battle of Midway had been won by Japan. Other authors take a different approach of only reviewing how events could have been different or how variants were avoided, but they never discuss the impact of the alternative event. This is the only weakness of the book in my opinion. Most articles joyfully carry through on the full description of how events could have differed and how the world would be different if they had turned out this way. For example, would Lincoln have negotiated peace with the Confederacy if Lee's orders for Sharpsburg had not fallen into McClellan's hands allowing the South to win this battle?
Finally, the scenarios are relatively realistic. There are no discussions of 'what would have happened if the Americans had automatic weapons in 1776...Read more ›
One of the topics we often discuss is counterfactual history or "What-if" scenarios. It's just plain fun to imagine what might have been if Custer never had a last stand or the Spanish Conquistadors hadn't have conquered the New World. What if Hitler had won W.W.II? The book explores history from this perspective of imagining how things might have been different if our history didn't occur. Having twenty plus distinguished historians who really know their stuff guide you through "what-if" scenarios makes for a good read. By the way, "counterfactual" is the word that academics prefer to use for "what-if" scenarios.
The book's full title is "What of? The World's Foremost military Historians Imagine What Might Have Been." The title fully describes the book's contents and all of the twenty scenarios describe how history could have taken a different turn had factors as uncontrollable as the weather were different. The twenty scenarios range from ancient history and the siege of Jerusalem by the Assyrians to the final scenario supposing what if Mao and the Chinese Communists hadn't have defeated Chiang Kai-Shek and the Chinese Nationalists. Every scenario was well written and discussed. The book has already provided my friend and I with great conversational fodder.
The book includes essays by: William H. McNeil, Victor Davis Hanson, Josiah Ober, Lewis H. Lapham, Barry S. Strauss, Cecilia Holland, Theodore K. Rabb, Ross Hassig, Geoffrey Parker, Thomas Fleming, David McCullough, Allistair Horne, James M. McPherson, Stephen W. Sears, Robert Cowley, John Keegan, Theodore F. Cook Jr.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
I really enjoy history and in this book the realities of the vagaries that influence the big picture of history and how things turn out comes home strongly.Published 5 months ago by Cathy
A very unique way to think about events of the past that have shaped history. This book uses the insights and ideas from people in various fields, not just history, as they run... Read morePublished 10 months ago by arbole
Good clean fun exploring various historical events and asking: what if they had turned out differently? Read morePublished 10 months ago by Sturmey Archer
My grown son who is a history buff loved this book with essays pondering what "might have been" if things had gone differently in history.Published 16 months ago by dlorac
My husband loves this book. He likes that they are like short stories to read that you can read just one at a time.Published 19 months ago by Wendy Patrick
The various authors have a very good knowledge of military and historical studies to present their conclusions.Published 19 months ago by Jorge Almeida Ch
The first volume of historical essays that speculate what would have happened if an event had gone in a different direction. Read morePublished 20 months ago by Mr. Linguist
WHAT IF ?, Eminent Historians Imagine What Might Have Been , I have to say up front, I enjoy these books and there are many out there. This one is good. Read morePublished 21 months ago by Wooley in PSL
I assigned essays from this book to my students. I like that it makes the reader think of alternative endings to what too many see as the inevitable outcomes of world history... Read morePublished on December 21, 2013 by Margaret Q. Dienhoffer