Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
I Would Find a Girl Walking: Every Female Was Prey Mass Market Paperback – April 5, 2011
See the Best Books of 2018 So Far
Looking for something great to read? Browse our editors' picks for the best books of the year so far in fiction, nonfiction, mysteries, children's books, and much more.
About the Author
Diana Montane is a reporter, editor, and published author. She was Arts & Entertainment writer, as well as art theatre and film critic for The Miami News.She has co-written six true crime books, including I Would Find a Girl Walking. She holds a B.A., M.A., and M.F.A. in Theatre and Communications, from the University of Miami, Coral Gables, Florida.
Kate Kelly is a staff reporter for The Wall Street Journal and a former reporter for Time magazine and the New York Observer. She attracted international attention for her three-part series of articles on Bear Stearns, which ran on the front pages of The Wall Street Journal in May 2008. This is her first book. She lives in Brooklyn, New York.
Top customer reviews
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
The first several chapters of the book focus upon individual victims and the lack of evidence at the crime scenes. I was approximately 1/3 of the way into the book when the first, subtle feelings of boredom began to grow. These chapters were somewhat repetitious and, while this is not necessarily the fault of the author, the victims began to meld into one amorphous mass. Each girl Gerald Stano picked up was like many of the others. Some were prostitutes, some were hitchhiking, some were just walking toward a destination. What prompted so many women to climb into the car of a man they did not know is really beyond comprehension.
Taken from his biological mother before he was 1 year of age, Stano was adopted by stable, caring parents. Further, he was adopted early enough that one might think any damage suffered during the first months of his life had been mitigated. Apparently not. Gerald Stano was a comupulsive liar and was perceived by peers throughout his childhood as strange and socially inept. Often in trouble with adult authority, Stano nurtured dark obsessions and abberant fantasies for years before he first killed a woman.
All of this information seems to suggest a book that would be interesting and insightful. However, it is not. Despite the inclusion of some 40 letters Stano wrote to the author/reporter, Kathy Kelly, there is not much psychological exploration of these letters. Many are simply printed, one after the other, without comment from the author or anyone else. What comments the author does make about these letters are rather abreviated, given the extensive forensic and psychological examination that might have been done.
Stano also included many comments about the author's visits, her appearance, and their relationship. While these elements of the letters were somewhat more interesting, there was little analysis from the author or a forensic psychiatrist about the changing nature of these letters. Stano clearly perceived the author as significantly more interested in him than she was and, consistent with his inflated feelings about himself, imagined himself a boyfriend or potential boyfriend to the author. As a woman, I found these aspects of Stano's letters sometimes laughable, often repulsive, and clearly delusional.
Stano is a repulsive man and, in many ways, a very boring man. While his crimes may have been notorious, Stano himself was a doughy, unsophisticated man who lacked appeal of any kind. He confessed to and then lied about some of his crimes, so it impossible to know what portions of Stano's confessions are true. Stano even recanted his confession of the killing of a 12 year old girl whom he knew from the skating rink. There is a photograph of Stano attempting to help police locate the body of this child. Therefore, his later recantation of this particular crime to the police and the author is nothing short of unbelievable and, on a personal level, a disgusting indulgence for the offender.
I found it interesting that Stano sent the author several childhood photographs of himself. These photographs would have been very interesting to view. However, the author stated in a small footnote at the bottom of one page that although she made copies of these photographs, she was unable to locate them later. This is odd given that the author kept all of Stano's letters in a single box and was never unclear to Stano or anyone else about her intent to write a book someday. Yet, she misplaces the photographs.
Finally, the book notes that Stano confessed to nearly 40 murders. However, there is only mention of approximately 12 victims and no explanation about what other confessions Stano made that may have led investigators to belive he killed as many as 40 women. I found this a regrettable oversight of the book and it contributed to the general feelings of dissatisfaction and lack of completeness that I experienced.
In short, the book was neither terrible nor terribly interesting. Many portions of the book were repititous and boring and I was relieved when I finally finished it so that I could move on to something else. I am somewhat surprised and confused about the many 5 star reviews of this book. While everyone is entitled to his or her opinion, I would encourage True Crime fans to either buy a used copy or visit the local library. I regret paying full price for this book.
Rarely does a book start out great then I can't finish it - as soon as I started this - I couldn't even tell you what it was, just wasn't for me...I am an Ann Rule fan - her last couple haven't been the best but early Ann Rule??? Nothing beats her and I guess I hold true crime up to a high standard, unfortunately, there are a lot of writers out there who cannot tell a story.
To be honest, I remember the killer's name is Gerald and thats it, he was boring, no wonder he was jealous of Ted Bundy - if you're going to "rate" killers at least Ted was an interesting scumbag,,,
maybe it was the way the author wrote it - I can't tell...I don't even recommend it
The letters got very repetitive,the victims were just a small piece and I realize this book was more about Stano.
It was interesting reading about his parents and upbringing but I would have liked it to go more in depth. I don't feel like a learned alot about him other than he was a serial killer who killed when he felt women were finding him unattractive,oh and he was a jerk.I would have detested having to exchange letters with him.
I think the book could have been better if some of the letters had of been left out,more family stuff put in and more about the How? Where? Why? that TC readers enjoy reading about.
I would not hesitate to read another book by this author as it wasn't horrible,Just dull.