The Wrong War: Grit, Strategy, and the Way Out of Afghanistan Hardcover – February 22, 2011
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Frequently bought together
What is this book about? I bring the reader onto the toughest battlefields in order to show what the war really is – a series of short, sharp clashes between our soldiers and the Taliban. This is hard stuff, and our rules of engagement are too strict. It’s nonsense to say wars aren’t won by killing and bloodshed. That’s how the terrorists seized power, and they have to be destroyed. Our troops understand this; our leaders do not. What is our goal in Afghanistan? Are we fighting to win? In 2009, President Obama said the goal was to “defeat the Taliban.” In 2011, he downgraded the goal to “preventing the Taliban from reestablishing a stranglehold over the Afghan people.” He no longer intends to win by defeating our enemy. Whether we settle for a tie by negotiations remains to be seen. What does your title, The Wrong War, mean? Afghanistan was the wrong war for our strategy of benevolent counterinsurgency. Our strategy has been to give money and some protection to the Pashtun tribes in order to win over their hearts and minds. In return, the Pashtuns were expected to stand against the Taliban who were, in fact, their stronger relatives. This strategy has failed. The Pashtuns have not rejected the Taliban. I bring the reader onto the battlefields in the mountains of the north and the poppy fields of the south to show why. Do our troops care about politics, or do they fight for one another? They fight for one another. But -- they volunteered to be grunts before they ever met one another. They wanted the adventure - the chance to prove themselves in battle- and to serve their country. But our generals have to set achievable goals. Otherwise grunts become cynical. Few of our grunts now believe we are winning hearts and minds, as our generals claim. Does Pakistan control the outcome in Afghanistan? Pakistan provides a vast sanctuary, and refuses to arrest the top Taliban leaders. Pakistan lacks the resources and determination to move against the sanctuaries. Afghanistan can remain intact only by developing a strong army to fight along the Pak border. What has been the main mistake in the war? We’re paying the bills, taking casualties and doing the fighting. Yet we ceded total sovereign control to an untrustworthy Karzai,. Our greatest mistake was not keeping some control over the finances and the promotions of the Afghan security forces. Six US generals have failed in Afghanistan. Why? Either we had six incompetents, or we have to acknowledge that very, very few men speak truth to power. On the one hand, our military was too strong to lose. On the other hand, Afghanistan was so vast and so chaotic that our mission of nation-building required three times the number of troops we committed. Our generals knew this. Yet Presidents Bush and Obama did not know. What is the book’s basic message? Our troops are trying to protect and provide projects to Pashtun tribes that are hurtling headlong into the 10th Century. Our strategy is kind and liberal, but it will take another ten years and one trillion dollars to nudge Afghanistan into a progressive, democratic, economically viable state. We don’t have that time. Our vital interest is to prevent a takeover of Kabul by the Taliban radicals. We can prevent this by reducing our troop levels and placing the Afghan soldiers in the lead, with American advisers. That is why my book brings the readers into combat with both British and American adviser teams. We must change what we are doing.
From Publishers Weekly
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
- ASIN : 1400068738
- Publisher : Random House; First Edition first Printing (February 22, 2011)
- Language : English
- Hardcover : 336 pages
- ISBN-10 : 9781400068739
- ISBN-13 : 978-1400068739
- Item Weight : 1.4 pounds
- Dimensions : 6.31 x 1.05 x 9.51 inches
- Best Sellers Rank: #1,734,737 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- Customer Reviews:
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
In a slow death spiral to the Taliban. Presenting personal insights into soldiers who have made the ultimate sacrifice and soldiers still in the fight Bing connects the necessary elements to clearly give the reader necessary data to begin to understand the situation the US and its partner's face today. Not pulling any punches the evolution of US civilian leadership and in turn US military leadership have combined as Bing illustrates to have created the quagmire in Afghanistan today. A great read. A troubling read. Exactly the book I expected from Bing. I give the book 5 stars
What is the bottomline? Mr. West captures the essence of how to be successful. It is not "protecting the people". It is getting the Afghans to protect the people. Our effort should be an advisory effort to develop a functioning Afghan Army and Afghan Police Force. The advisors must be embedded with the Afghans. It is going to take a long time. But we should be able to reduce our total manpower level as we transition to "advising".