What Thomas Cahill has delivered in this small, interesting volume cannot be considered serious history. It's more in the vein of what you might catch on the History Channel: Take a few historical figures, add a dash of overstimulated credulity, and rush it to press.
So, where to begin? There are historical mistakes, presumptions, and misrepresentations on almost every page, so we'll take small representative nuggets.
On page 35, Cahill writes of "the death of the last western emperor in 476." Umm, no. The last emperor was Romulus Augustulus. He was a teenager when we was deposed by Odovacar in 476, and lived on afterward to possibly as late as 507 A.D.
On page 195, amidst a push for female ordination, we find this strange offering: "At Amay in Belgium there was even discovered in 1977 a sarcophagus, ornamented in the Celtic manner and showing the image of a woman (mysteriously labeled 'Saint Chrodoara') who carries a bishop's crozier." Cahill seems unaware that when the leader of an abbey was installed by a bishop, that leader received a copy of the rule, a ring, a pectoral cross, and a CROZIER. The leader of the abbey might be a male abbot, or in the case of a female abbey, an abbess. Many abbesses even today still can be seen with a crozier.
These two mistakes near the beginning and end of the book sandwich dozens of similar ones. Anyone can look up these simple facts, and it's rather amazing that Cahill did not. Instead, he likes to tease with his own historical inventions, a la Dan Brown.
Cahill seems bent on reading 20th century sentiments into 5th century history, continually poking at the early Roman church in a thinly veiled attack on today's church leadership. (See his obligatory abortion plug on page 178.) And while he claims that the legacy of Augustine of Hippo has the Roman hierarchy obsessed with sexual morality where Patrick and his followers are not, it seems that it's Cahill who's obsessed. It crops up continually in this book. Consider this passage from page 149: "As late as the last [19th] century naked men (and, for all we know, women) raced horses bareback along Clare's beaches through the surf at high tide, looking for all the world like their prehistoric warrior ancestors." For all we know? That's to be taken as serious history? At least Cahill gives his source for this conjecture, in the notes on page 229: "The reference to naked riders ... originates in a wonderful talk I heard in 1970." A talk? Originates in 1970? This was the 19th century; no reports? no photos? no records?
Cahill insists that we have the Irish to thank for private confession, claiming that the Roman church had only public penance until then. But he seems to conflate or confuse confession with penance. Plenty of Church Fathers, long before Patrick, understood the need for—and advocated—private confession, even if the subsequent penance was public.
Cahill presents the Irish Church not so much as saving civilization, but downright opposed to it. Everything hinges (to borrow his word) on Irish Catholicism vs. Roman Catholicism. It comes to an historical head at the Synod of Whitby in 664, which you'd think might be the climax of the book. Instead, it appears at the end in anticlimax. Cahill is disappointed that the synod agenda is topped by the seemingly trivial matters of calendars and haircuts. Maybe, Mr. Cahill, that's because in important matters, like confession, eucharist, ordination, authority, monastic structures, ascetic practices, and even sexual ethics, there was no conflict or disagreement between them, much as you try to portray differently. "What is far more impressive about the period as a whole—and perhaps even about what actually happened at Whitby—is the close fraternal cooperation between the Irish and the English. ... If Christians of different tribes had in all ages cooperated with one another as did these men and women, the world would be a very different place." (p. 202) It would have been nice if Cahill himself adopted this attitude when writing the book. Instead, his personal axes are ground on every page.
I give this book 2 stars, because it's a fast, fun, provocative read. If you are not familiar with the main characters, it provides an introduction to them and their milieu. But other than that, this book does not serve history well.
Other Sellers on Amazon
$11.91
+ $15.48 shipping
+ $15.48 shipping
Sold by:
Book_sales
Sold by:
Book_sales
(47 ratings)
100% positive
100% positive
Only 1 left in stock - order soon.
Shipping rates
and
Return policy
$12.00
+ $15.48 shipping
+ $15.48 shipping
Sold by:
Siegred's Books
Sold by:
Siegred's Books
(232 ratings)
100% positive over last 12 months
100% positive over last 12 months
Only 1 left in stock - order soon.
Shipping rates
and
Return policy
$13.00
+ $15.48 shipping
+ $15.48 shipping
Sold by:
Lime Seed
Sold by:
Lime Seed
(33 ratings)
97% positive over last 12 months
97% positive over last 12 months
Only 1 left in stock - order soon.
Shipping rates
and
Return policy
Add to book club
Loading your book clubs
There was a problem loading your book clubs. Please try again.
Not in a club?
Learn more
Join or create book clubs
Choose books together
Track your books
Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club that’s right for you for free.
Flip to back
Flip to front
Follow the Author
Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.
OK
How the Irish Saved Civilization: The Untold Story of Ireland's Heroic Role From the Fall of Rome to the Rise of Medieval Europe (The Hinges of History) Paperback – Unabridged, February 1, 1996
by
Thomas Cahill
(Author)
|
Thomas Cahill
(Author)
Find all the books, read about the author, and more.
See search results for this author
|
|
Price
|
New from | Used from |
|
Audible Audiobook, Unabridged
"Please retry"
|
$0.00
|
Free with your Audible trial | |
-
Print length246 pages
-
LanguageEnglish
-
PublisherAnchor
-
Publication dateFebruary 1, 1996
-
Dimensions5.17 x 0.58 x 7.99 inches
-
ISBN-100385418493
-
ISBN-13978-0385418492
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
-
Apple
-
Android
-
Windows Phone
-
Android
|
Download to your computer
|
Kindle Cloud Reader
|
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
The Gifts of the Jews: How a Tribe of Desert Nomads Changed the Way Everyone Thinks and Feels (The Hinges of History)PaperbackFREE Shipping by AmazonIn stock soon.
The Story We Carry in Our Bones: Irish History for AmericansPaperback$19.16$19.16+ $35.48 shippingIn Stock.
Customers who bought this item also bought
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
The Gifts of the Jews: How a Tribe of Desert Nomads Changed the Way Everyone Thinks and Feels (The Hinges of History)PaperbackFREE Shipping by AmazonIn stock soon.
The Story We Carry in Our Bones: Irish History for AmericansPaperback$19.16$19.16+ $35.48 shippingIn Stock.
Editorial Reviews
Amazon.com Review
In this delightful and illuminating look into a crucial but little-known "hinge" of history, Thomas Cahill takes us to the "island of saints and scholars," the Ireland of St. Patrick and the Book of Kells. Here, far from the barbarian despoliation of the continent, monks and scribes laboriously, lovingly, even playfully preserved the West's written treasury. When stability returned in Europe, these Irish scholars were instrumental in spreading learning, becoming not only the conservators of civilization, but also the shapers of the medieval mind, putting their unique stamp on Western culture.
From Publishers Weekly
An account of the pivotal role played by Irish monks in transcribing and preserving Classical civilization during the Dark Ages.
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
We usually associate the preservation of Greek and Roman learning with the Muslim world, but here Cahill brings to light the vital role also played by Irish monks and scribes during the time of St. Patrick and the Book of Kells.
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
"Charming and poetic...an entirely engaging, delectable voyage into th edistant past, a small treasure." —The New York Times
"A lovely and engrossing tale . . . Graceful and instructive." —Richard Eder, Los Angeles Times
"Cahill's lively prose breathes life into a 1,600-year-old history." —The Boston Globe
"A lovely and engrossing tale . . . Graceful and instructive." —Richard Eder, Los Angeles Times
"Cahill's lively prose breathes life into a 1,600-year-old history." —The Boston Globe
From the Publisher
The perfect St. Patrick's Day gift, and a book in the best tradition of popular history -- the untold story of Ireland's role in maintaining Western culture while the Dark Ages settled on Europe. Every year millions of Americans celebrate St. Patrick's Day, but they may not be aware of how great an influence St. Patrick was on the subsequent history of civilization. Not only did he bring Christianity to Ireland, he instilled a sense of literacy and learning that would create the conditions that allowed Ireland to become "the isle of saints and scholars" -- and thus preserve Western culture while Europe was being overrun by barbarians. In this entertaining and compelling narrative, Thomas Cahill tells the story of how Europe evolved front the classical age of Rome to the medieval era. Without Ireland, the transition could not have taken place. Not only did Irish monks and scribes maintain the very record of Western civilization -- copying manuscripts of Greek and Latin writers, both pagan and Christian, while libraries and learning on the continent were forever lost -- they brought their uniquely Irish world-view to the task. As Cahill delightfully illustrates, so much of the liveliness we associate with medieval culture has its roots in Ireland. When the seeds of culture were replanted on the European continent, it was from Ireland that they were germinated. In the tradition of Barbara Tuchmail's A Distant Mirror, How The Irish Saved Civilization reconstructs an era that few know about but which is central to understanding our past and our cultural heritage. But it conveys its knowledge with a winking wit that aptly captures the sensibility of the unsung Irish who relaunched civilization.
"A lovely and engrossing tale . . . Graceful and instructive."--Richard Eder, Los Angeles Times
"Cahill's lively prose breathes life into a 1,600-year-old history."--The Boston Globe
From the Inside Flap
The perfect St. Patrick's Day gift, and a book in the best tradition of popular history -- the untold story of Ireland's role in maintaining Western culture while the Dark Ages settled on Europe.
Every year millions of Americans celebrate St. Patrick's Day, but they may not be aware of how great an influence St. Patrick was on the subsequent history of civilization. Not only did he bring Christianity to Ireland, he instilled a sense of literacy and learning that would create the conditions that allowed Ireland to become "the isle of saints and scholars" -- and thus preserve Western culture while Europe was being overrun by barbarians.
In this entertaining and compelling narrative, Thomas Cahill tells the story of how Europe evolved from the classical age of Rome to the medieval era. Without Ireland, the transition could not have taken place. Not only did Irish monks and scribes maintain the very record of Western civilization -- copying manuscripts of Greek and Latin writers, both pagan and Christian, while libraries and learning on the continent were forever lost -- they brought their uniquely Irish world-view to the task.
As Cahill delightfully illustrates, so much of the liveliness we associate with medieval culture has its roots in Ireland. When the seeds of culture were replanted on the European continent, it was from Ireland that they were germinated.
In the tradition of Barbara Tuchman's A Distant Mirror, How The Irish Saved Civilization reconstructs an era that few know about but which is central to understanding our past and our cultural heritage. But it conveys its knowledge with a winking wit that aptly captures the sensibility of the unsung Irish who relaunched civilization.
Every year millions of Americans celebrate St. Patrick's Day, but they may not be aware of how great an influence St. Patrick was on the subsequent history of civilization. Not only did he bring Christianity to Ireland, he instilled a sense of literacy and learning that would create the conditions that allowed Ireland to become "the isle of saints and scholars" -- and thus preserve Western culture while Europe was being overrun by barbarians.
In this entertaining and compelling narrative, Thomas Cahill tells the story of how Europe evolved from the classical age of Rome to the medieval era. Without Ireland, the transition could not have taken place. Not only did Irish monks and scribes maintain the very record of Western civilization -- copying manuscripts of Greek and Latin writers, both pagan and Christian, while libraries and learning on the continent were forever lost -- they brought their uniquely Irish world-view to the task.
As Cahill delightfully illustrates, so much of the liveliness we associate with medieval culture has its roots in Ireland. When the seeds of culture were replanted on the European continent, it was from Ireland that they were germinated.
In the tradition of Barbara Tuchman's A Distant Mirror, How The Irish Saved Civilization reconstructs an era that few know about but which is central to understanding our past and our cultural heritage. But it conveys its knowledge with a winking wit that aptly captures the sensibility of the unsung Irish who relaunched civilization.
From the Back Cover
The perfect St. Patrick's Day gift, and a book in the best tradition of popular history -- the untold story of Ireland's role in maintaining Western culture while the Dark Ages settled on Europe.
Every year millions of Americans celebrate St. Patrick's Day, but they may not be aware of how great an influence St. Patrick was on the subsequent history of civilization. Not only did he bring Christianity to Ireland, he instilled a sense of literacy and learning that would create the conditions that allowed Ireland to become "the isle of saints and scholars" -- and thus preserve Western culture while Europe was being overrun by barbarians.
In this entertaining and compelling narrative, Thomas Cahill tells the story of how Europe evolved from the classical age of Rome to the medieval era. Without Ireland, the transition could not have taken place. Not only did Irish monks and scribes maintain the very record of Western civilization -- copying manuscripts of Greek and Latin writers, both pagan and Christian, while libraries and learning on the continent were forever lost -- they brought their uniquely Irish world-view to the task.
As Cahill delightfully illustrates, so much of the liveliness we associate with medieval culture has its roots in Ireland. When the seeds of culture were replanted on the European continent, it was from Ireland that they were germinated.
In the tradition of Barbara Tuchman's A Distant Mirror, How The Irish Saved Civilization reconstructs an era that few know about but which is central to understanding our past and our cultural heritage. But it conveys its knowledge with a winking wit that aptly captures the sensibility of the unsung Irish whorelaunched civilization.
Every year millions of Americans celebrate St. Patrick's Day, but they may not be aware of how great an influence St. Patrick was on the subsequent history of civilization. Not only did he bring Christianity to Ireland, he instilled a sense of literacy and learning that would create the conditions that allowed Ireland to become "the isle of saints and scholars" -- and thus preserve Western culture while Europe was being overrun by barbarians.
In this entertaining and compelling narrative, Thomas Cahill tells the story of how Europe evolved from the classical age of Rome to the medieval era. Without Ireland, the transition could not have taken place. Not only did Irish monks and scribes maintain the very record of Western civilization -- copying manuscripts of Greek and Latin writers, both pagan and Christian, while libraries and learning on the continent were forever lost -- they brought their uniquely Irish world-view to the task.
As Cahill delightfully illustrates, so much of the liveliness we associate with medieval culture has its roots in Ireland. When the seeds of culture were replanted on the European continent, it was from Ireland that they were germinated.
In the tradition of Barbara Tuchman's A Distant Mirror, How The Irish Saved Civilization reconstructs an era that few know about but which is central to understanding our past and our cultural heritage. But it conveys its knowledge with a winking wit that aptly captures the sensibility of the unsung Irish whorelaunched civilization.
About the Author
THOMAS CAHILL is the author of the best-selling books, How the Irish Saved Civilization: The Untold Story of Ireland’s Heroic Role from the Fall of Rome to the Rise of Medieval Europe, The Gifts of the Jews: How a Tribe of Desert Nomads Changed the Way Everyone Thinks and Feels, Desire of the Everlasting Hills: The World Before and After Jesus, Sailing the Wine-Dark Sea: Why the Greeks Matter, Mysteries of the Middle Ages: And the Beginning of the Modern World, and, most recently, Heretics and Heroes: How Renaissance Artists and Reformation Priests Created Our World. These six books comprise Volumes I, II, III, IV, V, and VI, respectively, of the Hinges of History, a prospective seven-volume series in which the author recounts formative moments in Western civilization. In "The Hinges of History," Thomas Cahill endeavors to retell the story of the Western World through little-known stories of the great gift-givers, people who contributed immensely to Western, culture and the evolution of Western sensibility, thus revealing how we have become the people we are and why we think and feel the way we do today.
Thomas Cahill is best known, in his books and lectures, for taking on a broad scope of complex history and distilling it into accessible, instructive, and entertaining narrative. His lively, engaging writing animates cultures that existed up to five millennia ago, revealing the lives of his principal characters with refreshing insight and joy. He writes history, not in its usual terms of war and catastrophe, but as "narratives of grace, the recountings of those blessed and inexplicable moments when someone did something for someone else, saved a life, bestowed a gift, gave something beyond what was required by circumstance." Unlike all too many history lessons, a Thomas Cahill history book or speech is impossible to forget.
He has taught at Queens College, Fordham University and Seton Hall University, served as the North American education correspondent for the Times of London, and was for many years a regular contributor to the Los Angeles Times Book Review. Prior to retiring recently to write full-time, he was director of religious publishing at Doubleday for six years. He and his wife, Susan, also an author, founded the now legendary Cahill & Company, whose reader’s catalogue was much beloved in literary households throughout the country. They divide their time between New York, Rome and Paris.
Thomas Cahill is best known, in his books and lectures, for taking on a broad scope of complex history and distilling it into accessible, instructive, and entertaining narrative. His lively, engaging writing animates cultures that existed up to five millennia ago, revealing the lives of his principal characters with refreshing insight and joy. He writes history, not in its usual terms of war and catastrophe, but as "narratives of grace, the recountings of those blessed and inexplicable moments when someone did something for someone else, saved a life, bestowed a gift, gave something beyond what was required by circumstance." Unlike all too many history lessons, a Thomas Cahill history book or speech is impossible to forget.
He has taught at Queens College, Fordham University and Seton Hall University, served as the North American education correspondent for the Times of London, and was for many years a regular contributor to the Los Angeles Times Book Review. Prior to retiring recently to write full-time, he was director of religious publishing at Doubleday for six years. He and his wife, Susan, also an author, founded the now legendary Cahill & Company, whose reader’s catalogue was much beloved in literary households throughout the country. They divide their time between New York, Rome and Paris.
Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.
The word Irish is seldom coupled with the word civilization. When we think of peoples as civilized or civilizing, the Egyptians and the Greeks, the Italians and the French, the Chinese and the Jews may all come to mind. The Irish are wild, feckless, and charming, or morose, repressed, and corrupt, but not especially civilized. If we strain to think of "Irish civilization," no image appears, no Fertile Crescent or Indus Valley, no brooding bust of Beethoven. The simplest Greek auto mechanic will name his establishment "Parthenon," thus linking himself to an imagined ancestral culture. A semiliterate restaurateur of Sicilian origin will give pride of place to his plaster copy of Michelangelo's David, and so assert his presumed Renaissance ties. But an Irish businessman is far more likely to name his concern "The Breffni Bar" or "Kelly's Movers," announcing a merely local or personal connection, unburdened by the resonances of history or civilization.
And yet . . . Ireland, a little island at the edge of Europe that has known neither Renaissance nor Enlightenment--in some ways, a Third World country with, as John Betjeman claimed, a Stone Age culture had one moment of unblemished glory. For, as the Roman Empire fell, as all through Europe matted, unwashed barbarians descended on the Roman cities, looting artifacts and burning books, the Irish, who were just learning to read and write, took up the great labor of copying all of western literature--everything they could lay their hands on. These scribes then served as conduits through which the Greco-Roman and Judeo-Christian cultures were transmitted to the tribes of Europe, newly settled amid the rubble and ruined vineyards of the civilization they had overwhelmed. Without this Service of the Scribes, everything that happened subsequently would have been unthinkable. Without the Mission of the Irish Monks, who single-handedly refounded European civilization throughout the continent in the bays and valleys of their exile, the world that came after them would have been an entirely different one--a world without books. And our own world would never have come to be.
Not for a thousand years--not since the Spartan Legion had perished at the Hot Gates of Thermopylae had western civilization been put to such a test or faced such odds, nor would it again face extinction till in this century it devised the means of extinguishing all life. As our story opens at the beginning of the fifth century, no one could foresee the coming collapse. But to reasonable men in the second half of the century, surveying the situation of their time, the end was no longer in doubt: their world was finished. One could do nothing but, like Ausonius, retire to one's villa, write poetry, and await the inevitable. It never occurred to them that the building blocks of their world would be saved by outlandish oddities from a land so marginal that the Romans had not bothered to conquer it, by men so strange they lived in little huts on rocky outcrops and shaved half their heads and tortured themselves with fasts and chills and nettle baths. As Kenneth Clark said, "Looking back from the great civilizations of twelfth-century France or seventeenth-century Rome, it is hard to believe that for quite a long time--almost a hundred years--western Christianity survived by clinging to places like Skellig Michael, a pinnacle of rock eighteen miles from the Irish coast, rising seven hundred feet out of the sea."
Clark, who began his Civilisation with a chapter (called "The Skin of Our Teeth") on the precarious transition from classical to medieval, is an exception in that he gives full weight to the Irish contribution. Many historians fail to mention it entirely, and few advert to the breathtaking drama of this cultural cliffhanger. This is probably because it is easier to describe stasis (classical, then medieval) than movement (classical to medieval). It is also true that historians are generally expert in one period or the other, so that analysis of the transition falls outside their--and everyone's?--competence. At all events, I know of no single book now in print that is devoted to the subject of the transition, nor even one in which this subject plays a substantial part.
In looking to remedy this omission, we may as well ask ourselves the big question: How real is history? Is it just an enormous soup, so full of disparate ingredients that it is uncharacterizable? Is it true, as Emil Cioran has remarked, that history proves nothing because it contains everything? Is not the reverse side of this that history can be made to say whatever we wish it to?
I think, rather, that every age writes history anew, reviewing deeds and texts of other ages from its own vantage point. Our history, the history we read in school and refer to in later life, was largely written by Protestant Englishmen and Anglo-Saxon Protestant Americans. Just as certain contemporary historians have been discovering that such redactors are not always reliable when it comes to the contributions of, say, women or African Americans, we should not be surprised to find that such storytellers have overlooked a tremendous contribution in the distant past that was both Celtic and Catholic, a contribution without which European civilization would have been impossible.
To an educated Englishman of the last century, for instance, the Irish were by their very nature incapable of civilization. "The Irish," proclaimed Benjamin Disraeli, Queen Victoria's beloved prime minister, "hate our order, our civilization, our enterprising industry, our pure religion [Disraeli's father had abandoned Judaism for the Church of England]. This wild, reckless, indolent, uncertain and superstitious race have no sympathy with the English character. Their ideal of human felicity is an alternation of clannish broils and coarse idolatry [i.e., Catholicism]. Their history describes an unbroken circle of bigotry [!] and blood." The venomous racism and knuckle-headed prejudice of this characterization may be evident to us, but in the days of "dear old Dizzy," as the queen called the man who had presented her with India, it simply passed for indisputable truth.
Occasionally, of course, even the smug colonists of the little queen's empire would experience a momentary qualm: Could the conquerors possibly be responsible for the state of the colonized? But they quickly suppressed any doubt and wrapped themselves in their impervious superiority, as in this response by the historian Charles Kingsley to the famine-induced destitution he witnessed in Victorian Ireland: "I am daunted by the human chimpanzees I saw along that hundred miles of horrible country. I don't believe they are our fault [emphasis mine]. I believe that there are not only many more of them than of old, but that they are happier, better and more comfortably fed and lodged under our rule than they ever were. But to see white chimpanzees is dreadful; if they were black, one would not feel it so much, but their skins, except where tanned by exposure, are as white as ours."
Nor can we comfort ourselves that such thinking passed long ago from the scene. As the distinguished Princeton historian Anthony Grafton wrote recently in The New York Review of Books of history departments at the better American universities: "Catholic culture--like most Catholics--was usually disdained, as the province of lesser breeds fit only for the legendary parochial schools where nuns told their charges never to order ravioli on a date, lest their boy friends be reminded of pillows. Stereotypes and prejudices of this kind, as nasty as anything fastened upon Jews, persisted in American universities until an uncomfortably recent date."
That date may be only the day before yesterday. Yet this is not to accuse any historian of deliberate falsification. No, the problem is more subtle than deception--and artfully described by John Henry Newman in his fable of the Man and the Lion:
The Man once invited the Lion to be his guest, and received him with princely hospitality. The Lion had the run of a magnificent palace, in which there were a vast many things to admire. There were large saloons and long corridors, richly furnished and decorated, and filled with a profusion of fine specimens of sculpture and painting, the works of the first masters in either art. The subjects represented were various; but the most prominent of them had an especial interest for the noble animal who stalked by them. It was that of the Lion himself; and as the owner of the mansion led him from one apartment into another, he did not fail to direct his attention to the indirect homage which these various groups and tableaux paid to the importance of the lion tribe.
There was, however, one remarkable feature in all of them, to which the host, silent as he was from politeness, seemed not at all insensible; that diverse as were these representations, in one point they all agreed, that the man was always victorious, and the lion was always overcome.
It is not that the Lion has been excluded from the history of art, but rather that he has been presented badly--and he never wins. When the Lion had finished his tour of the mansion, continues Newman, "his entertainer asked him what he thought of the splendours it contained; and he in reply did full justice to the riches of its owner and the skill of its decorators, but he added, 'Lions would have fared better, had lions been the artists.'"
In the course of this history, we shall meet many entertainers, persons of substance who have their story to tell, some of whom may believe that their story is all there is to tell. We shall be gracious and give them a hearing without disparagement. We shall even attempt to see things from their point of view. But every once in a while we shall find ourselves entertaining lions. At which moments, it will be every reader for himself.
We begin, however, not in the land of lions, but in the orderly, predictable world of Rome. For in order to appreciate the significance of the Irish contribution, we need first to take an inventory of the civilized empire of late antiquity.
And yet . . . Ireland, a little island at the edge of Europe that has known neither Renaissance nor Enlightenment--in some ways, a Third World country with, as John Betjeman claimed, a Stone Age culture had one moment of unblemished glory. For, as the Roman Empire fell, as all through Europe matted, unwashed barbarians descended on the Roman cities, looting artifacts and burning books, the Irish, who were just learning to read and write, took up the great labor of copying all of western literature--everything they could lay their hands on. These scribes then served as conduits through which the Greco-Roman and Judeo-Christian cultures were transmitted to the tribes of Europe, newly settled amid the rubble and ruined vineyards of the civilization they had overwhelmed. Without this Service of the Scribes, everything that happened subsequently would have been unthinkable. Without the Mission of the Irish Monks, who single-handedly refounded European civilization throughout the continent in the bays and valleys of their exile, the world that came after them would have been an entirely different one--a world without books. And our own world would never have come to be.
Not for a thousand years--not since the Spartan Legion had perished at the Hot Gates of Thermopylae had western civilization been put to such a test or faced such odds, nor would it again face extinction till in this century it devised the means of extinguishing all life. As our story opens at the beginning of the fifth century, no one could foresee the coming collapse. But to reasonable men in the second half of the century, surveying the situation of their time, the end was no longer in doubt: their world was finished. One could do nothing but, like Ausonius, retire to one's villa, write poetry, and await the inevitable. It never occurred to them that the building blocks of their world would be saved by outlandish oddities from a land so marginal that the Romans had not bothered to conquer it, by men so strange they lived in little huts on rocky outcrops and shaved half their heads and tortured themselves with fasts and chills and nettle baths. As Kenneth Clark said, "Looking back from the great civilizations of twelfth-century France or seventeenth-century Rome, it is hard to believe that for quite a long time--almost a hundred years--western Christianity survived by clinging to places like Skellig Michael, a pinnacle of rock eighteen miles from the Irish coast, rising seven hundred feet out of the sea."
Clark, who began his Civilisation with a chapter (called "The Skin of Our Teeth") on the precarious transition from classical to medieval, is an exception in that he gives full weight to the Irish contribution. Many historians fail to mention it entirely, and few advert to the breathtaking drama of this cultural cliffhanger. This is probably because it is easier to describe stasis (classical, then medieval) than movement (classical to medieval). It is also true that historians are generally expert in one period or the other, so that analysis of the transition falls outside their--and everyone's?--competence. At all events, I know of no single book now in print that is devoted to the subject of the transition, nor even one in which this subject plays a substantial part.
In looking to remedy this omission, we may as well ask ourselves the big question: How real is history? Is it just an enormous soup, so full of disparate ingredients that it is uncharacterizable? Is it true, as Emil Cioran has remarked, that history proves nothing because it contains everything? Is not the reverse side of this that history can be made to say whatever we wish it to?
I think, rather, that every age writes history anew, reviewing deeds and texts of other ages from its own vantage point. Our history, the history we read in school and refer to in later life, was largely written by Protestant Englishmen and Anglo-Saxon Protestant Americans. Just as certain contemporary historians have been discovering that such redactors are not always reliable when it comes to the contributions of, say, women or African Americans, we should not be surprised to find that such storytellers have overlooked a tremendous contribution in the distant past that was both Celtic and Catholic, a contribution without which European civilization would have been impossible.
To an educated Englishman of the last century, for instance, the Irish were by their very nature incapable of civilization. "The Irish," proclaimed Benjamin Disraeli, Queen Victoria's beloved prime minister, "hate our order, our civilization, our enterprising industry, our pure religion [Disraeli's father had abandoned Judaism for the Church of England]. This wild, reckless, indolent, uncertain and superstitious race have no sympathy with the English character. Their ideal of human felicity is an alternation of clannish broils and coarse idolatry [i.e., Catholicism]. Their history describes an unbroken circle of bigotry [!] and blood." The venomous racism and knuckle-headed prejudice of this characterization may be evident to us, but in the days of "dear old Dizzy," as the queen called the man who had presented her with India, it simply passed for indisputable truth.
Occasionally, of course, even the smug colonists of the little queen's empire would experience a momentary qualm: Could the conquerors possibly be responsible for the state of the colonized? But they quickly suppressed any doubt and wrapped themselves in their impervious superiority, as in this response by the historian Charles Kingsley to the famine-induced destitution he witnessed in Victorian Ireland: "I am daunted by the human chimpanzees I saw along that hundred miles of horrible country. I don't believe they are our fault [emphasis mine]. I believe that there are not only many more of them than of old, but that they are happier, better and more comfortably fed and lodged under our rule than they ever were. But to see white chimpanzees is dreadful; if they were black, one would not feel it so much, but their skins, except where tanned by exposure, are as white as ours."
Nor can we comfort ourselves that such thinking passed long ago from the scene. As the distinguished Princeton historian Anthony Grafton wrote recently in The New York Review of Books of history departments at the better American universities: "Catholic culture--like most Catholics--was usually disdained, as the province of lesser breeds fit only for the legendary parochial schools where nuns told their charges never to order ravioli on a date, lest their boy friends be reminded of pillows. Stereotypes and prejudices of this kind, as nasty as anything fastened upon Jews, persisted in American universities until an uncomfortably recent date."
That date may be only the day before yesterday. Yet this is not to accuse any historian of deliberate falsification. No, the problem is more subtle than deception--and artfully described by John Henry Newman in his fable of the Man and the Lion:
The Man once invited the Lion to be his guest, and received him with princely hospitality. The Lion had the run of a magnificent palace, in which there were a vast many things to admire. There were large saloons and long corridors, richly furnished and decorated, and filled with a profusion of fine specimens of sculpture and painting, the works of the first masters in either art. The subjects represented were various; but the most prominent of them had an especial interest for the noble animal who stalked by them. It was that of the Lion himself; and as the owner of the mansion led him from one apartment into another, he did not fail to direct his attention to the indirect homage which these various groups and tableaux paid to the importance of the lion tribe.
There was, however, one remarkable feature in all of them, to which the host, silent as he was from politeness, seemed not at all insensible; that diverse as were these representations, in one point they all agreed, that the man was always victorious, and the lion was always overcome.
It is not that the Lion has been excluded from the history of art, but rather that he has been presented badly--and he never wins. When the Lion had finished his tour of the mansion, continues Newman, "his entertainer asked him what he thought of the splendours it contained; and he in reply did full justice to the riches of its owner and the skill of its decorators, but he added, 'Lions would have fared better, had lions been the artists.'"
In the course of this history, we shall meet many entertainers, persons of substance who have their story to tell, some of whom may believe that their story is all there is to tell. We shall be gracious and give them a hearing without disparagement. We shall even attempt to see things from their point of view. But every once in a while we shall find ourselves entertaining lions. At which moments, it will be every reader for himself.
We begin, however, not in the land of lions, but in the orderly, predictable world of Rome. For in order to appreciate the significance of the Irish contribution, we need first to take an inventory of the civilized empire of late antiquity.
Product details
- Publisher : Anchor; 1st edition (February 1, 1996)
- Language : English
- Paperback : 246 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0385418493
- ISBN-13 : 978-0385418492
- Item Weight : 7.6 ounces
- Dimensions : 5.17 x 0.58 x 7.99 inches
-
Best Sellers Rank:
#16,813 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- #20 in England History
- #50 in History of Christianity (Books)
- #59 in Christian Church History (Books)
- Customer Reviews:
Customer reviews
4.5 out of 5 stars
4.5 out of 5
1,401 global ratings
How are ratings calculated?
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Top reviews
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Reviewed in the United States on June 29, 2020
Verified Purchase
44 people found this helpful
Report abuse
5.0 out of 5 stars
From Classical Antiquity to Celtic Christianity Dominates through Literary & Biblical Scholarship
Reviewed in the United States on February 16, 2019Verified Purchase
Pleasantly surprised that the book was not specifically about Irish History. The first few chapters focus on classical antiquity in relation to Ireland and Celtic Christianity, which is why I described the chapters in detail because the title felt somewhat misleading although in the end Cahill does brilliantly prove his thesis.
Chapter 1: Explanation of the Fall of Rome; Uses interesting ideas for modern political reference which are strangely prophetic in TrumpAmerica
Chapter 2: Breaks down Augustine and talks about the art of his skillful Latin in the context of other writers and philosophers of the age; Cahill states that Confessions is the first autobiographical memoir of all of history opening up the world to psychology and the notion of consciousness; Also talks about Paul’s letters as well as Cicero, Plato and Virgil in a readable, not overly academic manner
Chapter 3: Various poetry and ballads from Irish literature comparing to other cultures such as the Greeks and highlighting traits that are make the Irish unique
Chapter 4: Beautiful insight and enlightening Biography about St. Patrick. He is the adopted father to the Irish people. Gets rid of slavery. Establishes the church and monasteries which is the founding of Christianity in Ireland. Cahill also makes an interesting comparison between St. Patrick’s Confessions and perspective and St. Augustine. Early church fathers who had a great influence on the growth of Christianity.
Chapter 1: Explanation of the Fall of Rome; Uses interesting ideas for modern political reference which are strangely prophetic in TrumpAmerica
Chapter 2: Breaks down Augustine and talks about the art of his skillful Latin in the context of other writers and philosophers of the age; Cahill states that Confessions is the first autobiographical memoir of all of history opening up the world to psychology and the notion of consciousness; Also talks about Paul’s letters as well as Cicero, Plato and Virgil in a readable, not overly academic manner
Chapter 3: Various poetry and ballads from Irish literature comparing to other cultures such as the Greeks and highlighting traits that are make the Irish unique
Chapter 4: Beautiful insight and enlightening Biography about St. Patrick. He is the adopted father to the Irish people. Gets rid of slavery. Establishes the church and monasteries which is the founding of Christianity in Ireland. Cahill also makes an interesting comparison between St. Patrick’s Confessions and perspective and St. Augustine. Early church fathers who had a great influence on the growth of Christianity.
42 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on April 28, 2016
Verified Purchase
Everyone should read this book! In the depths of the dark ages, 400 years after the fall of Rome, the only place in the world where the art of illuminated scripture was still being practiced was in the monasteries of Ireland: a place so remote and primitive that they were barely aware that they were no longer part of the Roman Empire. The clergy of Europe had become as illiterate as the peasants, but they memorized and recited tthe Bible from memory. Errors conpunded themselves as recondite knowledge was passed orally from generation to generation among the priests. The Irish monks, led by a man named Patrick,were the last literate Northern Europeans. They began traveling through Europe and teaching the clergy how to read. Absent their efforts, civilization as we know it would have passed out of existence: there would have been no Charlemagne to consolidate Europe again, no Elizabeth to sponsor the Reformed Church and the arts, and no Queen Isabella to finance the discovery of the Americas, because they would have all existed (if at all) barely above the level of cavemen. It is for this reason that Patrick was sainted: the stories of ridding Ireland of snakes is just a fairy tale made up by those who didn't read and didn't know why he was sainted. Skip this book, and your life will be poorer in its ignorance!
Cahill writes beautifully, and he brings the book to life: he presents history as saga, and the truth he gives us is more enjoyable and fulfilling than any fiction!
Cahill writes beautifully, and he brings the book to life: he presents history as saga, and the truth he gives us is more enjoyable and fulfilling than any fiction!
77 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Reviewed in the United States on November 25, 2017
Verified Purchase
I own this entire series and enjoy this book a great deal. It actually proved a religious-historical theory that I'd already had a hunch about (that my Irish/Celtic ancestors actually worshiped Baal and the Queen of Heaven a.k.a. Asherah a.k.a. Babylon). And even though there are statements in the book that irk me since I am a Christian and the author is clearly not, I can still appreciate this book for it's balanced, honest, historical perspective. Definitely recommend How the Irish Saved Civilization and the entire Hinges of History Series. Enjoy!
24 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Top reviews from other countries
The Other Book Worm
1.0 out of 5 stars
Still waiting to find out in a bit more detail ...............
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on July 17, 2019Verified Purchase
I'm so glad I bought this book second hand for very, very little as I'm afraid it's not going to make it to my keeper shelf.
I was intrigued by the title - sadly, that was the best bit. At just over 200 pages, it's a short work so taking about 70 pages to actually make it to Ireland from the ruins of Rome, another 30 for Patrick to put in an appearance and the next couple of chapters to get the island converted to Christianity and the written word (wading through all those Irish epics as we went) didn't leave much time to show exactly how the Irish actually managed to save civilisation (page 145 before the author got around to telling us and even then devoted exactly one chapter to the process before: bam! the conclusion). Spoiler alert: if you don't want to have to wade through the preliminary chapters, skip to chapter 6 of 7 to find out that those clever Irish basically copied everything they could lay their hands on before the Goths, Visigoths and even Vandals could barbecue it. Better still, just read the spoiler alert - it'll save you a lot of time.
Mr Cahill is obviously greatly impressed by the pre-Patrician Irish, their culture and legends and, if this had been his aim, the book would be a start but this work by no means fulfils the claims of the title. There was no detailed study of the collection of the classical works by the Irish monks - how did they choose what to copy; how did they go about collating and collecting; what were their copying methods - a small treatise on the manuscripts, their decoration and illumination - even how they were bound - would not have gone amiss. There could have been soooo much more to this book than there was. Sorry, but I can't recommend it as a scholarly work of any great depth and it left me feeling very disappointed.
I was intrigued by the title - sadly, that was the best bit. At just over 200 pages, it's a short work so taking about 70 pages to actually make it to Ireland from the ruins of Rome, another 30 for Patrick to put in an appearance and the next couple of chapters to get the island converted to Christianity and the written word (wading through all those Irish epics as we went) didn't leave much time to show exactly how the Irish actually managed to save civilisation (page 145 before the author got around to telling us and even then devoted exactly one chapter to the process before: bam! the conclusion). Spoiler alert: if you don't want to have to wade through the preliminary chapters, skip to chapter 6 of 7 to find out that those clever Irish basically copied everything they could lay their hands on before the Goths, Visigoths and even Vandals could barbecue it. Better still, just read the spoiler alert - it'll save you a lot of time.
Mr Cahill is obviously greatly impressed by the pre-Patrician Irish, their culture and legends and, if this had been his aim, the book would be a start but this work by no means fulfils the claims of the title. There was no detailed study of the collection of the classical works by the Irish monks - how did they choose what to copy; how did they go about collating and collecting; what were their copying methods - a small treatise on the manuscripts, their decoration and illumination - even how they were bound - would not have gone amiss. There could have been soooo much more to this book than there was. Sorry, but I can't recommend it as a scholarly work of any great depth and it left me feeling very disappointed.
7 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Norman Ridenour
3.0 out of 5 stars
The writer comingles Christianity and Western Civilization
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on June 11, 2019Verified Purchase
The writer assumes that civilization means Christianity and that the preservation of the monastaries and their traditions implies saving civilization. I assert that western culture was saved in Islamic Spain with the mass salvation of the clasical world.
3 people found this helpful
Report abuse
NellieD
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Island of Saints and Scholars
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on May 28, 2018Verified Purchase
I had often heard that Ireland had been called The Island of Saints and Scholars but I knew very little about this period in history.This book has helped to fill that gap and inspired me to read more on the subject. It is very accessible for a non academic like myself. It is a book I will come back to and read again. I can thoroughly recommend it.
3 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Iskander Magnus
5.0 out of 5 stars
Here’s why Ireland was the Isle of Saints and Scholars.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on November 13, 2019Verified Purchase
Most valuable summary of the achievements of early Christian Ireland. Many obscure facts showcased in a very accessible way.
2 people found this helpful
Report abuse
Áighne
5.0 out of 5 stars
True
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on October 31, 2019Verified Purchase
Preaching to the choir!
2 people found this helpful
Report abuse
What other items do customers buy after viewing this item?
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
Pages with related products.
See and discover other items: dark ages, europe culture, europe history, european history, ireland books, medieval europe books




