Some information is simply not safe for us--not because there is something wrong with its possession in the abstract, but because it is the sort of thing we humans are not well suited to cope with. There are various things we simply ought not not to know. If we did not have to live our lives amidst a fog of uncertainty about a whole range of matters that are actually of fundamental interest and importance to us, it would no longer be a human mode of existence that we would live. Instead we would become a being of another sort, perhaps angelic, perhaps machine-like, but certainly not human. -Nicholas Rescher, an essay entitled Forbidden Knowledge
In his excellent book, Forbidden Knowledge (see Orrin's review), Roger Shattuck discussed the persistence and continued relevance of one of the central themes of Western Civilization : the idea that certain kinds of knowledge have been placed, quite specifically and intentionally, beyond our reach because we do not have the capacity, at this time, to handle them, or to wield them responsibly. I've no idea if Darren Aronofsky had read Shattuck's book before making this movie, nor whether Professor Shattuck has ever commented upon the film, but it perfectly illustrates the point.
In Aronofsky's film, a brilliant young mathematician, Max Cohen (Sean Gullette), believes in several precepts :
(1) that mathematics is the language of the universe (2) nature can be expressed in numbers, and (3) there are patterns everywhere in nature.
Most importantly, he believes that we should be able to perceive and interpret the patterns, to comprehend the language, and that he is on the verge of doing so. Yet, while patterns seem to emerge at every turn, from a swirl of cream in a coffee cup to a seashell at Coney Island, the meanings of these patterns remain maddeningly elusive.
Meanwhile, both a vicious Wall Street henchwoman and a Hassidic Jew approach Max about his work, the first thinking he's about to figure out the hidden patterns in the Market, the latter thinking he can decipher the numerical code hidden in the Torah. Max however has hit an impasse, including crashing his computer, and turns to his mentor for help. Like Max, he too was once a brilliant, cocky young mathematician, but he's had a stroke and now just sits in his apartment playing the game of Go.
And just in case all that isn't enough, Max has paralyzing headaches brought on by an incident from his youth, an incident which evokes Daedalus :
9:22. Personal note: When I was a little kid my mother told me not to stare into the sun. So one day when I was six, I did ... the next day I had my first headache.
Whether physical or mental in nature, Max's headaches are soon accompanied by nosebleeds, hallucinations, and a mounting sense of paranoia, as his grip on reality begins to slip away.
Aronofsky achieves some sense of the disjointed and terrifying world that Max is living in by setting the film in a decaying tenement in Brooklyn, shooting in Black and White, manipulating the film to make it incredibly grainy, actually mounting a camera on Sean Gullette (the actor playing Max) so that on tracking shots we're moving with him but looking right in his face, etc. Some of these techniques work better than others, but all serve to give the film such an unusual look that it is very much its own distinctive world.
But most of all there are the ideas. Max's hubris--his belief that the universe's secrets are lurking just beyond his line of sight or his chain of thought, and even more important, that he in particular has been given the capacity to finally perceive them and that when they are revealed he will be able to handle them--is shared by so many of the great heroes of our culture, from Adam and Eve to Dr. Frankenstein, to Faust, and so on. (Like Faust he even makes a deal with the Wall Streeters in order to get a new, extraordinarily powerful processor for his computer.) The message of the film, as in all of its predecessors, that no matter the quality of the individual--no matter the genius, or the purity, or the ambition--Man is simply not ready to share in these secrets, is so profoundly antithetical to our Age of Reason that it is a pleasant shock to find an artist who's still resorting to it. And, amazingly enough, this mythical lesson is still just as powerful today as it has been throughout human history.
You can't really discuss the end of the film without ruining it for first time viewers. Suffice it to say that the denouement is both shocking and inevitable. This is a movie that not everyone will like--mostly due to the unusual look of the film, Max's sometimes off-putting behavior, and some genuinely disturbing images--but if you stick with it and at least accept the visual style, you'll be treated to a compelling version of one of our oldest, but still most relevant, stories.
GRADE : A+
| Additional VHS Tape options | Edition | Discs | Price | New from | Used from |
|
VHS Tape
January 12, 1999 "Please retry" | — | — |
—
| $8.99 | $3.99 |
|
VHS Tape
March 15, 2000 "Please retry" | — | — |
—
| — | $41.64 |
Watch Instantly with 
| Rent | Buy |
| Pi | — | — |
Reviews with images
Submit a report
A few common reasons customers report reviews:
- Harassment, profanity
- Spam, advertisement, promotions
- Given in exchange for cash, discounts
When we get your report, we'll check if the review meets our Community guidelines. If it doesn't, we'll remove it.
Sorry, there was an error
Please try again later.
Top reviews from other countries
Roxane
Klaustrophobisch, eindringlich, anstrengend...
Reviewed in Germany on January 12, 2019
alitine
"Daß ich paranoid bin, heißt ja noch lange nicht, daß sie nicht wirklich hinter mir her sind"
Reviewed in Germany on December 24, 2007
