Overall: 4 1/2 stars
Plot/Storyline: 4 1/4 stars
This is simply a very rich retelling of Cinderella, with many of the well-known details intact, and a few changes and additions. If you are a fan of the Celtic style of fairy tale/folklore - with fairies as a magical race that humans stumbled across at their own peril - I believe this will be extra pleasing. Ash interacts with the fairy race throughout the story and this adds a level of suspense and danger since it's not all bibbity bobbity boo, and there are stories throughout to remind us of how dangerous these interactions can be.
The love story - Ash and the huntress - is not treated as controversial. In this world, people don't seem to give a thought to it as a forbidden thing, and the treatment is matter of fact. People fall in love and this one girl, Ash, almost without realizing it falls in love with the Royal Huntress. There is more controversy in the class difference between someone who looks and acts like a scullery maid and a person who is part of the royal court. Their relationship is only overtly romantic well into the book, and this aspect is quite G-rated.
(It's worth noting that the author comments on her blog that "in Ash's world, there is no homosexuality or heterosexuality; there is only love. The story is about her falling in love. It's not about her being gay.")
The novel length is of benefit to the story, allowing Lo to give more time to Ash's profound grief over the loss of her parents, particularly her mother, as well as to show our heroine as a tough character, and to wed this tale, with the most popular tellings of French or German derivation, with the storytelling traditions of the British Isles.
One of my complaints is that the author downplays Ash's dilemma between a life with the fairies and love in the real world. I think it could make her feelings seem shallower than had been intended, and her transition perhaps seemed less than completely explained.
The other complaint is the ending. It ends happily, as it should! However, the resolution was simply too easy, as if the writer couldn't think of a more complex way to get the same result. To say more would be to spoil, but there was definitely some missing conflict.
Characters: 4 1/4 stars
Ash is a likable character, with courage and spirit. Whether or not you'll consider her intelligent is a matter of how you perceive her interactions with the fairy world since pretty much every story she'd read and her mother and everyone who believed in fairies told you they don't play! However, in the beginning she was longing to be with her dead mother and felt she had nothing left for her, and so it makes some sense to me.
I would have liked at least one more scene where we get to see what's in the love interest's heart, but - as is often the case with romantic stories - it's enough that a sympathetic character found love.
Lo made one of the stepsisters awful, but still with a hint of girlish hopes for herself, and one on the brink of likable. The stepmother seemed to have a justification for her actions, or at least she was able to justify it in her own mind. For the most part, I cannot say the secondary characters were fully fleshed out, but fairytales do tend to be told in broad strokes.
Writing style: 4 1/2 stars
Lo does a nice job of making the story feel both traditional and new - honoring folktales and traditions while seamlessly including a message of acceptance. By having it not matter to these people, in Once Upon A Time Land, that a girl's heart is given to another girl, it points out pretty sharply that it's odd that it bothers so many people in this world.
As someone who enjoys fairytales, and folktales, and the reimagining of them, I found the author's choices and treatment of this story to be quite satisfactory.
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Customers who bought this item also bought
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
From the Publisher
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ash | Huntress | Adaptation | Inheritance | Natural Selection | |
|
|
|||||
| Customer Reviews |
1,463
|
600
|
315
|
166
|
107
|
| Price | $11.15 | $11.15 | $18.55 | $21.99 | — |
| Welcome to the beautifully haunting and thrilling world of Malinda Lo! | Hauntingly romantic lesbian retelling of Cinderella beautifully unfolds the connections between life and love, and solitude and death. | This exciting adventure prequel to Ash is overflowing with lush Chinese influences and details and is filled with action and romance. | Reese can't remember anything from the accident up until she woke up a month later. But she does know one thing: She's different now. | Thoughtful exploration of adolescence, identity, and "the other" in Adaptation's impossible to put down sequel. | This novella takes readers on a trip through Amber's past and gives a deeper look into one of Adaptation's most compelling characters. |
About the author
Top reviews from other countries
davide albertin
Recensione Ash
Reviewed in Italy on September 12, 2022
davide albertin
Reviewed in Italy on September 12, 2022
Images in this review
Annabelle Simons
New favourite book
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on March 19, 2017Amazon Customer
Not much of a reader, but... loved it!!
Reviewed in Australia on January 5, 2017Céline
Un conte comme on voudrait en lire plus souvent
Reviewed in France on August 21, 2015
