Well, not really. But, what if ---
The Soviets just kept going? Took a breather and then in late '45 rolled west?
How would it have all shook out? My sense is that the US would win, but would they?
In 1945, the Soviets had over 11 million battle hardened soldiers in the Red Army and over 100 tank divisions. Pretty formidable. Huge tactical air force.
By the same token, in 1945, the US had at its disposal some 8 million GI's, 3.3 million squidlies, and about 400,000 jarheads. How many were forward deployed to Europe, I think about 2.5 million plus another 400,000 in the UK. How does it shake out.
Experience, roughly the same.
Combat fatigue, probably worse in the USSR.
Air power, I am forced to say the USAAF.
Armored forces, more agile and reactive, US. Sheer hitting power and tough vehicles, USSR.
Secure rear area, margin US
Logistics, US, increasing over time.
Geographical position, in the West? East, likely US, in the South? US with deep USSR vulnerability in the Balkans and the 'stans, real coin toss
Allies, USSR, likely none. US, UK, probably France, and the real wild card, 2 million battle hardened and experienced German soldiers who nearly took the Soviets down ... all by themselves (I have no idea how this shakes out)
A-bomb, the US has it, but only a few, the Russian will have it. The limitation, the US may not have the capacity to get it to any place the USSR is likely to care about
The deal breaker, logistics ...
I see it as the USSR getting no more than 100 km into France and a US roll back perhaps to the USSR frontier. Then total exhaustion kicks in.
How do you see it?
There are going to be some good comments here and it is likely to have been done already at some point but, what say you?
Recent discussions in the History forum
AnnouncementAmazon Discussions Feedback Forum
|459||Mar 11, 2017|
|Should we have bombed the Nazi concentration camps in 1942?||17||9 hours ago|
|Are Jews God's Chosen People? And Could this Core Belief have led to the Backlash of Persistent Anit-Semitism?||673||13 hours ago|
|Would you have voted for Jefferson?||13||17 hours ago|
|Should the US have become involved in WWI?||112||1 day ago|
|Nazis in a good light...||5892||1 day ago|
|Was it necessary to use the atomic bomb on Japan to end the Pacific war?||2150||1 day ago|
|Holocaust files||2||3 days ago|
|USS Arizona survivor rejoins shipmates, interred aboard ship||2||4 days ago|
|Books on the American Revolution - Culper Ring - Robert Townsend||0||5 days ago|
|Great book (Shopping For Bombs) shows that Bush disarmed Gadhafi WMD-wise with his 2003 invasion of Iraq||96||5 days ago|
|WWI July 28, 1914 – November 11, 1918||7||6 days ago|