I went with these after reading reviews on these in particular and higher end brands. We went across country and these were large enough for us to use but I did not over stuff one. I read they would rip if they were too full. Two of these were ripped after using one time. The zipper was ripped on one and there’s a tear in the seam on another. As much as I love compression these aren’t that. You could just roll your things in a cheap canvas tote. That’s what they feel like to me.