First off, they have very very little sole in them. They're almost like walking barefoot. Secondly the last is pretty darn skinny. This, coupled with the "winter" version where they seemed to have taken the same, already too skinny boot, and added some faux fur on the inside, makes them ridiculously tight. I'm already 1 size up and they're still annoyingly tight and difficult to get on. Solve these problems and they'd be great, but for now 2 stars.
The second annoying thing about these boots are the pull tabs in back. They're too small to hook a finger in, so why even bother!?! They just taunt you with the usefulness they fail to deliver.