My Yorkie absolutely refuses dry food. I tried so many brands. I received a sample of this I and love and you, Naked Essentials and gave my dog a handful. To my surprise, she really liked it. I then bought a bag for her . She doesn't like to eat it as food, she prefers me to give her a handful as a snack. That is fine. As long as she gets the nutrients and her teeth get the cleaning from the hard kibble, I am fine with feeding it to her any way she wants it. The taste must be pretty darn good for Molly to eat this and the ingredients, while not the very best, are good. If she keeps eating this, i will keep buying it!