I feel like a lot of post are either this good is the greatest or this food almost killed my dog! I'm going to ride the middle because honestly, the food has been pretty good for the first 5 months of my pups life. He has however become disinterested in it now. I've tried a couple other brands of food and those were highly ranking above this product. I'm not saying this stuff will hurt your dog. But it does seems like his stools are often soft from it. He isn't at the same weight as his brothers who aren't on it. And from what I've read, it's a terrible product. But I'm just reviewing based on visual observations. I'm done with thr product from here on. Good luck.