I feed these to my 22 lb. dog because she has significant allergies (corn, wheat, barley, most oils, et.c). she seems to prefer the Avoderm Oatmeal & Berry to these but eats them both and loves the brand. They are very large treats so I have to break them into about 6 pieces for my dog and they crumble quit a bit leaving tiny pieces that fill the bottom of the baggie that I use to keep the pieces. They also crumble when she eats them. My dog cleans up the crumbs but if your dog isn't so neat, they could be messy. For dogs with allergies these are great and worth the issues I have about size and crumbs.