If you’re only judging the comfort to walk on ... it’s a Croc and is comfy. That said, this is soooooo tight across the foot. The rubber is super hard. Not bendy. My niece is the same size and she’s got super skinny feet. Even she had a hard time putting these on. I wore them once and unless I can find a way to soften the material I may never wear again. I couldn’t wait to get these off of my feet.