My dogs love these things. They have loved them ever since they came out. I stopped feeding them some time ago due to the expense of feeding 4 dogs the large and Jumbo sizes. I decided to get them a Christmas treat. These were way softer than they used to be. I bought large. My 45 pound Shar pei chewed this up faster than he does a chicken jerky strip. They used to spend at least 5 minutes chewing up one. These were easily bitten into large chunks and swallowed by my dogs. I won't be feeding them again since the chunks the dogs swallow are so large. Bring back the old recipe where the bones are harder to chew and I'll be buying them again. But soft as these are, they're a danger to my dogs.