Usually, rarities/B-Side collections appeal only to the serious fan, but "Lost Dogs" should appeal to the die hard and the casual fan. I say this because instead of the usual collection of outtakes and material that is clearly not album worthy, Pearl Jam has put together two CD's that easily contain an album's worth of material. I mean that quite literally, they could have easily worked up a dozen songs from the thirty found here and put together a studio release on par with their other albums. Moreover, the excellent liner notes offer great insight into Pearl Jam's recording process and the origins of their songs.
It would be impossible for me to comment on all of the thirty songs in the available space, so I'm just going to touch on the highlights. However, that should no way indicate my dislike for the balance of the material. A few of the songs (Sweet Lew, Bee Girl) are quirky, but none are by any means bad.
The first track is "All Night" from the No Code sessions. While it was understandably left off the album (it's totally out character with the rest of the songs on it), it is a pretty great song. With a driving guitar line and interesting vocals from Ed, it actually presages some of their later work, and would fit right in on Binaural or Riot Act.
Next up is "Sad" from the Binaural album, and which I would have gladly seen in the place of "Evacuation". This is a beautiful song with the great atmosphere that characterized that album. Ed's vocals have a haunted quality, and the lyrics beautifully capture the pain of a lost love.
"Down" appeared somewhat regularly during the 2003 tour, and there was much discussion as to why it didn't make the album. Having now heard the studio version, I have to say that I prefer the song live. Lacking here are the flourishes and energy that made it one of the highlights of the tour.
"Don't Gimme No Lip" is interesting as a window into Stone's development as a writer. While not a bad song, it is very simple, and not in the same league as "Mankind", for example.
"Alone" was really a blast from the past; I had forgotten how raw (and I mean that in a good sense) Ten was; it plays like an open wound and "Alone" fits right in. Another song about relationships, this song features the raging guitars and Ed's characteristic wail that defined the early days. A great cut, and one I'd love to hear live.
"Education" is a really interesting track because it is largely unlike anything you're likely to find on a Pearl Jam album. Matt's fingerprints are all over this one, with an almost tribal drumbeat. Takes a few listens to get used to, but it's become one of my favorites.
"Gremmie Out of Control" is off a benefit album and is a cover of a silly surfer song from the 1960's. Two things make it noteworthy; the first is Stone's back-up vocals, which are completely over the top and absolutely hilarious. The second the guitar work of producer, engineer, collaborator and all around friend of the band, Brendan O'Brien; you'd think that Brian Wilson was playing with them.
"Undone" is an absolutely amazing song from the Riot Act sessions. Again, it's not really in keeping with the rest of the album, but I still wish they could have shoehorned it in. Actually, it would have fit perfectly in place of "Bu$hleaguer" which I've always found to be uncharacteristically negative. Featuring beautiful, hopeful (but still protesting) lyrics and a Springsteen/REM hybrid sound, this is in the top three on Lost Dogs.
Disc 2 kicks off with "Fatal" from the Binaural session. Another moody, complicated song, it was producer Tchad Blake's favorite, but somehow didn't make the album.
Next is "Other Side" which is an absolutely beautiful song that, if not crying out right, certainly had me tear up a few times. Written by Jeff and inspired by his parents' marriage, "Other Side" describes the sadness of those who pass on and are forced to wait for their partner. Offering both a unique perspective and heartfelt lyrics, anyone this song will touch who has been in a long-term relationship.
"Strangest Tribe" is off the 1999 Fan Club single and is a simple but fascinating song. First off, the sound is amazing; while mostly acoustic guitars, Ed's voice, the simple drumbeat and a few ell chosen effects lend a distinctly Middle Eastern sound. The lyrics capture the oddity, but simple beauty of faith. This is a song that deserved a wider release, and offers a look at Pearl Jam from a rarely seen angle.
"Drifting" is Ed's take on Dylan, and it isn't bad, not least because he has a much better voice. A simple song about living life simply, it's got a great beat and Ed reveals a genuine affinity for playing the harmonica.
"Dirty Frank" is the only song I really have a complaint about. For those unfamiliar with it, it is Pearl Jam's legendary tribute to the Chile Peppers and features lyrics about a serial killer bus driver. However, it used to feature Ed at several points during the song riffing on "Shaft" ("That Dirty Frank is a bad mother..."). All of those moments are no longer in the mix, and that's a shame because they really added to the fun of the song and sort of defined it.
Finally there is "4/20/02", a hidden song that appears six minutes after "Bee Girl". Written and performed by Ed the day that Layne Staley died, it is a raw and moving tribute to a lost friend, that reveals both anger and pathos. A really powerful cut.
Unfortunately, I'm out of space and I've had to assume that tracks like "Wash", "Footsteps" and "Hard to Imagine" are already familiar. If not, they're great too!
Enjoy!
Jake Mohlman
Image Unavailable
Image not available for
Color:
Color:
-
-
-
- Sorry, this item is not available in
- Image not available
- To view this video download Flash Player
Lost Dogs
See all 13 formats and editions
Hide other formats and editions
| Listen Now with Amazon Music |
|
Lost Dogs
"Please retry" | Amazon Music Unlimited |
| Price | New from | Used from |
|
MP3 Music, November 11, 2003
"Please retry" | $14.99 | — |
|
Vinyl
"Please retry" |
—
| — | — |
Includes FREE MP3 version of this album. Provided by Amazon Digital Services LLC. Terms and Conditions. Does not apply to gift orders. Complete your purchase to save the MP3 version to your music library.
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
From the brand
Track Listings
Disc: 1
| 1 | All Night (Album Version) |
| 2 | Sad (Album Version) |
| 3 | Down (Album Version) |
| 4 | Hitchhiker (Album Version) |
| 5 | Don't Gimme No Lip (Album Version) |
| 6 | Alone |
| 7 | In The Moonlight (Album Version) |
| 8 | Education (Album Version) |
| 9 | Black, Red, Yellow (Album Version) |
| 10 | You |
| 11 | Leavin Here (Album Version) |
| 12 | Gremmie Out of Control (Album Version) |
| 13 | Whale Song (Album Version) |
| 14 | Undone (Album Version) |
| 15 | Hold On (Album Version) |
| 16 | Yellow Ledbetter |
Disc: 2
| 1 | Fatal (Album Version) |
| 2 | Other Side (Album Version) |
| 3 | Hard To Imagine (Album Version) |
| 4 | Footsteps (Album Version) |
| 5 | Wash (Album Version) |
| 6 | Dead Man (Album Version) |
| 7 | Strangest Tribe (Album Version) |
| 8 | Drifting (Album Version) |
| 9 | Let Me Sleep (It's Christmas Time) |
| 10 | Last Kiss |
| 11 | Sweet Lew (Album Version) |
| 12 | Dirty Frank (Album Version) |
| 13 | Brother (Album Version) |
| 14 | Bee Girl (Album Version) |
Editorial Reviews
.
Product details
- Is Discontinued By Manufacturer : No
- Language : English
- Product Dimensions : 4.92 x 5.6 x 0.64 inches; 5.28 ounces
- Manufacturer : Legacy Recordings
- Item model number : 2110249
- Original Release Date : 2003
- Run time : 1 hour and 42 minutes
- Date First Available : October 21, 2006
- Label : Legacy Recordings
- ASIN : B0000DYJM6
- Number of discs : 2
- Best Sellers Rank: #25,150 in CDs & Vinyl (See Top 100 in CDs & Vinyl)
- #2,486 in Metal
- #2,628 in Alternative Rock (CDs & Vinyl)
- #10,377 in Pop (CDs & Vinyl)
- Customer Reviews:
Customer reviews
4.7 out of 5 stars
4.7 out of 5
407 global ratings
How customer reviews and ratings work
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonReviews with images
5 out of 5 stars
real art.
simply a masterpiece, you can't pay enough for it! buy it, you will not regret it!.
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry, there was an error
Sorry we couldn't load the review
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on November 17, 2003
- Reviewed in the United States on June 8, 2005This isn't a review I'm going to approach like I would a normal one-- "Lost Dogs" is a collection of 30 b-sides, tracks from benefit albums, and unreleased material. This is not likely the place to look for the casual fan, but it really is a fantastic set.
One of the things about Pearl Jam's first album was there was a wealth of material that didn't make it on the album that was superb-- b-sides like "Yellow Ledbetter" (concert and radio staple, likely left off because of its resemblance to Hendrix's "Little Wing"), "Footsteps" (a haunting piece left off because it was already released with Cornell's lyrics as Temple of the Dog's "Times of Trouble") and fan favorite "Wash" are all as powerful as the material on "Ten".
But "Ten" wasn't the only album that great material was left off of-- "Down" and "U" from "Riot Act" and "Yield" respectively are superb, exciting and ecstatic in a way nothing on the album was. And certainly there are few Pearl Jam pieces as superb as "Dead Man" (originally written for the "Dead Man Walking" soundtrack but left off in favor of a Bruce Springsteen track), with its haunting, throbbing bass and downright frightening lyrics.
The other thing you get here is a lot of fun and silly songs-- "Don't Gimme No Lip", featuring a Stone Gossard vocal and the bizarre "Dirty Frank" (about a psychotic bus driver and done in a funky Chili Peppers style) are good examples of this. The band never put stuff like this on their albums, but they're really a trip.
Noticable absences from this set are "Breath" and "State of Love and Trust" from the "Singles" soundtrack, "I Got ID" and "Long Road" from the "Merkinball" single, "Yield" era b-side "Leatherman", and from the "Sweet Relief" benefit album, "Crazy Mary". But even without this material, this is a superb collection. Recommended for all Pearl Jam fans.
- Reviewed in the United States on February 7, 2024It's a CD lol no scratches, timely delivery. Son is very happy!
- Reviewed in the United States on September 15, 2019If pj had just found all these tracks in some basement and released them today, it’d be a big deal indeed. If you’ve just come across them, go ahead, preview them. Mp3-4 streaming-whatever versions of these won’t be enough, not for a real music junkie.
Top reviews from other countries
-
ovonReviewed in Japan on November 21, 20035.0 out of 5 stars 単なる「寄せ集め」ではない!
未発表音源に加え"Yellow ledbetter"やファンクラブ限定シングル曲なども入っているのはうれしい。特に1枚目を聴いていると、こんなにいい曲がアルバムからあふれてしまっていたのかと驚いてしまうほど印象的なナンバーが続きます(7曲目なんかはモロにZeppelin風)。
アルバムとは違う形で発表された曲も加えて、悪く言えば「寄せ集め的」なアルバムなのでしょうが、そういうことを知らずに聴いているとしたら、一つのアルバム作品と間違ってしまうかもしれません。それだけ彼らのスタイルが一貫しているということでしょうか。
-
ResidentReviewed in Italy on June 19, 20205.0 out of 5 stars Il lato B dei PJ
Arrivo a quest’album, anzi doppio album, o meglio “un quasi cofanetto” visto anche la cura del prodotto anche se sono soltanto due cd, in cui sono raccolte tutta una serie di canzoni “minori” dei Pearl Jam, di outtake, di b-sides, bonus tracks, ecc, ecc. dopo avere collezionato (religiosamente) tutta la discografia dei Pearl Jam (cioè gli album in studio). Per cui avviso subito l’eventuale lettore: non comprare questo album se non hai mai ascoltato i Pearl Jam e non hai già tutto quello che hanno pubblicato, il meglio è altrove.
Seconda avvertenza: questa è la mia “personalissima festa della recensione”, sono arrivato alla settima tappa. Sto scrivendo una recensione per ogni anno di acquisti e di pubblicazioni di mie recensioni su Amazon. Ho iniziato il 1° dicembre 2010, recensendo l’album United by Fate dei Rival Schools, e quest’anno, questo strano 2020, festeggio i dieci anni di “attività” (Amazon festeggerà i 10 anni in Italia). La festa consiste nello scrivere dieci recensioni, una per ogni anno, e così vado a vedere negli ordini degli anni passati quali album ho comprato e devo ancora recensire, cerco di trovare un nesso con il mio vissuto in relazione all’album e ai 10 anni trascorsi e provo a dire la mia.
Quest’album l’ho preso nel 2016, anno in cui ho deciso di dimettermi dalla mia vecchia azienda e provare ad “andare con le mie gambe” nel mondo del lavoro. Quale colonna sonora migliore di quella dei Pearl Jam? Avevo bisogno di coraggio, e che la decisione mi permettesse anche di sopravvivere (Alive), per ora va bene e speriamo continui. I Pearl Jam mi hanno fornito coraggio e decisione, sempre, dal primo momento in cui li ho “incontrati”. Non ho mai negato che siano una delle mie band preferite (credo di aver scritto una delle recensioni che più amo proprio su Ten, il loro primo album), e la loro storia si è sovrapposta alla mia (per quanto riguarda la musica naturalmente e anche perché mi ha accompagnato durante gli anni). Non ho mai fatto a meno di loro, non ho mai saltato una pubblicazione, non ho mai considerato l’ipotesi di “voltargli” le spalle. Questo perché mi rispecchio nell’onestà intellettuale dei PJ. Questa “enorme” raccolta però non mi ha rapito subito, e ci ho messo un po’ per decidermi, il tempo necessario per capire che sarei diventato anche un “completista” (cioè quei maniaci che vogliono possedere tutto quello che pubblica il loro amato cantante/band, qualsiasi uscita in qualsiasi formato). Non sono a quei livelli (non è che ho poi così tanto denaro da spendere), non ci sono neanche vicino, ma qualche soldo in più lo spendo per chi merita. Così dopo un po’ di pensieri l’ho comprato. Devo dire che la parte più interessante di questo lavoro sono contenute non nei cd, ma nel booklet. Sono infatti commentate tutte le canzoni della compilation, da parte dei protagonisti. Anche solo due o tre righe per ricordare il perché o il per come è stata registrata la canzone, o quali erano gli spunti, o anche cosa avevano fatto i PJ prima di scrivere quella canzone. Frammenti di vita che io personalmente adoro leggere. Mi fanno capire molto meglio i pensieri degli artisti, mi fanno entrare nel loro immaginario e mi fanno scoprire affinità oltre a quelle palesi che abbiamo in comune (io amo la musica che loro scrivono e suonano). Giusto per capire prendo ad esempio l’ultima canzone del primo cd, Yellow Ledbetter, e provo a tradurre il commento che ha fatto Mike: “è un riff basato su (non dice cosa ...) durante le sessioni di registrazione di Ten. Poi Eddy ha iniziato a scriverci sopra delle parole. Non so cosa significhino ancora oggi, ma l’ho conservata, la adoro. E anche i fans la adorano infatti anche essendo una b-side, è diventata una delle nostre canzoni preferite nei concerti.
Ecco un esempio di quello che intendo, ecco come è nata la canzone, così, per gioco, in una jam forse. Poi è stata scartata, non è mai apparsa sull’album, ed ora è qui in questa raccolta. Ebbene ci sono 30 canzoni e 30 mini-racconti. Si trovano anche delle chicche di notevole interesse, infatti ci sono 4 canzone scritte, suonate e registrate esclusivamente come “regalo di Natale” per i Fan Club (anni 1999 due canzoni, 1991 e 1998 una canzone), più altre rarità. Insomma, il valore musicale ed artistico non si discute, e trovo tutto questo fantastico (ma sono un fan, per cui non sono credibile). Ecco un pezzetto dei Pearl Jam, per amanti.
-
bardieruReviewed in Spain on December 13, 20205.0 out of 5 stars Más que caras B
Un disco esencial con una buena recopilación de temas que no entraron en los primeros discos pero que a lo largo de los años han demostrado ser esenciales en cualquier concierto. Imprescindible.
Jason ParkesReviewed in the United Kingdom on November 4, 20035.0 out of 5 stars Twin-disc overview of b-sides & rarities
Lost Dogs is a welcome addition to the Pearl Jam back-catalogue, after the live-album overkill of recent years. It is a two-disc , 31 song selection of Pearl Jam's back catalogue taking in b-sides (often hard to find), rarities (from tribute albums) & outtakes that have thus far remained unreleased. Personally I became more of a fan of Pearl Jam following Vitalogy (1994) & the direction advanced from there, rather than the early 'grunge' anthems.
There are quite a few outtakes- songs such as All Night, Sad, Education, Fatal & In the Moonlight- which easily rank next to anything PJ have released prior. There are great b-sides: Alone (Go), Wash (Alive), Other Side (Fatal), Down (I Am Mine) & Black Red Yellow (Hail, Hail)- longtime fans will be pleased to see early b-sides such as Dirty Frank, Footsteps & Yellow Ledbetter- a track I previously only had live on the Daughter-single. Not having bought all the singles- as the format has become a rip-off and an irrelevance in the UK thanks to the 3-track/20 minute rule- I was pleased to discover the track Dead Man- which was apparently written for the Jim Jarmusch film that Neil Young scored. There's even an Xmas song- Let Me Sleep (It's Christmas Time), which is nice! Obviously PJ have a vast back-catalogue, so Lost Dogs is a nice way of getting out previously unheard joys- really, a compilation up there with Dylan's Biograph or Young's Decade. I'd much rather have a compilation like this, than the rather obvious best ofs surfacing at present (Suede, Primal Scream). There's plenty here for hardcore fans and the curious alike- two discs at this price is screaming good value. A few quibbles- where is Leatherman (Given to Fly b-side)?- this remains one of my favourite PJ tracks!!! & pity the Merkinball ep is unrepresented- no I Got ID/I Got Shit or the PJ-take of The Long Road (one of the tracks Eddie Vedder did with Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan & Ry Cooder for the Dead Man Walking soundtrack). Regardless, Lost Dogs is a great compilation & a welcome addition to the Pearl Jam back catalogue. & it's not a live album!!!!
-
LümmelReviewed in Germany on December 29, 20125.0 out of 5 stars andere Bands wären froh wenn dsie in die Nähe dieser B-Seiten kommen würden
Anfangs aufgrund eines zu hohen Preises, ja PearlJam ist bei den Alben dann doch spätestens seit den unzähligen Live Alben auf der Kommerzschiene angekommen, wohl nicht ganz so erfolgreich wie verdient, ist das Doppelalbum nun bei einem absolut fairen Preis angekommen. Fans werden die SOngs zwar alle schon einzeln gesammelt haben. Wer allerdings nicht in den Genuss gekommen ist oder Pearl Jam erst entdeckt hat sollte in diese "B-Seiten" unbedingt reinhören.
Dabei findet man einmalige, großartige Songs wie Yellow Ledbetter, Footsteps,Let me sleep und natürlich Last Kiss auf den beiden Silberlingen. Wer auf exzellente Rockmusik steht sollte zuschlagen!
Open Web Player





