This is filmmaking at its finest! Ki Duk tells a story of incest, castration and suicide in a Korean family without any dialogue for an hour and a half. It is an Oedipal tale about a Moebius strip of a family, where one nightmarish thing leads to another and things go around and around. The direction shows through in the fine performances of the actors, who must use only their expressions and body language to portray what is going on. It isn't a throwback to silent films though, because the acting is modern and stylized, the emotions are raw and plain to see, and the way it is filmed (camera work, sound) is exquisite. This is not a movie for American audiences, brought up on Batman, Superman, The Hobbit; it is a movie that requires an open mind and an understand heart in order to make sense out of the surprising, and often shocking twists and turns of the plot. Duk is not content to just turn out a easygoing Hollywood thriller or fantasy film. This is completely original from beginning to end. The subject matter is twisted and over the edge, even after Korean censors had Duk remove some scenes. It is a film for the diminishing group of film devotees left in our culture.