This book is an eyewitness report of what happened in Japan and Korea during the Occupation years from December 1945 to May 1948.
It is also meant to be some other things. It is the story of that extraordinary figure General Douglas MacArthur, and the men around him. It is the story of the way American foreign polity operated in one segment of the globe and of the plot and counterplot that went on behind the Japanese throne in the years of war and of the subsequent conspiracy to thwart the Allied purposes. It is the story of the common people in two Oriental lands. It is, finally, the record of the author's education, and not a few readers will find it controversial. But it is an absorbing book nonetheless, and the years that have passed since its first publication have not diminished its value as the chronicle of a highly observant reporter.
It is indeed an intriguing panorama that Gayn presents, and whether the reader agrees with him in all of his observations, he can hardly accuse him of being unexciting.
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
This book is a time capsule of Japan immediately after its defeat in WWII. It shows how General MacArthur and his staff pledged to 'Democratize' Japan then turned around and put the same men who got Japan into the war back in power. Mark was a newspaper correspondent who tried to cover the goings on and was gradually shut down and finally forced to leave Japan because he wanted to tell the American readers what was really going on. He gives delightful descriptions of the Japanese people, places and American policies that he felt were the opposite of what was being publicly espoused. I recommend this book to anyone that has an interest in Japan and in hidden history.
Reviewed in the United States on December 29, 2022
. . . albeit only the first couple of years. As another reader says, a very interesting first hand account of those times. Gayn reports on a lot of the hypocrisy and u-turns and incompetence of the US occupation authorities. And some of the good. But what stands out to me is the overall pessimism of most everyone involved - Japanese and American and other Allies. Gayn left feeling sure that the 'Americanization' of Japan wouldn't stick and that nationalistic Japan would regroup within a decade or two. Much of his encounters with Japanese reinforced this opinion that the Japanese were playing the Americans and just biding their time. But recall that Gayn's time there ended within a couple years of the war's end. Much of the cities still had rubble heaps, much food and materials for survival were being shipped in by the US, and basically the Japanese were still reeling from the devastation. They were just starting to get on their feet.
Yes, there were (and still are some) Japanese who were not remorseful and wished to continue with the emperor system and all that went with it. But, IMO, this attitude held by some was overwhelmed by the rebuilding of Japan and by the eventual improvement in peoples' lives - a substantial improvement in the standard of living of most Japanese within a couple of decades. And with the enfranchisement of the Japanese, particularly the vote for all adults, brought on by occupation policy, perhaps that's why a peaceful post war Japan has stood the test of 77 years.
IOW, Japanese are too busy working, doing business and maintaining a pretty good life to get wrapped up in nationalistic fervor. Like they used to say about the USA the business of Japan is . . . business. Sadly, as an aside, the business of the USA these days seems to be the dreams of equality of outcome and of attaining some kind of 'cosmic justice' - as Dr. Sowell has said.
The takeaway for me is how a very observant and very intelligent person can still get the future wrong. It's kind of like Fukuyama's 'End of History'. Nice try.