Numerous convicts in this country face the death penalty each year for crimes such as capital murder. Many of those individuals are on death row for a valid reason after being convicted by a jury of twelve. Death row inmates and prisoners in general seem to routinely claim their innocence as a way of working the system and prolonging their own miserable lives, after maliciously destroying those of their victims and the victims families. In many cases they also greatly impact the lives of their own families, sometimes leaving spouses and children to fend for themselves.
This movie is based on the story of Louis Castro Perez, who has been a Texas Death Row inmate since 1999 for the murders of Cynda Bars, Stacy Mitchell and Michelle Fulweiler. His devoted sister Delia Perez-Meyer, believes in his innocence and has waged a tireless battle to win his freedom.
As the story begins, Perez himself is being interviewed in prison by an unseen camera crew. His sister is also depicted throughout the movie, explaining the difficulties and hardship she's encountered while attempting to gain her brothers freedom. The film doesn’t document the details of the case, no description of evidence, no discussion with law enforcement officers or prosecutors who worked the crime scene or investigated the case, etc. It’s impossible to look at the facts of the case as a layman and have any opinion of guilt or innocence. Based on the information as presented, everyone who has ever known Perez believes him to be innocent.
My heart goes out to Delia Perez-Meyer for believing in her brothers innocence and having the perseverance in attempting to gain his freedom. She has dedicated her life to this goal. I sympathize for the families of the murder victims, who received no mention at all. As for Louis Castro Perez, his guilt was decided by a jury based partially on the fact that one of the victims had his DNA underneath her fingernails. Although there's a very slim possibility that he's been wrongfully convicted, a couple of comments he made during the interview leads me to believe that he’s exactly where he deserves to be.