I purchased a different brand for my first one because it had the most reviews and was the most popular. I tried this one because I love the concept of the cup and wanted to make it a permanent go to when it came to that time of the month. Between the two brands this one is more comfortable. It is more pliable and while both brands work this brand is so comfortable that I forget I am using it. The other brand is stiffer where this one is softer and unless you are familiar with these products you may not take that into consideration. This product is the better, more comfortable product in my opinion and I highly recommend it.