We get these through amazon fresh and they are consistently good. The flavor is solid - and we haven't had any bad one's. The shells are thick enough that they are sturdy. The only issue we've had is sometimes whoever is packing amazon fresh here in the DC/MD/VA area where I am puts these in the regular bag and they get broken from the pressure. I now put a note in the order that says "please do not put the eggs in with the regular heavy groceries!" and that seems to work most of the time.