Bought these as replacements for the controller that died. Feel- These do not have the feel and the weight of the Sony controllers. They are lighter and feel less substantial. Controls- Been using a couple of days (update later), so far, they seem to work great. Response time is good. No lag or skips noticed. Connecting- Took a minute to get this sorted. Suggestion, charge them up before trying. Once charged, use the wire to make initial contact, assign controller numbers and such. Reboot for good measure. And double check it is all connected. Battery- First day on full charge, they were used for about 4 hours straight. Went to charge them afterwards, and they showed still 4 dots (near full charge). The question to be answered over next few weeks, will they stay as such? Will the battery life continue to be solid.
Biggest compliant- The feel. As noted, they are less weight, less substantial. They feel plastic and hollow. Biggest plus- so far the price and battery life.
Bottomline- they work. Isn't that what you are wanting?