Diffently a 5, if I could score it higher I would. These three ladies are awesome writers on their own. Put them together and it's pure magic. I love how the story flowed from the first book into the second book. Heavenly, Beck and Seth's story has its ups and down of learning all the secrets they each have. They learn to love and understand each other while finding their path to be together. I could not put it down I read it in one sitting, it is so captivating. Diffently a must read. Cannot wait for the next book..