I’ve owned 2 other foot bath massagers. So far this one is absolutely tte best one. First of all, it keeps up with the desired temperature. I kept temperatures set to 43 degrees and when temperatures drops, this massager will automatically heat up. The tube is also big and deeper than the other one, so no water will leak out. The massager rollers will can be set to automatically massage or manual. Tube also design with a hanger, for easy carrying. Recommended!