Full disclosure I have drunk the Froglube Kool-aid and use the CLP on all my guns. Yes, there is a debate among the community of gun owners that feel inclined to post opinionated rants on various gun forums, (as distasteful as that might be) both pro and con for this line of products and am I am firmly in the opinionated pro camp. Having said all that, I love Frog Lube and wanted the cleaner to work, but I don't see that it does.
Yes, it smells good and is easy on the skin it might even make a nice facial scrub for oily skin and or a quick rinse for mild gunk in action of a gun, but as for harder deposits or grease, it does not appear to do anything.
This product will be used to rinse out my shotgun barrel after clay shooting until gone and will not be replaced.