I had a different case before I bought this one. The other one I had, it was made out of silicon material and while it was thicker and felt more durable, it would always collect dust because the dust would stick to the material. I hated that, especially when I leave it in my purse and it collects all the dirty stuff on the bottom of my purse.
I really like this one. The material is really soft and it doesn't collect dust. I love the color and the material, while not as thick as the other one I had, still makes me feel confident about keeping my AirPods in it. I'd highly recommend this one! I've received so many compliments on it. I work at Apple and so many people don't realize there are covers for it and I've recommended this one to all of my colleagues.