So far I am extremely pleased. For the past 17.5 years we have used multiple other strainers that do not look as nice, or perform as well. I will include some pics of my old and the new strainers. These strainers have a curved edge that fits perfectly into the outermost circle of the drain (see pics) so they look like they should be there and will keep little bits from slipping under the strainer! The product description states that it has a mirror finish, that is very accurate.