This is the worst mascara I have ever purchased. Within an hour of applying the mascara it had already bled under my eyes, making it look like I had black eyes, and was flaking off, leaving black particles all over my face. Removing the mascara made me hate it even more, even after using make up remover I could still feel the mascara on my eyelashes. The mascara is also supposed to be waterproof, it did not hold up to a light sweat at the gym at all. I unknowingly walked around the gym with black eyes. Horrible purchase, save yourself the trouble and don't buy this product.