I received this in the same order as a Neutrogena eye make up remover. I decided to use each one at the same time, for the first time.( I was worried the covergirl wouldn't work, So I bought the Neutrogena one as a second) My right eye, covergirl, left eye, Neutrogena. I clearly saw a difference. The mascara all came off my lashes with one slow, steady wipe. The Neutrogena had mascara left, not a lot, in the outer-corner group of lashes...swiped slow and steady. I have blonde eyelashes (red hair) and wear a ton of eye makeup. So, I know the covergirl works awesome. As long as I can find it, its my new #1.