Top critical review
178 people found this helpful
3.0 out of 5 starsIt's Okay or Awesome, Depending on What You are Looking For
ByBlake Adamson July 26, 2014
I bought this book, having ready Kelly Starett's 'Supple Leopard' and looking for some other books on foundational fitness concepts. This is not it. I was expecting Mr. Paoli to lay out some basis for his choice of the four movements he considers important 'basic' movements. The pistol squat, handstand pushup, burpee, and muscle up are his foundational four...not a lot of logic behind these highly advanced movements, which the average person may never achieve, with the exception of burpees. So, let me hit the negative first...but, stay with me long enough to hear the positive.
Most people that are not CrossFit folks will find this a strange place to start. For the initiated CrossFitter, these are the pinnacle moves (minus pull-ups and double unders) that every athlete hopes to achieve. Pictures atop a kettlebell with a load overhead doing a pistol squat is the iconic CrossFit move. For the everyday fitness person looking to improve their general fitness, movements like the pistol squat, muscle up, and handstand pushup are not on their 'to do' list. These are very, very advanced movements that require significant practice to become proficient. Minus dancers, gymnasts, and children - attempting these movements will be very discouraging. They are true 'end range' movements that require significant strength and skill to accomplish well. Additionally, you will have to have access to rings, pirouettes, plyo boxes, etc to work on these, which the average person does not have at their local or home gym. So, from a foundational perspective, Free+Style falls short...it is a book for the advanced athlete, CrossFitter, or someone who is looking at the long game and wants to learn some challenging and new skills. Not only are these skills advanced movements, the last part of the book is about even more advanced movements you can add to our repertoire. If I can't get a pistol squat, I am not sure I am going to be doing a back flip.
So, what is good about it? After being initially disappointed, I started looking through the book and realized that there is a lot of great information and progressions to learn these movements. I have been working out for years and trying to learn a new skill every six months, which the muscle up, pistol squat, and handstand pushup have been on my list. As I looked through the book more, I found some great advice, insights, and detail about how to begin developing to learn these skills.
In the past few days, I have begun implementing the progressions into my 'skill day' workouts and I continue see progress in learning the pistol squat, handstand pushup, and muscle up. They are not easy - at 46, the range of motion, balance, strength, and skill these take are very difficult. But, as I am working on my mobility, I look at these as something I would like to achieve over the next year, not in the next few weeks.
I would have liked to see more of an introduction and in depth understanding of why these movements were chosen over other more accessible movements. But, from what I can tell, this book is primarily aimed at the CrossFit movement and hoping to capture some new audiences along the way. I would count myself in, with the understanding that these are not basic, nor easy. The book is laid out well, lots of great photos with detail shots, and for 30 plus dollars you get a pretty hefty book coming in at over 400 pages!