Amazon.com: Customer reviews: Rachael Ray Bakeware Nonstick Cookie Pan Set, 3-Piece, Gray with Agave Blue Grips

Top positive review

My "GO TO" Pans for almost everything I cook...LOVE THEM

Reviewed in the United States on August 7, 2016

I LOVE this Rachel Ray Oven Lovin’ Nonstick Pan Set. Couldn’t have named it better myself.

Some of the things I Love about them:
~~They 3 pc set offers me the perfect size option for my oven and cooking needs.
~~It comes as a three piece set—one 9X13, one 10X15, and an 11X17 pan.
~~ They stack inside of each other so they don’t take up extra space in my cabinet.
~~They are so versatile that I have used them for so many different things. Baking chicken or other meats that don’t require a deep pan for sauce, oven French fries, roasting vegetables, baking cookies, garlic bread and the list goes on…
~~Most foods do not stick to the pans. **When I cooked chicken legs in a really hot oven the skin did stick a bit but it still was ok.
~~ Oven Safe to 450 degrees.
~~Easy to clean because so far they truly are nonstick.
~~A portion of the proceeds go to a non-profit group called Yum-O.

These have become my “go to” pans for almost everything I cook in the oven. I highly recommend them!!!

27 people found this helpful

Top critical review

All critical reviews›

Patti

Don't waste your money!

Reviewed in the United States on February 17, 2017

I wanted to wait before I wrote my review...i bought these in September so here goes....dont waste another dime on anything but stainless steel....i always bake with parchment paper and the parts that weren't covered turned dark brown, you can't get it off! The orange rubber thingys on the handles keep coming off....the high reviews are either because they received the products free or discounted OR I received some sort of knock off. And it makes no difference to hand wash or use the dishwasher.

245 people found this helpful

Sort by

Filter by

18,272 global ratings | 2,460 global reviews

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

From the United States

Patti

Don't waste your money!

Reviewed in the United States on February 17, 2017

Color: Gray with Orange GripsPattern Name: SetVerified Purchase

245 people found this helpful

Helpful

Carla Lewis

Warps, Weak Coating, Looses Non-Stick

Reviewed in the United States on December 13, 2017

Color: Gray with Orange GripsPattern Name: SetVerified Purchase

I've only used the smaller pan six times. The inset silicone handles turned from a bright orange to a yucky brown. The non-stick coating worked well the first two times, but seems to have oxidized and turned brownish. The coating has started to turn brown on the back and chip off. The pan has only been hand washed. Lastly, they immediately warp as soon as they get hot.

168 people found this helpful

Helpful

Erica Hasser

Do Not Waste your Money!

Reviewed in the United States on November 4, 2019

Color: Gray with Agave Blue GripsPattern Name: SetVerified Purchase

Is this product serious? I was so excited for these baking sheets. First time using them I placed the small one in the oven, 2 minutes later.. seriously only 2 min. I heard a noise and looked into the oven to see my brand new baking sheet completely warped!!!!! Can’t anyone put out a decent product anymore instead of trying to rip people off!

87 people found this helpful

Helpful

Jason

Looks nice, but is it?

Reviewed in the United States on December 5, 2016

Color: Gray with Orange GripsPattern Name: SetVerified Purchase

I just received this pan an the the 3-Piece Baking and Cookie Pan Set of the same brand. My wife ordered these right after she tossed out my old "expensive' set because they had the yellow residue of cooking spray on them and they didn't look nice anymore.
As a former kitchen cook and engineer, here are my first impressions.
Pro's:
The pans feel nice, slick, not too thick or thin. They are aesthetically pleasing.
I haven't used much on them to see how they hold up to cooking various things. We shall see.

Con's:
The first thing i did was wash the factor chemicals off the set. I had read in the other reviews that these are prone to rusting. So I washed them by hand and left them to dry in the dish rack. In the morning I was to place them in storage and I immediately noted why these are prone to rusting. The curl around the outer lip was not sealed, i could hear water swishing around inside despite my best efforts to drain it. I will have to drill a drain hole to counter act this poor design. I can all be assure you that the coating was applied after the lip cure, so that means the inside will probably rust anyway. Right now I have the set in the oven to evaporate any moisture.

I will update this review after a month of use. Let's see if i add to t he list of Pro's or Con's?

334 people found this helpful

Helpful

Pans leak rusty water from silicon handles after washing.

Reviewed in the United States on December 4, 2017

Color: Gray with Orange GripsPattern Name: SetVerified Purchase

These are the most annoying pans I have ever owned. They come with an added "feature" of holding rusty water in a hidden compartment. Every time I pull them out of the diswasher, rusty water comes out from the silicon handles leaves an ugly brown water spots everywhere in the kitchen. I guess those people giving these 5 stars don't wash their pans.

91 people found this helpful

Helpful

yan

We've had these for about 6 months. The largest ...

Reviewed in the United States on April 20, 2018

Color: Gray with Orange GripsPattern Name: SetVerified Purchase

We've had these for about 6 months. The largest of the 3 pieces bends when used under normal heat. It comes back to its normal shape when it cools. It did this from the beginning, although it took us a while to use it and discover the problem. Also, when hand-washed, color drips from the orange plastic on the side, and the colored water has a metallic smell.

71 people found this helpful

Helpful

Joel

Buyer beware, awful product

Reviewed in the United States on May 29, 2019

Color: Gray with Orange GripsPattern Name: SetVerified Purchase

These are by far the worst non stick baking sheets we have ever owned. They are NOT non stick as advertised, everything we bake on it sticks, and is impossible to get out of the pan with out ruining the cookies or what ever in the process. These pans “Warp” in the oven even at low temperatures, 300-350, forget about it, they twist and do NOT lay flat. The rubber handles, well they are NOT heat resistant (see picture), and as far as easy cleaning, absolutely horrible, ( I have copper bottom pots and pans that look brand new after 30 years) these pans are only 5 years old, and they are going in the trash, can’t believe Rachel Ray put her name on such an awful product, wish I could get my money back, I even bought these for all our kids!

38 people found this helpful

Helpful

S. HYANS

Not good

Reviewed in the United States on September 12, 2017

Color: Gray with Orange GripsPattern Name: SetVerified Purchase

I bought these Feb 2017, it is now Sept 2017. Long story short, the non-stick coating is peeling off and sticking to the food. Yuck...keep shopping!

64 people found this helpful

Helpful

Amazon Customer

TRASH!

Reviewed in the United States on November 12, 2020

Color: Gray with Orange GripsPattern Name: SetVerified Purchase

I bought these pans in December 2017 after reading the reviews. For the first year of use, these pans held up well. They were non-stick, didn't rust, and I really liked the orange grip handles. With each use, I clean and dry before storage.

After 1.5 years of use, I noticed some rusting. The rusting started in the corners of the pan (the cooking side with the non-stick). I thought this was to be expected. There was also some rusting occurring underneath the lip of the pans. This was not to be expected.

From years 2-3, I still used these pans regularly and used the same procedures when storing (clean and dry). The rust was getting progressively worse. As you can see from the pictures (taken early 2020), the rust is progressing.

I've used generic brand and name brand pans for the past 20 years. I've never had to replace any pans after just 2-3 years of use!

I wrote to the Rachael Ray company directly from their website. I was very disappointed in the generic email response. My questions were not answered. In addition, they didn't answer my questions nor resolve the problems, but rather, they sent a 20% coupon (as a courtesy, of course(becasue they are do me a favor))! So instead of trying to resolve this problem, they want me to spend more of my money to buy more of their products. I don't think so! This company DOES NOT stand behind their products!