184 of 189 people found the following review helpful
This is a great movie...,
This review is from: Evita (DVD)
I just purchased this DVD and I remembered instantly why I enjoyed this film so much when it came out. I would just like to answer some of the critiques listed here.
1) The character of Ché was always meant to be a nemesis to Evita, but not the real character as such . In the stage production that I saw, it was a man with the typical beret and machine gun singing to the side of the action. It would have been ridiculous and historically inaccurate to portray Ché as such in the movie version. Ché Guevara was still a medical student when Eva died. I think it is very effective to blend Ché into various characters because it represents the silent and not so silent opposition to the Perón Revolution. The only time the two characters meet for real interaction is when Evita is having delusions. The song argued in that moment perfectly clashes Ché's "idealism" with Evita's "realism." Ché is always there in some form, yet Evita is oblivious to his presence, brushes him off with a quick lyric or purposely chooses to ignore him. This adds a metaphysical dimension to the plot as if Evita were increasingly self-justifying her growing power as a simple tool to help the impoverished.
2) The soundtrack to the movie is not an operatic stage version but the songs are presented using the operatic techniques of repetition. This was done on purpose, not due to a lack of creativity.
3) When I saw this off off broadway, the people that were with me were straining to understand the singing beside the fact that they had no idea about the history of post WWII Argentina. I don't think they enjoyed it as much as they wanted to let on.
4) Madonna sings very well and is completely understood. I had the argument with some friends that heard the soundtrack and thought she was singing off key on the last couple of tracks... Ummm. Not really. She was about ready to pass away in those scenes which in the movie are close-ups. It would have been ridiculous to have anyone belt out the lyrics in such an intimate moment before passing on. It sounds like she is dying, because she is...
5) The cinematography is simply amazing. The funeral scene at the very beginning was incredible as well as the scene where Eva puts her foundation to work. Pictures of the real Evita meeting the Pope and others perfectly match the costumes used in the movie.
6) For me, the main focus of the movie is the strategy of propaganda and how it can dominate reason. The mystery lies in how much of the persuasion was authentically from the heart of the Peróns and how much of it was naked manipulation. The movie captures both aspects and yet leaves them unanswered...Much like the historical analysis of Eva Perón.
This movie is an awesome production ...
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-5 of 5 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Apr 14, 2012 2:55:45 PM PDT
M Faire says:
Posted on Jun 17, 2012 5:40:24 PM PDT
[Deleted by the author on Jun 17, 2012 5:41:19 PM PDT]
Posted on Dec 17, 2014 10:13:02 AM PST
A note of clarification -- it is not Che Guevara portrayed in the movie. According to Bolivian friends of ours, "Che" is often used as a generic nickname for an "anonymous everyman" in South American culture, similar to "John Doe" or "Dude" or "Bro" in English. Rice and Webber simply used the nondescript name to identify the omnipresent narrator who provides background and exposition.
In reply to an earlier post on Jan 27, 2015 6:27:22 AM PST
Last edited by the author on Nov 9, 2015 9:04:52 AM PST
DJ Control says:
Great review R Glasgow! I love the movie because it's an Alan Parker film.
I'm sorry jks. Whilst what your Bolivian friends say may be true regarding generic nicknames the character of Ché in Evita IS based on Guevara. In the notes for the original stage show's libretto Tim Rice explains that the character, whilst not a part of the historical story is in fact based on the legendary revolutionary. It's on page 11 of the iTunes Evita - Musical Excerpts and complete libretto ebook. :)
In reply to an earlier post on Aug 30, 2015 12:47:27 AM PDT
J. Schofield says:
Cool. So like Che is saying "Dude, I can't find my revolution"?
‹ Previous 1 Next ›