I ordered the Goat/Dark Olive for my dad as a x-mas gift and I love them and so did he. After reading the review I ordered my dad's normal size and they fit perfectly. I am really impressed and excited about the look and quality of the boots! I am not super excited that the liner is not attached to the boot...but I guess it will be nice to take the liner out in the spring and summer. Super great boots, you can't go wrong with ordering them!