522 of 535 people found the following review helpful
As good as the Edirol R-09 for about half the price!,
This review is from: Zoom H2 Handy Portable Stereo Recorder (Electronics)
A year ago, I wrote a lengthy comparison of the Edirol R-09 WAVE/MP3 Recorder, Black and the Zoom H4 Handy Recorder + 2GB Accessory Kit (pre-accessory kit). I wanted a high quality, easy to use recorder, so even though the H4 had all of the features of the Edirol and sold for considerably less, I kept the Edirol because it was so much easier to use.
Zoom has responded with the H2, a scaled down version of the H4 with all of the features of the R-09 and all of the controls right where you need them. The H2 even has additional features over the R-09, but they don't get in the way. For example, there's a choice of a 90 degree recording pattern, a 120 degree recording pattern, and even a surround sound option. Samsontech has some nice video demonstrations on its website.
One big complaint I've had with the Edirol is the cost of its add-on stand. Unlike the Edirol, the H2 comes with a simple stand. In addition, the H2 has a threaded hole so that it can be mounted on a standard digital camera tripod! On a separate note, it's much easier to replace batteries with the H2 than the Edirol.
Recently, I got together with friends and recorded the same live acoustic music on both the Edirol R-09 and the Zoom H2. I used Adobe Audition only to normalize both tracks (that is, equalize their loudness). The first time we played them back, I thought I detected a VERY slight preference for the Edirol, with the overall opinion of the group split between the two units. The second time we played them back, my preference was for the H2, with overall opinion continuing to be split. We all agreed that the differences were so small as to be negligible if there were any at all. The sound files can be found at [...] for those who'd like to hear for themselves. We were sitting in a circle with the recorders located next to each other on a mantle above and outside the group.
I do prefer the Edirol's control buttons to the H2's membrane and I'm not about to sell the Edirol, perhaps because I am more familiar with the Edirol and don't want to give it up just yet. Also, the Edirol R-09 is the darling of the moment. However, if I owned neither, I couldn't justify the huge bump in price of the Edirol over the H2 and would opt for the H2. When I went to a music party last weekend and knew I'd need only one recorder, I grabbed the H2.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-5 of 5 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Dec 17, 2008 7:29:02 AM PST
Tammy L. Dickens says:
I have been researching these and pulling my hair out trying to decide which to buy for my musical teenage daughter. Your review was very helpful. Thank you for taking the time to write it!! I think she'll be very happy Christmas morning and I'm much happier with the price of the zoom!
Posted on Aug 21, 2010 7:42:58 AM PDT
Could anyone comment on how well this would work recording a presentation in a small (40-person) room, or even a large lecture hall (200-person)? Most of the commentary is in regards to instrument recording - would other products be more suitable for speech recording? Thank you.
Posted on Oct 15, 2010 3:12:30 AM PDT
What gear would you put together for a friend who wanted to record 2- and 3 person panel discussions (indoor quiet) or outside on quiet evenings .... with the H2 ... inexpensively and in no way a pro venture.
with the provision that person_1 could wear a wired mic, but person_2 and optional person_3 would want bluetooth mics (as the other wireless option while seeming better would break the bank on a not-for-profit application... tedious transcription later)
* unless there is a ~$50/mic wireless alternative to bluetooth (or bluetooth bridging). :gulp: .. $85?
In reply to an earlier post on Oct 15, 2010 5:23:42 AM PDT
I'm afraid you're asking the wrong guy if you're expecting a professional's advice. Here's what I'd do, but it's strictly juryrigging. I'd get an omnidirecdtional boundary mic and put it on a table so that everyone was about equidistant, or I'd even use the H2 in 2 channel mode, positioned so that no one was directly off to the side. I'd make my recording and then post process according to http://www.snn-rdr.ca/snn/nr_reporterstoo
Posted on Jul 13, 2011 6:09:10 AM PDT
Is there a good compressor built in, to avoid clipping in unpredictable environments?
‹ Previous 1 Next ›