553 of 583 people found the following review helpful
Deliberate practice "hurts but it works.",
This review is from: Talent Is Overrated: What Really Separates World-Class Performers from Everybody Else (Hardcover)
Colvin set out to answer this question: "What does great performance require?" In this volume, he shares several insights generated by hundreds of research studies whose major conclusions offer what seem to be several counterintuitive perspectives on what is frequently referred to as "talent." (See Pages 6-7.) In this context, I am reminded of Thomas Edison's observation that "vision without execution is hallucination." If Colvin were asked to paraphrase that to indicate his own purposes in this book, my guess (only a guess) is that his response would be, "Talent without deliberate practice is latent" and agrees with Darrell Royal that "potential" means "you ain't done it yet." In other words, there would be no great performances in any field (e.g. business, theatre, dance, symphonic music, athletics, science, mathematics, entertainment, exploration) without those who have, through deliberate practice developed the requisite abilities.
It occurs to me that, however different they may be in almost all other respects, athletes such as Cynthia Cooper, Roger Federer, Michael Jordan, Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Lorena Ochoa, Candace Parker, Michael Phelps, Vijay Singh, and Tiger Woods "make it look so easy" in competition because their preparation is so focused, rigorous, and thorough. Obviously, they do not win every game, match, tournament, etc. Colvin's point (and I agree) is that all great performers "make it look so easy" because of their commitment to deliberate practice, often for several years before their first victory. In fact, Colvin cites a "ten-year rule" widely endorsed in chess circles (attributed to Herbert Simon and William Chase) that "no one seemed to reach the top ranks of chess players without a decade or so of intensive study, and some required much more time." The same could also be said of "overnight sensations" who struggled for years to prepare for their "big break" on Broadway or in Hollywood.
Colvin duly acknowledges that deliberate practice "is a large concept, and to say that it explains everything would be simplistic and reductive." Colvin goes on to say, "Critical questions immediately present themselves: What exactly needs to be practiced? Precisely how? Which specific skills or other assets must be acquired? The research has revealed answers that generalize quite well across a wide range of fields." Even after committing all of my time and attention to several years of deliberate practice, under the direct supervision of the best instructor (e.g. Hank Haney, Butch Harman, or David Leadbetter) I probably could not reduce my handicap to zero but I could lower it under those conditions. Colvin's insights offer a reassurance that almost anyone's performance can be improved, sometimes substantially, even if it isn't world-class. Talent is overrated if it is perceived to be the most important factor. It isn't. In fact, talent does not exist unless and until it is developed...and the only way to develop it is (you guessed it) with deliberate practice. When Ben Hogan was asked the "secret" to playing great golf, he replied, "It's in the dirt."
Others have their reasons for thinking so highly of this book. Here are three of mine. First, Colvin's observations and suggestions are research-driven rather than based almost entirely on theories developed in isolation from real-world phenomena. He commits sufficient attention to identifying the core components of great performance but focuses most of his narrative to explaining how almost anyone can improve her or his own performance. He reveals himself to be both an empiricist as he shares what he has observed and experienced and a pragmatist who is curious to know what works, what doesn't, and why. I also appreciate Colvin's repudiation of the most common misconceptions about the various dimensions of talent. For example, that "is innate; you're born with it, and if you're not born with it, you can't acquire it." Many people still believe that Mozart was born with so much talent that he required very little (if any) development. In fact, according to Alex Ross, "Mozart became Mozart by working furiously hard" as did all others discussed, including Jack Welch, David Ogilvy, Warren Buffett, Robert Rubin, Jerry Rice, Chris Rock, and Benjamin Franklin. Some were prodigies but most were late-bloomers and each followed a significantly different process of development. About all they shared in common is their commitment to continuous self-improvement through deliberate practice.
Here's another reason I hold this book in such high regard. Throughout his narrative, Colvin inserts clusters of insights and recommendations that literally anyone can consider and then act upon to improve her or his individual performance as well as helping to improve the performance of a team of which she or he is a member. For example:
1. Attributes of deliberate practice (Pages 66-72)
2. What top performers perceive that others do not notice (Pages 89-94)
3. Benefits of having a "rich mental model"(Pages 123-124)
4. Rules for peak performance that "elite" organizations follow (Pages 128-136)
5. Misconceptions about innovation and creativity (Pages 149-151)
6. How innovators become great (Pages 159-161)
7. How to make organizations innovative (Pages 162-166)
8. What homes can teach organizations (Pages 172-175)
9. The "drivers" of great performance (Pages 187-193)
10. How some organizations "blow it" (Pages 194-198)
Colvin provides a wealth of research-driven information that he has rigorously examined and he also draws upon his own extensive and direct experience with all manner of organizations and their C-level executives. Throughout his narrative, with great skill, he sustains a personal rapport with his reader. It is therefore appropriate that, in the final chapter, he invokes direct address and poses a series of questions. "What would cause you to do the enormous work necessary to be a top-performing CEO, Wall Street trader, jazz, pianist, courtroom lawyer, or anything else? Would anything? The answer depends on your answers to two basic questions: What do you really want? And what do you really believe? What you want - really want - is fundamental because deliberate practice is a heavy investment." Corbin has provided all the evidence anyone needs to answer those two questions that, in fact, serve as a challenge.
Colvin leaves no doubt that by understanding how a few become great, anyone can become better...and that includes his reader. This reader is now convinced that talent is a process that "grows," not a pre-determined set of skills. Also, that deliberate practice "hurts but it works." Long ago, Henry Ford said, "Whether you think you can or think you can't, you're right." It would be "tragically constraining," Colvin asserts, for anyone to lack sufficient self-confidence because "what the evidence shouts most loudly is striking, liberating news: That great performance is not reserved for a preordained few. It is available to you and to everyone."
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-10 of 18 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Nov 23, 2008 4:52:17 AM PST
Robert - (Bob?), Thanks for a thorough and informative review. You convinced me to read the book. I'd be interested to hear if you've read Gene Landrum's books.
In reply to an earlier post on Nov 23, 2008 1:37:58 PM PST
Last edited by the author on Nov 23, 2008 1:45:00 PM PST
Robert Morris says:
Baz: Thanks for the comment.
Yes, I have read and then reviewed two of Landrum's books: Profiles of Genius and Profiles of Power and Success.
I plan to read and then review The Innovative Mind ASAP.
Best regards, Bob
In reply to an earlier post on Nov 23, 2008 4:38:45 PM PST
[Deleted by Amazon on Feb 2, 2013 2:50:22 PM PST]
Posted on Dec 5, 2008 12:16:43 AM PST
W. P. Danitz, Jr. says:
People are successful because they really WANT to be! Some people have a " Bent" ( a bit more talent or skill at whatever they are doing) toward whatever they happen to do, but if they love what they are doing and have a deep desire to do it they will be successful. The winner of any game is the person or team, who in their hearts really wants it most. Practice is essential to be the best. However, when you love what you do and have the deep desire to do it, thousands of hours of practice are not hard work. They are pure joy! Finding joy in what you do makes success!
In reply to an earlier post on Dec 5, 2008 9:47:21 AM PST
Robert Morris says:
You make an excellent point and remind me of Rod Steiger's response when asked about giving career advice to young people. "Oh yeh...sure, sure, sure. They come up to me all the time. I always look them in the eye and ask 'Do you want to be an actor or do you have to be an actor?' The longer it takes for them to answer, the less chance they'll make it." Thank you for sharing your comments.
Posted on Dec 11, 2008 9:45:57 AM PST
Fantastic review! If only all reviews were this well-written and informative!
Keep it up.
In reply to an earlier post on Dec 16, 2008 10:34:09 AM PST
Robert Speirs says:
In reply to an earlier post on Dec 19, 2008 10:32:16 PM PST
[Deleted by the author on Dec 19, 2008 11:10:11 PM PST]
In reply to an earlier post on Dec 26, 2008 10:59:14 AM PST
[Deleted by Amazon on Nov 16, 2009 3:02:48 PM PST]
Posted on Apr 4, 2009 6:55:17 AM PDT
Sandra B. G. says: