Amazon Vehicles Buy 2 kids' books and save Amazon Fashion Learn more Discover it Joseph Fire TV Stick Health, Household and Grocery Back to School Totes Summer-Event-Garden Amazon Cash Back Offer TheKicks TheKicks TheKicks  Amazon Echo  Echo Dot  Amazon Tap  Echo Dot  Amazon Tap  Amazon Echo Starting at $49.99 All-New Kindle Oasis Celine Dion Water Sports
Customer Review

14 of 17 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Were the Blues Invented in a Brooklyn YMCA?, December 26, 2008
This review is from: In Search of the Blues (Hardcover)
In her book, "Inventing the Blues" (2008), Marybeth Hamilton advances the provocative claim that the blues, more specifially tbe Delta Blues, is a form of music created in large part by the imaginations of white men. I do not find her argument compelling, to say the least. Nevertheless, I found this book worth reading for the story it tells about how various individuals pioneered in the study of the blues beginning early in the 20th Century to the revival of interest in blues music in the 1960s. Although her book is unconvincing and even infuriating in some respects, it is valuable for those readers with an interest in the blues. Hamilton, born in California, teaches American history at Birkbeck College, University of London, and has written other books on aspects of American popular culture.

Early in her book, (p.22) Hamilton says she is not going to cover the development of the Delta Blues as a musical style by analyzing the songs of Charlie Patton, Son House, Robert Johnson and other bluesmen. She points to Robert Palmer's study "Deep Blues" as among the works that have explored the music. Instead, Hamilton proposed to show how her central characters, all of whom are white, "set out to find an undiluted and primal black music." Hamilton then asks what it was that drove these indivduals to think that an "undiluted and primal black" music existed and why it was important to these individuals to find it. The way Hamilton frames her question largely presupposes her result. The works of Palmer and other writers such as Ted Gioia in his excellent recent study "Delta Blues" examine the blues by looking at the blues, bluesmen and blueswomen. Hamilton will have little of this and begins with the assumption that the blues was somehow a conceptual creation of whites. Hamilton finds the need for this conceptualization in the racial attitudes and segregation prevailing in the United States up through at least the 1950's. Late in the book, Hamilton introduces another theme. She finds the Delta blues largely a sexist creation by men who were uncomfortable with their masculinity and worried about evolving ideas of gender and egalitarianism. (see pp 240-243).

Each of the five major characters Hamilton discusses is well described. Hamilton offers good insight into how the blues were found, in spite of her hyperbolic claim that the blues were invented. She describes the work of the early sociologist, Howard Odum who early in has career travelled in the byways of lumber camps and out of the way fields in the rural South to hear and record on primitive equipment the frequently obscene hollers and calls of laborers and field hands. Hamilton spends a great deal of time on pioneering work of John Lomax, who discovered Leadbelly in a Louisiana prison. She explores John Lomax's racial attitudes and offers a personal portrayal of him through love letters he wrote to a woman named Ruby Terrill. Lomax's son Alan also figures largely in the story as he tried to move away from his father's racial prejudices. Alan Lomax was instrumental in the rediscovery of Jelly Roll Morton as Hamilton points out. She underplays his role in the 1940s in recording and preserving the work of Deltabluesmen Muddy Waters and Son House.

Of Hamilton's characters, two are infrequently associated with the blues, and it was worth learning about them in the book. Dorothy Scarborough was a highly-educated woman whose parents had been active in the Confederacy. While living and teaching in New York City, she conceived the idea of studying black music. She travelled south and interviewed many people, mostly the descendants of white plantation owners but some black musicians as well. In 1925, she wrote a book "On the Trail of Negro Folk Songs". Hamilton points out that this book is little read today due to its racial stereotyping. But I think Hamilton is correct that this book has much to teach about early black music.

The fourth group of charactrs Hamilton discusses are William Russell, Frederick Ramsey, and Charles Smith who became enamored of New Orleans jazz and of the fabled Storyville district. They published an early study of jazz called "Jazzmen" in 1937 which seemed to conflate jazz and the blues and to find the heart of black music in the urban area of New Orleans rather than in the fields and rural areas that the Lomaxes, Odum, and Scarborough explored.

The final characters explored in the book are the record collectors of the 1940s. in particular a lonely and puzzling figure named James McKune. McKune lived in poverty and obscurity for 25 years in a Brooklyn YMCA amassing a collection of race records that he stored in a cardboard box under his bed. As McKune delved into what was then obscure music, he developed a passion for what we now know as the Delta bluesmen, especially for Charlie Patton. Slowly, a small group of collectors coalesced around McKune and shared his interest in this music. In the early 1960s, pioneering reissues of Delta blues music based upon McKune's collection were issued by small record labels and scholars and enthusiasts, in the United States and Britain, began to take note. McKune himself, bedeveled by problems with alcohol, sex, and mental health, was the victim of a bizarre murder in 1971, long after he had lost interest in the Delta blues. McKune, with has fantasies, loneliness and obsessions, Hamilton argues "invented" the Delta blues. Hamilton describes this "invention"

"the blues revival stands alongside the Beat movement as an opening movement of ... the 'male flight from committment' that percolated through postwar American culture. What united both movement was their almost exclusively male constituency and their romance with outsider manhood, with defiant black men who seemed to scorn the suburban breadwinner's stiffling, soul-destroying routine." (p. 241)

I don't see anything in this analysis that supports the conclusion that McKune and his fellow-collectors "invented" the Delta blues. Palmer and others have shown there was a music there to be discovered. Other scholars such as Elijah Wald in "Escaping the Delta" have shown how much other forms of black music influenced the Delta blues. But the influence of other styles of music in the Delta hardly shows that the genre was somehow conceptualized and invented by white fans.

In his book, "Delta Blues" which I mentioned earlier, Ted Gioia takes issue with Hamilton's portrayal of McKune's role. He writes:

"Perhaps it would have been better for academics such as Hamilton to take the lead on this process during these years of neglect-- although other fears and obsessions might have emerged in this case. But the issue is moot: college professors had no interest in the blues at this time. Moreover, the record collectors were the only people who had access to this music, most of which was available solely on the original 78s in which it had first been presented to the public. As such, we must temper our critcism of these enthusiasts with at least a measure of gratitude for the music they were able to track down, preserve, and share with those open-minded enought to appreciate its virtues." (Gioia p. 349)

Although her primary claim in this book lacks support, Hamilton has written a valuable account of the individuals who pursued their passion for the blues and made this music available to all Americans.

Robin Friedman
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

[Add comment]
Post a comment
To insert a product link use the format: [[ASIN:ASIN product-title]] (What's this?)
Amazon will display this name with all your submissions, including reviews and discussion posts. (Learn more)
This badge will be assigned to you and will appear along with your name.
There was an error. Please try again.
Please see the full guidelines here.

Official Comment

As a representative of this product you can post one Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
The following name and badge will be shown with this comment:
 (edit name)
After clicking the Post button you will be asked to create your public name, which will be shown with all your contributions.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.  Learn more
Otherwise, you can still post a regular comment on this review.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
System timed out

We were unable to verify whether you represent the product. Please try again later, or retry now. Otherwise you can post a regular comment.

Since you previously posted an Official Comment, this comment will appear in the comment section below. You also have the option to edit your Official Comment.   Learn more
The maximum number of Official Comments have been posted. This comment will appear in the comment section below.   Learn more
Prompts for sign-in


Track comments by e-mail

Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-3 of 3 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Jan 11, 2009 5:40:28 PM PST
I liked your review, I will probably buy/read this book. However I can't understand your praise of Ted Gioia's book Delta blues. I am trying to read it now, am half way through and have read nothing new. He must have gotten paid by the word because he uses a lot of words to say very little. He will cite a comment by some blues character then go off speculating for two or three pages. It is beyond simple passion for the blues, it boarders on creative writing. Perhaps "Inventing the Blues" is what is needed. I have read many books on this topic and yes they are filled with passion for the material and not necessarily scholarly.

In reply to an earlier post on Aug 19, 2014 11:09:47 AM PDT
Joseph Scott says:
"I liked your review, I will probably buy/read this book. However I can't understand your praise of Ted Gioia's book Delta blues." Oh man! Anyone who noticed Gioia's book was only mediocre would hate Hamilton's far less substantive and more misguidedly creative book.

Posted on Mar 5, 2015 2:06:32 PM PST
Last edited by the author on Mar 5, 2015 4:01:09 PM PST
Joseph Scott says:
"Were the Blues Invented in a Brooklyn YMCA?" Were the "delta blues" invented in a Brooklyn YMCA, the reviewer meant there. No. Alan Lomax was already promoting the idea of delta blues as special in at least one book and two periodicals as of 1947-1948. (The fact that _he_ had recorded in the Yazoo-Mississippi Delta in 1941-1942, rather than in e.g. Alabama, may have affected his opinion there.) If there is one inventor of the idea that "delta blues" (blues from the Yazoo-Mississippi Delta) are specialer than other blues, it's A. Lomax, not Brooklyn's J. McKune, who began writing columns about music in 1960. Howard Odum and Antonio Maggio both encountered black blues music in the South during the 1905-1908 period. (One of the blues Odum encountered, in Georgia, is the 12-bar "Knife-Song.") People began talking about blues music as a genre in about 1909, and blues music became popular with blacks and whites, but especially blacks... with blacks _not_ identifying the Yazoo-Mississippi Delta as somehow a particularly important region for blues during 1918-1947, or buying their blues records accordingly. (For instance, some of the most popular blues artists with blacks during 1945-1947 were Louis Jordan, Cleanhead Vinson, Joe Liggins, Julia Lee, and Charles Brown, none of whom was from the Yazoo-Mississippi Delta.) The guy Robert Johnson learned to play guitar well from, Ike Zimmerman, wasn't from the Delta. The guy Son House learned slide from, Rube Lacy, wasn't from the Delta. The real Sonny Boy Williamson, whom A. Lomax publicized as from the Delta, wasn't from the Delta. "Mississippi" Fred McDowell learned to play in Tennessee. Skip James wasn't from the Delta. The bluesman Hacksaw Harney, born the same year as Son House, was from the Delta, and didn't play like Charlie Patton because he hadn't got the memo from whites such as A. Lomax that he would for some reason.

Contrary to what some books handwave, the black folk songs from Mississippi that Charles Peabody published in 1903 are no more bluesy than the black folk songs the Thomas brothers of Texas encountered before him or the black folk songs Anne Hobson of Alabama published in 1903. The earliest known publication of a partly 12-bar "Blues" was in Louisiana. The earliest known reference in print to blues as a type of music, describing a different tune, is also from Louisiana. The "delta blues" myth _is_ a myth, but Hamilton is way, way over her head trying to tell anyone how.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›

Review Details



Robin Friedman

Location: Washington, D.C. United States