29 of 32 people found the following review helpful
Room for Improvement,
This review is from: The RSpec Book: Behaviour Driven Development with RSpec, Cucumber, and Friends (Facets of Ruby) (Paperback)
I hate to be the first one to give a less than great review of this book, especially since several of the authors are chiefly responsible for these great testing tools to be in existence. But I'd probably be even harder on the book than I am if I knew of a good alternative, which I don't. So best I can tell, this is still the best book to learn BDD using RSpec and Cucumber.
There seems to be a fair amount of errata that didn't get fixed prior to going to print. In fact, the book on whole seems like it could have used more in the editing process. I question the organization of the book; however I do get a sense of what the authors were trying to accomplish.
I am sympathetic to the challenges of writing a book for technologies that are very rapidly changing; that said, at a conference in June 2010, the author had already switched to using Capybara instead of Webrat, so I was shocked that the book went to print in December 2010 without mention of Capybara, which from what I can tell, seems to be the new de facto standard for browser simulation.
No doubt BDD while easy to understand at an abstract level, seems to be an art hard to explain concretely. Surely examples are the best way to learn, and fortunately this book does use plenty of examples. I love that they devote 100 pages specifically to BDD in Rails (although I'm sure developers using other languages and frameworks don't). I'd say this edition of the book is a good 0.8 release, and I look to the inevitable 1.0 (aka 2nd Edition).