These are wonderful small treats that my dog has been eating for quite a while now. She loves the flavor and I feel like they don't add too many calories to her diet. The only problem we have now with them is that they seem to be difficult for her to chew but that's because of her age not because of these treats. They are very dry and crumchy which she used to love, but we have noticed she's having some trouble with that kind of chewing lately. So, for a young dog that you are training, these are great treats.