"Cute / tacky felt gets the job done, but don't expect high quality for $10..."
So, you have to look at the price. What you pay for is what you get, and this $10 toilet seat cover is exactly what I expected. Cutesy, cheap, and a bit tacky (or more than a bit tacky? I can't tell where the line is between tacky and cute, honestly.) And how long does it have to last, realistically?
I bought this as one of my pranks for my Christmas Prank Advent in my house, and this totally gets the job done. The people with more refined decor tastes in my house will be provoked, and I will laugh!
Four stars because it is what it is.